Psychology › Section M · Industrial-organizational psychology › Topic M.1

What is industrial-organizational psychology?

Most adults spend more of their waking hours at work than anywhere else, so how people are hired, led and equipped matters enormously. Industrial-organisational psychology studies that world, and its history runs from army testing to the factory floor.

Psychology at work

A full-time worker in the United States spends roughly 40 or more hours a week on the job, more than on any other waking activity. Work shapes income, health, friendships and identity, and in turn people's abilities, attitudes and relationships shape how well organisations run. Industrial-organisational (I-O) psychology is the branch of psychology that studies how human behaviour affects work and how work affects people. The topic on contemporary psychology introduced it as an applied specialty; this topic sets out its areas and history, and the next three take each area in turn.

Three areas of I-O psychology

The field has three broad areas. Industrial psychology, sometimes called personnel psychology, describes what jobs require and matches people to them: job analysis, selection, training and performance appraisal. It must also make sure hiring is fair and legal. Organisational psychology studies the social side of work: job satisfaction, motivation, commitment, leadership, teams, organisational culture, and problems such as harassment. Human factors psychology studies how people interact with tools, machines and systems, and designs them for safety, efficiency and comfort, from an office chair to an aircraft cockpit. In Europe and elsewhere this area is often called ergonomics.

Where I-O psychologists work

I-O psychologists work in four main settings: universities, government (including the military), consulting firms and businesses. Most hold a master's degree or a doctorate. In the United States their professional body is the Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology (SIOP), which is Division 14 of the American Psychological Association. Two newer branches extend the field. Occupational health psychology studies how work causes stress, illness and injury, and how to make jobs healthier, including the spillover between work and home life. Humanitarian work psychology, which emerged as an organised field around 2009, applies I-O methods to poverty, disaster relief and helping marginalised people develop skills for decent work.

Early pioneers

The field began in the early twentieth century, and several founders had trained with Wilhelm Wundt. Walter Dill Scott applied psychology to advertising in books from 1903, and later to selecting salespeople. Hugo Münsterberg's Psychology and Industrial Efficiency (1913) covered employee selection, training and advertising, and argued that psychological tests could match people to jobs. James McKeen Cattell founded the Psychological Corporation in 1921, a firm that sold psychological testing services to businesses. These early researchers worked as consultants as well as academics, a pattern the field still follows. Their focus was what we now call industrial psychology; organisational psychology grew up later.

Testing an army

When the United States entered the First World War in 1917, Robert Yerkes, then president of the American Psychological Association, led a team that built group tests to screen recruits. The Army Alpha was a written test of mental ability; the Army Beta used pictures and demonstrations for men who could not read or did not speak English. About 1.75 million men were tested. Walter Dill Scott and Walter Bingham built rating and placement systems for officers. The project showed that testing could work on a vast scale, but historians argue that the tests were culturally biased and that their results were misused in the 1920s to support claims about racial and ethnic differences and to justify restricting immigration.

Scientific management and motion study

Frederick Taylor, an engineer, argued in The Principles of Scientific Management (1911) that managers should study each task scientifically, find the one best way to do it, select and train workers to that method, and pay by output. His time-and-motion studies broke jobs into measured steps. Output often rose, but critics, including unions, said the approach treated workers as interchangeable parts, gave all judgement to managers and ignored wellbeing. Lillian Gilbreth, an engineer and psychologist, worked with her husband Frank on cutting wasted motions, but she also studied fatigue and workers' satisfaction. Her book The Psychology of Management (1914) brought people back into the picture, and in 1966 she became the first woman to receive the Hoover Medal, which honours engineers' public service.

Worked example: the Hawthorne studies

From about 1924 to 1932, researchers studied workers at Western Electric's Hawthorne Works near Chicago, later joined by Elton Mayo's Harvard group. Analyse the studies as cause and effect. 1. The question: does better lighting raise output? 2. The puzzle: output reportedly rose in test groups whatever the lighting change, even when light was dimmed. 3. The researchers' interpretation: attention, supervision and group relations mattered more than physical conditions, which turned research towards social factors and helped found organisational psychology. 4. The legacy: the Hawthorne effect, a change in behaviour because people know they are being studied, became a standard concern in research design. 5. Current status: reanalyses of surviving data, such as one in 2011, found the original lighting effects weaker than the legend claims.

Groups, leaders and fair testing

In the late 1930s Kurt Lewin, often called the founder of modern social psychology, and his students compared boys' clubs run by autocratic, democratic and laissez-faire adult leaders, finding differences in atmosphere, aggression and productivity. Lewin also coined the term group dynamics. In the Second World War, Bingham led the US Army's personnel testing and classification. After the war, research on job satisfaction and motivation grew. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII) banned job discrimination based on race, colour, religion, sex or national origin, and in Griggs v. Duke Power Co. (1971) the Supreme Court ruled that hiring requirements that screen out one group must be shown to be job-related. Fair, valid testing became central to the field.

Worked example: one problem, three areas

A hospital call centre loses half its new staff within a year. Show how each area of I-O psychology would investigate. 1. Industrial: is the job analysis accurate, do selection tests predict who stays and performs well, and is training adequate before staff take calls? 2. Organisational: are supervisors supportive, are workloads fair, and what do satisfaction surveys and exit interviews show about culture and stress? 3. Human factors: are the headsets, screens and booking software easy to use, or do confusing displays cause errors and frustration? 4. Combine: the causes may lie in more than one area, so solutions might include better screening, leadership training and redesigned software. 5. Check: each question belongs to exactly one area, as defined earlier.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating I-O psychology as just human resources paperwork: it is a research science that tests whether its methods work. Second, mixing up the areas: selection and appraisal are industrial; satisfaction and leadership are organisational; equipment and display design are human factors. Third, telling the Hawthorne story as settled fact; the original data are weaker than the legend. Fourth, assuming early mass testing was neutral: the army tests were culturally biased and misused. Fifth, crediting Taylor with a concern for worker wellbeing, which was Gilbreth's contribution more than his. Sixth, forgetting that law, such as Title VII, shapes what selection methods may be used.

Key takeaways

I-O psychology has three areas: industrial (selection, training, appraisal), organisational (satisfaction, leadership, culture) and human factors (designing tools and systems), plus occupational health and humanitarian branches. Scott, Münsterberg and Cattell founded it; the Army Alpha and Beta showed testing at scale but were biased and misused. Taylor's scientific management neglected workers; Gilbreth added fatigue and satisfaction. The Hawthorne studies turned attention to social factors, though their data are disputed. Lewin studied leadership, and Title VII and Griggs made job-related selection a legal requirement.

Flashcards

Flashcard

I-O psychology

Studies how behaviour affects work and how work affects people

Industrial-organisational.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

An airline asks a psychologist to redesign cockpit warning lights so that pilots notice and read them faster. Which area of I-O psychology is this?

Question 2 of 5

Which criticism was most often made of Frederick Taylor's scientific management?

Question 3 of 5

What was the most lasting effect of the Hawthorne studies on I-O psychology?

Question 4 of 5

Why did the First World War testing programme include the Army Beta as well as the Army Alpha?

Question 5 of 5

A company requires a high-school diploma for a labouring job, and the rule screens out far more applicants from one racial group. Under Griggs v. Duke Power, what must the company show?

← Previous topicNext topic →