Sociology › Section O · Religion › Topic O.3
Religion in the United States
The United States has no official religion, yet faith runs through its history, its politics and its neighbourhoods. Recent survey data show a country that is still fairly religious by the standards of wealthy nations, but less uniformly Christian than a generation ago.
Religion as a force for change
Religion can resist social change, but it can also drive it. The printing press spread Martin Luther's criticisms of the Church across Europe after 1517, helping to launch the Protestant Reformation. In the United States, many early European settlers came for religious reasons, and churches later supplied leaders, meeting places and moral language to movements from abolition to temperance. In the civil rights movement of the 1950s and 1960s, Black churches were central: ministers such as Martin Luther King Jr. led campaigns, and congregations organised boycotts and marches. Religious groups have also mobilised on the other side of many issues, so faith appears on more than one side of most debates.
Liberation theology
Liberation theology emerged within the Roman Catholic Church in Latin America in the 1960s and 1970s; the Peruvian priest Gustavo Gutiérrez gave it a name in his book A Theology of Liberation (1971). It reads Christian teaching through the eyes of the poor and calls on the church to act against poverty, oppression and injustice, including through political action. It was controversial within the Church, which criticised some versions for borrowing from Marxist analysis. Related approaches include Black theology in the United States and feminist theology. For sociologists, it shows religion working against the conflict view of religion as simply a prop for inequality.
Megachurches
A megachurch is a Protestant congregation with an average weekly attendance of 2,000 or more. The Hartford Institute for Religion Research lists about 1,800 in the United States in the 2020s, up from about 1,300 in 2010, with many in states such as Texas, California, Georgia and Florida. Many hold services in arena-like buildings with large screens and contemporary music, and offer childcare, counselling, sports and small groups through the week. Most are evangelical in theology, many are nondenominational, and about 70% in a 2020 Hartford study met on more than one site. Sociologists see them partly as a response to suburban life and partly as a sign of competition in a religious market.
How religious is the United States?
Pew Research Center's 2023-24 Religious Landscape Study surveyed 36,908 adults between July 2023 and March 2024. It found 62% identified as Christian: 40% Protestant, 19% Catholic and 3% other Christian groups such as Latter-day Saints and Orthodox Christians. About 7% belonged to other religions, including roughly 2% Jewish and about 1% each Muslim, Buddhist and Hindu. The religiously unaffiliated, often called "nones", made up 29%. Belief remains widespread: 83% said they believe in God or a universal spirit, 44% said they pray at least daily, and 33% attend religious services at least monthly. Compared with most wealthy democracies, these levels of belief and practice are high.
The rise of the nones
The unaffiliated share grew quickly, from 16% in Pew's 2007 study to 23% in 2014 and 29% in 2023-24, while the Christian share fell from 78% to 71% to 62%. Nones are not all nonbelievers. In the 2023-24 study, 5% of all adults described themselves as atheist, 6% as agnostic and 19% as "nothing in particular", and many in that last group still pray or believe in God. Some people raised in a faith leave after disagreeing with its teaching, others drift away, some were raised with none, and a growing number describe themselves as spiritual but not religious. Pew reports that the Christian share has been relatively stable since about 2019, so the decline may have levelled off, at least for now.
The secularisation debate
The secularisation thesis predicted that modernisation, science and religious diversity would steadily reduce religion's social importance. Classical sociologists, including Weber with his idea of disenchantment, expected something like this, and the steep fall in churchgoing in much of Western Europe seemed to confirm it. The United States long looked like an exception, combining wealth with high religiosity. The sociologist Peter Berger, once a leading defender of the thesis, argued from the 1990s that the world was as religious as ever outside Western Europe and some elite groups. Others answer that recent American trends show secularisation arriving late. Rational choice theorists add a third view: competition among many freely chosen groups keeps American religion vigorous.
Church and state
The First Amendment's establishment clause bars government from establishing or favouring a religion, and its free exercise clause protects people's right to practise their faith. Courts balance the two. In Engel v. Vitale (1962) the Supreme Court ruled that official school-led prayer in public schools was unconstitutional. In Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe (2000) it struck down school-sponsored, student-led prayer broadcast before football games. In Kennedy v. Bremerton School District (2022) it ruled that a public school coach's brief personal prayer on the field after games was protected. Denominations also differ on social questions such as same-sex marriage, which many mainline churches now perform and many conservative ones do not.
Worked example: three prayers at a stadium
Apply the cases to three scenes at a public high school. 1. Scene A: before kick-off, the principal arranges for a student chosen by the school to lead a prayer over the stadium speakers. This resembles Santa Fe: the school sponsors it, so it breaches the establishment clause. 2. Scene B: a group of parents in the stands bows their heads and prays together. No official is involved, so this is private free exercise. 3. Scene C: after the game, an assistant coach kneels alone for a brief silent prayer, not asking players to join. This resembles Kennedy and is likely protected. 4. Identify the test: who sponsors the prayer and whether anyone is pressed to take part.
Worked example: reading the nones data
A news story claims that "29% of Americans have rejected God." Evaluate it with the 2023-24 figures. 1. Find the measure: 29% is religious identity, the share with no religious affiliation, not a measure of belief. 2. Break it down: only 5% of adults call themselves atheist; 6% are agnostic and 19% are "nothing in particular". 3. Compare with belief: 83% of adults believe in God or a universal spirit, so many nones still believe. 4. Correct the claim: about three in ten adults do not identify with a religion, but far fewer reject belief in God. 5. Add the trend: the share rose sharply after 2007 but has been roughly steady since about 2019.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, equating nones with atheists: most nones are not atheists, and many hold spiritual beliefs. Second, treating secularisation as settled fact: scholars still debate it, and patterns differ between Western Europe, the United States and the rest of the world. Third, assuming the separation of church and state bans all religion in public places: it limits government sponsorship, while private religious expression is protected. Fourth, seeing religion only as a conservative force: it has also inspired movements for change. Fifth, defining a megachurch by its building rather than its weekly attendance of 2,000 or more.
Key takeaways
Religion can both resist and drive social change, from the Reformation to the civil rights movement and liberation theology. Megachurches, with 2,000 or more weekly attenders, number about 1,800 in the 2020s. Pew's 2023-24 study found 62% Christian, 29% unaffiliated and 7% other religions, with the Christian decline apparently levelling off since about 2019. Most nones are not atheists. Scholars debate secularisation. The First Amendment bars government establishment of religion while protecting free exercise, and courts weigh sponsorship and pressure.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Religion can resist change but can also drive it
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
According to Pew's 2023-24 Religious Landscape Study, what share of US adults were religiously unaffiliated?
Question 2 of 5
A headline says nearly three in ten Americans are atheists. What is the best correction?
Question 3 of 5
At a public school football game, which activity is most clearly unconstitutional under the Supreme Court's rulings?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement best describes liberation theology?
Question 5 of 5
Why do many scholars say the United States complicates the secularisation thesis?
