Psychology › Section B · Psychological research › Topic B.1
Why research is important
Without research we would navigate our complex world on intuition, authority and blind luck - and history shows how badly that goes. This topic covers why evidence beats certainty, how contradictory findings are a field thinking, and the two kinds of reasoning science runs on.
The alternative to research is being wrong
Most people feel confident in their ability to read the world, and history records how wrong that confidence can be. At various times, people were sure that the sun circled the earth, that continents never moved, and that mental illness came from evil spirits. Skulls with deliberately drilled holes (trephination) survive from many ancient cultures, and one common interpretation is that some were meant to let spirits escape. Systematic research is how we test such beliefs, trading the feeling of certainty for evidence. The lesson is not that our ancestors were foolish; it is that unaided intuition is everyone's default, including ours.
Contradictory findings: a field thinking out loud
News coverage treats two opposing studies as a scandal; research treats them as the normal sound of a field reaching consensus. Consider teenagers and screens. Jean Twenge and colleagues (2018) reported that heavier screen use went with lower wellbeing in large US surveys. Amy Orben and Andrew Przybylski (2019), analysing similar large datasets in many different ways, found the link real but very small - about as strong as the link between wellbeing and eating potatoes. Neither finding is thrown out: the field weighs measures, samples and analysis choices until a consensus forms. Until then, the honest stance is critical thinking: healthy scepticism towards every claim, including the ones we like.
Facts and opinions
Research draws the line between facts and opinions. Facts are observable realities; an opinion is a personal view or judgement, which might turn out right or wrong. In science, facts are established through empirical research - evidence collected by observation and experiment. An online search on a health question returns blog posts, top-ten lists and advocacy pages; much of it is opinion dressed as information, and research is how the two are told apart.
The people who built the evidence
Psychology's evidence base came from a broader cast than the standard histories once admitted. The first woman to earn a doctorate in the field was Margaret Floy Washburn (1871-1939), who studied how animals perceive and think. Mary Whiton Calkins (1863-1930) founded one of the earliest US experimental psychology laboratories and studied memory; Harvard refused her the PhD she had earned. The APA's founding members in 1892 were all white men, yet by 1905 Calkins was its first woman president. Francis Sumner received the first US psychology doctorate awarded to an African American (1920). In India, Gunamudian David Boaz and Narendra Nath Sen Gupta founded the first independent psychology departments, at Madras and Calcutta. By 1946 nearly a quarter of American psychologists were women. The lesson: who does science shapes what gets studied.
Two directions of reasoning: deductive and inductive
Scientific research runs on two complementary logics. Deductive reasoning works from the general to the specific: if the premises are true, the conclusion must be true - the logical structure of deriving a prediction. Inductive reasoning works from observations to generalisations, and its conclusions can be wrong however careful the observations: centuries of Europeans saw only white swans and concluded "all swans are white," until black swans were recorded in Australia in 1697. Science uses both in a loop: inductive reasoning builds theories from accumulated observations; the theories generate hypotheses that deductive reasoning tests against new data.
Theories and hypotheses
A theory is a developed body of ideas that explains a range of observations; a hypothesis is a specific, testable prediction derived from it. Theories are too broad to test whole, so researchers derive hypotheses and test those. The James-Lange theory of emotion (1880s) holds that bodily changes come first and produce the felt emotion. One hypothesis that follows is facial feedback: putting the face into a smile should make people feel somewhat happier. Each tested hypothesis probes the theory behind it: support strengthens the theory, and failure forces a revision.
Falsifiability: the make-or-break property
A scientific hypothesis must be falsifiable - capable of being shown incorrect by some imaginable observation. The best-known critique targets Freud: the philosopher Karl Popper argued that psychoanalysis could explain any outcome after the fact, and Freud's division of the mind into id, ego and superego is still taught for its history but offers no observation that could disprove it. The facial feedback hypothesis is the contrast: it predicts that people made to smile will rate jokes as funnier, and an experiment can show that they do not. Unfalsifiable ideas are not worthless; they are simply outside science.
Worked example: evaluating a health claim
A blog promises a supplement "proven to boost memory." Apply the research questions. 1. Who makes the claim, and what do they gain if you believe it? A seller's "proof" deserves extra scrutiny. 2. What does "proven" mean here - is there a cited study, and is the study of humans or of cells in a dish? 3. Who was measured, against what comparison? A before-and-after testimonial is not a controlled comparison. 4. Does the finding replicate - does independent evidence agree? 5. Verdict, honestly hedged: the claim is an opinion until research establishes it, and the burden of proof lies with the person making it.
Worked example: a falsifiable hypothesis meets replication
1. Test: in 1988 Fritz Strack, Leonard Martin and Sabine Stepper had people hold a pen in their teeth (which forces a smile) or in their lips (which blocks one) while rating cartoons; the "smiling" group rated them funnier. 2. Replication: in 2016, 17 laboratories repeated the pen procedure under a shared, pre-registered plan and found no reliable effect. 3. Further test: a 2022 multi-country study (the Many Smiles Collaboration) found that deliberately posed smiles slightly raised reported happiness, while the pen version again showed little effect. 4. Current status: a small effect for posed expressions, not the original pen result. 5. Check: because the hypothesis was falsifiable, the data could correct it.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating confidence as knowledge: certainty without evidence is a human default, not an ancient quirk. Second, reading two contradictory studies as the failure of science - it is the process of consensus forming, slowly and in public. Third, demanding that every individual study be the last word: single studies are data points, not verdicts. Fourth, confusing opinions with facts: facts are observable realities established by empirical research, not by repetition or enthusiasm. Fifth, accepting unfalsifiable claims as scientific because they sound profound - the id, ego and superego standard. Sixth, forgetting that the researcher's own perspective shapes what gets studied - the diversity-of-science lesson runs both ways.
Key takeaways
Research is the dependable alternative to intuition, authority and luck. Contradictory findings - such as the screen-time studies (Twenge and colleagues, 2018; Orben and Przybylski, 2019) - are consensus forming in real time, and the consumer's stance is healthy scepticism. Facts are observable realities established by empirical research; opinions are personal judgements. Science uses deductive (general to specific) and inductive (observations to generalisations, fallible) reasoning: theories generate falsifiable hypotheses - the property Freud's id, ego and superego lack and facial feedback has, which let replications from 2016 and 2022 correct it. The evidence base was built by a wider cast than history once admitted: Washburn, Calkins, Sumner, Boaz, Sen Gupta - diversity shaping what gets asked.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A sun circling the earth, fixed continents, spirits causing illness
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Two large studies reach different conclusions about teenagers and screen time. The best interpretation:
Question 2 of 5
In science, facts are established by:
Question 3 of 5
Seeing only white swans for centuries and concluding that all swans are white is an example of:
Question 4 of 5
Freud's id, ego and superego are criticised as unscientific because:
Question 5 of 5
From the James-Lange theory, a researcher predicts that people made to smile will rate cartoons as funnier. This prediction is:
