Psychology › Section N · Stress, lifestyle, and health › Topic N.3

Stress and illness

The stress response evolved to get us through a few minutes of danger, yet many people run it for months over bills, jobs and relationships. This topic follows the evidence on what that does to the immune system, the heart, the lungs and even our cells.

An emergency system left switched on

The neuroscientist Robert Sapolsky has argued that most stress-related disease comes from a mismatch. The fight-or-flight and HPA responses from the earlier stress topics are built for short physical emergencies, but humans can trigger them for weeks with worry alone. Kept running, the response causes cumulative wear: blood pressure that stays raised strains the heart and blood vessels, and cortisol that stays high weakens immune defences. Bruce McEwen called this accumulated cost allostatic load. Think of an engine kept at high revs in neutral: no single minute does much harm, but months of it wear out the parts.

Psychophysiological disorders

Psychophysiological disorders are physical illnesses whose symptoms psychological factors such as stress and emotion help bring on or make worse. The symptoms are entirely real: the name means the mind (psycho) acts through the body's physiology, not that the illness is imagined. Examples include hypertension and coronary heart disease, irritable bowel syndrome, asthma, tension headaches and low back pain, and eczema and psoriasis. Psychological factors are rarely the only cause; genes, infections and behaviour matter too. Reviews have also linked lasting negative states, such as depression, chronic anxiety and hostility, with more illness and earlier death.

The immune system and psychoneuroimmunology

The immune system is the body's defence network against bacteria, viruses and other invaders. It can fail in two directions. In autoimmune diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis or lupus, it attacks the body's own tissue. In immunosuppression, it is weakened and infections take hold more easily. Psychoneuroimmunology, named in a 1981 book edited by Robert Ader, studies how psychological factors affect immunity. In a striking early study, Ader and Nicholas Cohen (1975) gave rats sweetened water paired with a drug that suppresses immunity; later, the sweet taste alone suppressed their immune response. Immunity had been classically conditioned, revealing a direct brain-immune link.

How stress weakens immune defences

Hundreds of studies have tied stressors, from exams to divorce, unemployment and long-term caregiving, to weaker immune function. The pathways are physical. Sympathetic nerves reach immune organs such as the spleen and lymph nodes, and cortisol from the HPA axis reduces the production of lymphocytes, the white blood cells central to immune responses. The effects show up in real outcomes. Older adults caring for a spouse with dementia made fewer antibodies after a flu jab than similar adults without that burden, and small skin wounds healed more slowly in people under high stress. Stress rarely causes infection directly; it lowers the body's guard.

Worked example: reading a cold-virus experiment

Sheldon Cohen and colleagues (1998) asked 276 healthy volunteers about recent stress, then gave them nasal drops containing a cold virus and monitored them in quarantine. 1. Timing: stress was recorded before exposure, so illness could not have caused the reported stress. 2. Control: everyone received the same virus in the same way. 3. Result: people with chronic stressors lasting a month or more, especially at work or in relationships, were more likely to develop colds, and risk rose with longer stressors. 4. Limit: stress was measured, not randomly assigned, so a third factor such as poor sleep could contribute. Check: the design supports a causal link far better than a survey, but it is not a true experiment.

Stress and ageing cells

Telomeres are protective DNA caps on the ends of chromosomes. They shorten as cells divide, so their length is one marker of cellular ageing. A widely cited study by Elissa Epel, Elizabeth Blackburn and colleagues (2004) compared mothers caring for a chronically ill child with mothers of healthy children. The more years of caregiving, and the more stress a mother reported, the shorter her telomeres tended to be. Later studies have linked childhood adversity, such as abuse, with shorter telomeres too. The findings are correlational and the mechanisms are still being studied, but they suggest chronic stress may speed biological ageing.

Stress and the heart: from Type A to hostility

Heart disease is the leading cause of death in the United States, and hypertension, called the silent killer because it usually has no symptoms, is a major risk factor. Job strain, marital conflict, perceived discrimination and chronic noise have all been linked to raised blood pressure. In the 1950s the cardiologists Meyer Friedman and Ray Rosenman described the Type A behaviour pattern: competitive, impatient, hurried and hostile, unlike relaxed Type B. Early studies found more heart disease in Type A people, but later, larger studies often failed to replicate this. When researchers pulled the pattern apart, anger and hostility carried most of the risk.

Worked example: a hostility cycle

A transactional model proposes that hostility and social strain feed each other. Marcus assumes colleagues are trying to undermine him. 1. Thought: he reads a delayed reply as a deliberate snub. 2. Behaviour: he sends a sharp, accusing email. 3. Response: the colleague replies coldly and starts avoiding him. 4. Feedback: the cold reply confirms his belief, so he grows more suspicious and hostile. 5. Body: each tense exchange raises his heart rate and blood pressure, many times a week. Check: the model shows how a personality trait becomes repeated physical stress responses, one way hostility may raise cardiovascular risk.

Depression, negative emotion and the heart

Folklore has long linked sorrow and the heart, and research supports a real connection running both ways. Depression is more common among heart patients than in the wider public, and depressed people are more likely to develop heart disease and to die of it, with risk rising as depression deepens. The American Heart Association now treats depression as a risk factor for poorer outcomes in heart disease. Likely pathways include inflammation, stress hormones and behaviour such as smoking and inactivity. Negative affectivity, a general tendency towards anger, fear and guilt, is also linked to hypertension and heart disease.

Asthma and tension headaches

Asthma is a chronic disease in which inflamed airways narrow, causing wheezing, coughing and breathlessness. Most attacks are triggered by allergens, smoke, pollution, infections, cold air or exercise, but emotional stress is a common trigger for some people. Studies tracking adults with asthma through the day link high stress and negative emotion with worse airway function, and some people develop symptoms simply because they expect to. Tension headaches, the most common type, involve tight muscles in the head and neck. Poor sleep, skipped meals and eye strain contribute, and stress seems to add to them by raising sensitivity to pain.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling psychophysiological illnesses imaginary: the symptoms are real and physical. Second, claiming stress directly causes infections: it weakens defences, and a pathogen is still needed. Third, treating correlational findings, such as the telomere studies, as proof of cause. Fourth, saying Type A personality causes heart attacks: the overall pattern failed to replicate, and hostility is the risky part. Fifth, assuming stress is the only cause: genes, infections and behaviour matter too. Sixth, ignoring behaviour as a pathway: stressed people often sleep, eat and exercise worse.

Key takeaways

Chronic activation of the stress response causes cumulative wear, or allostatic load. Psychophysiological disorders are real physical illnesses that psychological factors help cause or worsen. Psychoneuroimmunology shows the brain influences immunity, as Ader and Cohen's conditioned rats revealed; stress lowers defences through cortisol and sympathetic nerves. Chronic stressors raised cold risk in Cohen's virus study, and stress is linked to shorter telomeres. Hostility, not the overall Type A pattern, predicts heart disease, as do depression and negative affectivity. Stress can trigger asthma and worsen tension headaches. This topic is for learning only: anyone worried about their health should talk to a qualified professional.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Allostatic load

Cumulative wear on the body from repeated or chronic stress responses

Bruce McEwen's term.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which statement about psychophysiological disorders is correct?

Question 2 of 5

In Ader and Cohen's 1975 study, rats came to show immune suppression after drinking only sweetened water. What did this show?

Question 3 of 5

In Cohen's 1998 cold-virus study, why does measuring stress before giving the virus matter?

Question 4 of 5

What did later research conclude about the Type A behaviour pattern and heart disease?

Question 5 of 5

Which is the best description of how chronic stress usually affects infection?

← Previous topicNext topic →