Sociology › Section P · Education › Topic P.3

Issues in education

American schools have long been where the country fights over equality, from racial segregation to testing, disability rights and school choice. Knowing the key court cases, laws and data helps you weigh these debates on the evidence.

From Plessy to Brown

In Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) the Supreme Court upheld a Louisiana law segregating railway carriages, accepting the doctrine of "separate but equal". Segregated public schools across the South rested on that doctrine for nearly 60 years, and Black schools typically received far less funding. In Brown v. Board of Education (1954) the Court ruled unanimously that state-mandated segregation in public schools was unconstitutional, because separate educational facilities are inherently unequal. Resistance was fierce. In 1957 the governor of Arkansas used the National Guard to keep nine Black students out of Little Rock Central High School, and President Eisenhower sent federal troops from the 101st Airborne Division to escort them in.

Busing and its limits

Because neighbourhoods were themselves segregated, ending segregation by law did not integrate most schools. Courts ordered busing: assigning students to schools outside their neighbourhoods to achieve racial balance. In Swann v. Charlotte-Mecklenburg Board of Education (1971) the Supreme Court upheld busing as a remedy. Busing met strong opposition from many families, sometimes with violence, as in Boston in the mid-1970s. In Milliken v. Bradley (1974) the Court limited remedies that crossed district lines, so largely white suburban districts usually could not be included in a city's desegregation plan. Many researchers find that racial and economic separation between schools has persisted or grown in recent decades.

The Coleman Report and Head Start

In 1966 the sociologist James Coleman led a federal study, Equality of Educational Opportunity, of about 650,000 students. The Coleman Report found that students' family background and the social background of their classmates predicted achievement more strongly than differences in school spending and facilities. The finding was controversial, because it suggested schools alone could not close gaps rooted in family circumstances. It reinforced interest in early help. Head Start, the federal preschool programme for children from low-income families, had begun in 1965 as part of the War on Poverty, so it predates the report. Later research has shown that teacher quality and some reforms also make a substantial difference.

Testing and accountability

The No Child Left Behind Act, signed in January 2002, required states to test students in reading and maths every year in grades 3 to 8 and once in high school, and to show adequate yearly progress for every student group, with sanctions for schools that fell short. Supporters said it exposed gaps hidden by averages. Critics argued it encouraged teaching to the test, narrowing lessons to tested content. The Every Student Succeeds Act of 2015 kept annual testing but returned most decisions about goals and interventions to the states. In college admissions, many colleges dropped SAT or ACT requirements during the pandemic; since 2022 some selective universities, including MIT, Dartmouth and Harvard, have reinstated them.

Students with disabilities

Before 1975 many children with disabilities were excluded from public schools or poorly served. The Education for All Handicapped Children Act of 1975, renamed the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) in 1990, guarantees eligible children a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment, with an individualised education programme. Outcomes have improved but gaps remain. NCES reports a national four-year graduation rate of 87% for public high school students in 2021-22, compared with 71% for students with disabilities. Identification also varies between states and by race and income, so some students go unidentified and unsupported while others may be over-identified.

School choice

School choice covers options beyond the assigned neighbourhood school: magnet schools, charter schools, private schools, vouchers or tax-credit scholarships that help pay private fees, virtual schools and homeschooling. Charter schools are publicly funded but run independently of the local district; NCES counted about 3.7 million charter students in fall 2021, about 7% of public school students, roughly double the 2010 number. NCES's household survey found about 2.8% of school-age children homeschooled in 2019, and experimental surveys suggest the share rose during the pandemic. Supporters argue choice lets families find schools that fit their children and pressures weak schools to improve. Opponents argue it draws money and motivated families away from district schools. Research results are mixed and vary by programme.

The pandemic's impact

When COVID-19 closed schools in spring 2020, most students switched to remote learning, and many districts stayed remote or hybrid for months. The effects showed up in national data. The 2022 National Assessment of Educational Progress recorded the largest declines in maths at grades 4 and 8 since the assessments began in 1990, with the average eighth-grade score 8 points below 2019. Losses were generally larger in high-poverty districts and in districts that stayed remote longer, widening existing gaps. Chronic absenteeism rose sharply and has been slow to fall. Schools also expanded technology, tutoring and mental health support, some of which may last.

Worked example: tracing a cause and effect

Explain why many schools remained racially separate long after 1954. 1. Legal change: Brown ended segregation required by law. 2. Underlying pattern: housing remained segregated through discrimination and economic inequality, and most children attended neighbourhood schools. 3. Remedy: courts ordered busing within districts, upheld in Swann (1971). 4. Limit: Milliken (1974) blocked most remedies across district lines, so families who moved to separate suburban districts were largely outside desegregation plans. 5. Outcome: separation by law ended, but separation by residence and district boundaries persisted. 6. Check: each step links a cause to a documented legal or social change.

Worked example: weighing a graduation gap

NCES reports that 87% of all public high school students graduated in four years in 2021-22, against 71% of students with disabilities. Analyse the gap. 1. Measure: the gap is 16 percentage points. 2. Possible causes: unequal support, varied quality of services across states, and lower expectations, an interactionist concern about labelling. 3. Complication: students with disabilities are a varied group, and some follow longer programmes that a four-year rate does not count. 4. Policy link: IDEA's promise of an appropriate education is measured partly by such outcomes. 5. Conclude: the gap signals unequal outcomes, but explaining it needs data on services and pathways.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking Brown ended school segregation in practice: it ended legal segregation, but separation persisted through housing and district lines. Second, claiming the Coleman Report found schools do not matter: it found family and peer background predicted more variation than school resources. Third, saying Head Start was created because of the Coleman Report: it began a year earlier, in 1965. Fourth, confusing No Child Left Behind with ESSA, which returned power to the states. Fifth, citing graduation or test figures without their year and source.

Key takeaways

Brown (1954) overturned "separate but equal" from Plessy (1896), but busing was limited by Milliken (1974) and separation persists. The Coleman Report (1966) stressed family and peer background; Head Start began in 1965. NCLB (2002) imposed annual testing and accountability; ESSA (2015) returned control to states. IDEA protects students with disabilities, whose 2021-22 graduation rate was 71% against 87% overall. Choice options include about 3.7 million charter students and about 3% homeschooled before the pandemic. The pandemic caused record NAEP maths declines in 2022.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Plessy v. Ferguson (1896)

Upheld racial segregation under "separate but equal"

Concerned railway carriages.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did many US schools remain racially separate long after Brown v. Board of Education?

Question 2 of 5

What was the central finding of the Coleman Report (1966)?

Question 3 of 5

How did the Every Student Succeeds Act (2015) change No Child Left Behind?

Question 4 of 5

According to NCES, what was the four-year graduation rate for students with disabilities in 2021-22?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about Head Start is accurate?

← Previous topicNext topic →