Psychology › Section J · Emotion and motivation › Topic J.3
Sexual behavior, sexuality, and gender identity
Sexual motivation, sexual orientation and gender identity are three different parts of who people are, and mixing them up causes real confusion and harm. This topic covers what research has found about each, using the current, respectful terms psychologists use.
More than reproduction
From an evolutionary view, sexual motivation exists because it leads to reproduction. Human sexuality, though, also involves pleasure, intimacy, identity and culture. Psychologists study three related but separate questions: what drives sexual behaviour, whom a person is attracted to, and what a person's inner sense of their own gender is. Keeping these apart is the main skill of this topic. Like hunger, sexual motivation depends on the hypothalamus and hormones, while learning and culture shape its expression.
The biology of sexual motivation
Much of the biological evidence comes from animal studies. In male rats, damage to the medial preoptic area of the hypothalamus abolishes the ability to mate, yet the animals still work hard to reach a receptive female. Damage to the amygdala or the nucleus accumbens, part of the reward system, does the reverse: motivation drops while the ability remains. Female rats show similar dissociations, so wanting and ability rely partly on different brain systems. In many animals sexual behaviour depends on gonadal hormones; in humans the link is looser, but testosterone levels are related to sexual desire in people of all genders.
Two landmark research programmes
Alfred Kinsey at Indiana University interviewed thousands of Americans and published reports on men (1948) and women (1953). He found that sexual behaviours once thought rare, including same-sex experiences, were fairly common, and he described orientation on a continuum, the Kinsey scale. His volunteer samples were unrepresentative, so his percentages are unreliable. William Masters and Virginia Johnson (1966) instead measured bodily responses directly in the laboratory. They described a sexual response cycle of four phases: excitement, plateau, orgasm and resolution, often followed by a refractory period. Later researchers, such as Rosemary Basson, argued that desire does not always come first and may follow arousal and closeness.
Sexual orientation
Sexual orientation is a person's lasting pattern of emotional, romantic or sexual attraction to people of a particular gender, to more than one gender, or to no one. Common terms include heterosexual (straight), gay, lesbian, bisexual (attraction to more than one gender), pansexual (attraction regardless of gender) and asexual (little or no sexual attraction). Aromantic people experience little or no romantic attraction, which is a separate dimension. LGBTQ+ is an umbrella abbreviation; the plus sign stands for other identities. People choose the label that fits them, or none. In Gallup's 2024 survey, about 9% of US adults identified as LGBTQ+, with much higher shares among younger adults.
What shapes orientation
Researchers once assumed that orientation came from upbringing, but studies have found that the family backgrounds of gay, lesbian and heterosexual people are broadly similar. Twin studies suggest a moderate genetic influence. A 2019 study of nearly half a million people found many genetic variants, each with a very small effect, and no single "gay gene". The scientific consensus is that orientation is not a choice and is not changed by therapy. Conversion therapy, any attempt to change a person's orientation or gender identity, has no credible evidence of working and is linked to harm, including depression; the American Psychological Association and other bodies oppose it.
Gender identity
Sex assigned at birth is the label given at birth, usually from external anatomy. Gender identity is a person's inner sense of their own gender: woman, man, both, neither, or another gender. Gender expression is how someone shows gender through clothing, voice or behaviour. A cisgender person's gender identity matches their assigned sex; for a transgender person, the two differ. Nonbinary people do not identify solely as a woman or a man. Intersex people are born with sex traits, such as chromosomes, hormones or anatomy, that differ from typical male or female patterns; intersex is not the same as transgender. Gender identity is also separate from sexual orientation.
Gender dysphoria and transition
Not all transgender people feel distress about their bodies, but some experience gender dysphoria: significant distress or difficulty caused by a mismatch between gender identity and sex assigned at birth. The DSM-5-TR lists it as a diagnosis requiring at least six months of symptoms and clear distress or impairment. The label is debated; in the ICD-11, adopted in 2019, the World Health Organization moved "gender incongruence" out of the mental disorders chapter into one on sexual health. This is for understanding only: assessment is a clinician's job. Some transgender people transition socially (name, pronouns, presentation), legally (documents) or medically, and some do none of these.
Worked example: keeping the concepts apart
Ana was assigned male at birth, is a woman, often wears jeans and trainers, and is attracted to women. Describe her using the terms correctly. 1. Sex assigned at birth: male. 2. Gender identity: woman. Because it differs from her assigned sex, she is a transgender woman. 3. Gender expression: casual, and it does not change her identity; clothing never defines gender identity. 4. Sexual orientation: attraction to women, so she may describe herself as lesbian, or choose another term. 5. Check: each answer came from a different question; knowing that Ana is transgender told us nothing about whom she is attracted to.
Worked example: the David Reimer case
In 1966 a Canadian baby boy's penis was destroyed in a botched circumcision. Psychologist John Money, who argued that gender identity is set mainly by upbringing in early childhood, advised raising the child as a girl. Money reported the case as a success. Analyse it. 1. The prediction: if rearing determines gender identity, the child should identify as a girl. 2. The outcome: the child never felt like a girl, learned the history at 14 and chose to live as a man, David Reimer. 3. The flaw: Money's reports left out evidence that contradicted his theory. 4. Conclusion: rearing alone did not determine gender identity in this case, though one case cannot settle how biology and environment combine.
Culture and gender
A society that treats heterosexuality as the default is called heteronormative, and one that assumes everyone's gender matches their assigned sex is cisnormative. Many societies have long recognised more than two genders. The Bugis people of Sulawesi in Indonesia describe five, including the bissu, who hold ritual roles. In South Asia, hijra communities have a recorded history of centuries. Two-Spirit is a modern umbrella term used by some Indigenous people in North America for traditional gender roles in their nations. Recognition does not guarantee safety: such groups, like LGBTQ+ people generally, still face stigma and discrimination in many places.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating sexual orientation and gender identity as the same thing: one is about attraction, the other about a person's own gender. Second, assuming gender expression reveals identity or orientation, or confusing intersex with transgender. Third, calling orientation a "lifestyle" or "preference", which wrongly implies a choice. Fourth, trusting Kinsey's percentages as population figures. Fifth, assuming every transgender person has gender dysphoria, or using DSM criteria to label anyone; that is for qualified clinicians. Sixth, saying "the gay gene": the evidence points to many genes with small effects.
Key takeaways
Sexual motivation involves the hypothalamus, reward areas and hormones, with wanting and ability partly separable. Kinsey's interviews and Masters and Johnson's four-phase response cycle founded sex research, with known limits. Orientation concerns attraction, is not a choice, and is not changed by conversion therapy, which causes harm. Gender identity is separate from expression, orientation and intersex traits. Gender dysphoria is a debated diagnosis for clinicians only. The Reimer case and many cultures' multiple genders show gender is not simply taught.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Hypothalamic region needed in rats for the ability to mate
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Male rats with damage to the medial preoptic area cannot mate but still work hard to reach a receptive female. What does this suggest?
Question 2 of 5
How did Masters and Johnson's research method differ from Kinsey's?
Question 3 of 5
Jordan is a cisgender man who is attracted to men and women. Which statement uses the terms correctly?
Question 4 of 5
What does current scientific evidence say about conversion therapy?
Question 5 of 5
What is the most justified conclusion from the David Reimer case?
