Sociology › Section L · Gender, sex, and sexuality › Topic L.1
Sex, gender, identity, and expression
Is a trait part of biology, or something a society expects? Sociologists separate sex from gender to ask that question clearly, then study how gender roles are taught, how identities vary across cultures, and why these questions have become some of the most debated in public life.
Sex and gender
Sociologists use sex for biological characteristics: chromosomes, gonads, hormones and reproductive anatomy. They use gender for the roles, behaviours and expectations a society attaches to being a woman, a man or another gender. The distinction lets researchers ask which differences are rooted in the body and which are created by social life. The psychology topic Sexual behavior, sexuality, and gender identity defines the identity terms used here, such as cisgender, transgender, nonbinary and intersex; this topic looks at how societies organise gender and respond to those identities.
Sex is not a single trait
Sex has several layers, and they usually, but not always, line up. Intersex people are born with variations in sex characteristics, such as chromosome patterns, gonads or hormone responses, that differ from typical male or female development. How common intersex variations are depends on the definition. Anne Fausto-Sterling (2000) estimated up to about 1.7% of births using a broad definition, while Leonard Sax (2002) argued for about 0.02% if only cases with ambiguous anatomy are counted. Many intersex advocates and some medical ethicists argue that surgery on a healthy infant's genitals should wait until the person can decide; some surgeons and parents favour earlier surgery.
Gender as social construction
Gender norms are learned and change. In US culture skirts are coded feminine, yet the kilt is a masculine garment in Scotland, and in many parts of South and Southeast Asia men wear wrap-around garments such as the sarong or lungi. Even colour codes shift: historians report that in the early twentieth century some American advice writers recommended pink for boys and blue for girls before the modern pattern settled. Gender roles are the sets of behaviours a society expects from each gender. Calling gender socially constructed does not mean it is trivial or easily changed: norms are built into families, schools, jobs and laws.
Learning gender roles
Gender socialisation begins at birth, with names, clothing and room colours, and continues through play. Studies of parents and toddlers have found that adults tend to praise and join in play with toys considered appropriate for the child's sex, such as trucks for boys and dolls for girls, and children's toy choices follow that feedback. Boys in particular face strong disapproval for feminine-coded behaviour. These lessons carry into adulthood in occupational sorting: men still form large majorities in fields such as construction, policing and engineering, while women form large majorities in nursing, childcare and primary teaching. The next topic, Gender and gender inequality, follows the consequences for pay and power.
Gender identity and expression
Gender identity is a person's internal sense of their own gender; gender expression is how they show gender through appearance, voice and behaviour. Expression does not reveal identity: a man who wears make-up on stage, or a woman who prefers short hair and work boots, may be cisgender. Cross-dressing is a form of expression and is not the same as being transgender. Some transgender people transition socially, legally or medically, and some do none of these. A society that assumes everyone is cisgender is described as cisnormative. Respectful practice includes using the names and pronouns people ask for; singular they has been used in English for centuries.
Beyond two categories
Many cultures recognise more than two gender roles. In Samoa, fa'afafine are people assigned male at birth who take on feminine roles; they are a long-established and widely accepted part of Samoan society. In Juchitán, in the Mexican state of Oaxaca, the Zapotec community recognises muxes, a third gender with a recognised place in local life. Older anthropological writing used the term berdache for gender-variant roles in some Native nations; that term is now considered offensive, and many Indigenous people use Two-Spirit instead. Recognition is not the same as equality: such groups can still face discrimination.
How many people are transgender?
Measuring gender identity is difficult because surveys differ in wording, age range and sampling. The Williams Institute at UCLA estimated in 2025 that about 2.8 million people aged 13 and over in the United States, about 1.0% of that age group, identify as transgender, including about 2.1 million adults, or 0.8%. Gallup's figure of about 9% of US adults identifying as LGBTQ+ in 2025 includes transgender people but is mostly made up of people who identify as bisexual. Because estimates depend on method, sociologists compare several surveys and report the definitions each one used.
Law and public opinion
Gender identity is now a central political issue. In Bostock v. Clayton County (2020) the Supreme Court held that firing someone for being transgender is sex discrimination. In 2025 an executive order directed federal agencies to recognise only two sexes, male and female, and in United States v. Skrmetti (2025) the Court upheld Tennessee's ban on puberty blockers and hormone treatment for minors with gender dysphoria. In 2026 it upheld state laws limiting girls' school sports teams to students born female. Supporters of these measures cite fairness, safety and caution about medical treatment; opponents cite discrimination and harm to transgender people. In Gallup's May 2026 survey, 38% of US adults said changing one's gender is morally acceptable, down from 46% in 2021.
Worked example: sex or gender?
Classify each statement. 1. "On average, adult men are taller than adult women." Sex-linked: height differences are mainly biological, though they are averages with large overlap. 2. "Nursing is women's work." Gender: an occupational norm, and men work as nurses in growing numbers. 3. "A kilt is a masculine garment." Gender: true in Scotland, not universally. 4. "A person has XY chromosomes, but their body does not respond to testosterone and develops a typically female appearance." Sex: an intersex variation called complete androgen insensitivity. 5. Check: in each case ask whether the trait varies across cultures. If it does, gender norms are involved; if it is much the same everywhere, biology probably plays a larger part.
Worked example: analysing a policy debate
A state debates whether school sports should be grouped by sex or by gender identity. Analyse it sociologically, without taking a side. 1. Identify the concepts: one side defines categories by sex at birth, the other by gender identity. 2. Identify the values: supporters of sex-based teams stress fair competition and safety for girls; opponents stress inclusion and the harm of exclusion. 3. Ask what evidence bears on each claim, such as research on athletic performance after hormone treatment, and where the evidence is limited. 4. Note the institutions involved: schools, courts, sports bodies and legislatures. 5. Conclusion: sociology can clarify concepts, values and evidence, while the choice between them is a political decision.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, using sex and gender as if they were the same: one is biological, the other social. Second, treating sex as one simple trait: it has several layers, and intersex variations exist. Third, assuming gender expression reveals identity or orientation. Fourth, thinking a socially constructed role is easy to change or not real. Fifth, presenting one estimate of the transgender or intersex population as settled without stating its definition. Sixth, describing a contested policy as if only one side had reasons. Seventh, using outdated terms such as berdache.
Key takeaways
Sex refers to biological characteristics and gender to socially created roles and expectations. Sex has several layers, and intersex estimates range from about 0.02% to 1.7% depending on the definition. Gender norms vary across cultures and are learned through socialisation, including play and occupational sorting. Gender identity is inner; expression is outward; cisnormativity assumes everyone is cisgender. Samoan fa'afafine and Zapotec muxes show roles beyond two categories. About 2.8 million Americans aged 13 and over identify as transgender (Williams Institute, 2025). Law and opinion on gender identity are sharply contested.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Biological characteristics: chromosomes, gonads, hormones, anatomy
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which of these is best described as a gender norm rather than a sex characteristic?
Question 2 of 5
Why do estimates of the share of people who are intersex range from about 0.02% to about 1.7%?
Question 3 of 5
A woman with short hair who wears work boots and no make-up says she is a woman and has always identified as one. What can we conclude?
Question 4 of 5
Samoan fa'afafine and Zapotec muxes are cited by sociologists to show that:
Question 5 of 5
According to the Williams Institute's 2025 estimate, about how many people aged 13 and over in the United States identify as transgender?
