Sociology › Section Q · Government and politics › Topic Q.3

Politics in the United States

Free elections are the foundation of American democracy, yet the right to vote was won in stages and many eligible citizens still do not use it. Who votes, who does not, and why are questions about social structure as much as about politics.

Politics as a window on society

Political scientists mostly study how citizens and governments deal with each other: through parties, elections and institutions. Sociologists use politics as a window on society. A country's political practices reveal its norms and values, how power and wealth are distributed, and which groups are heard. Americans broadly share the ideal of equal citizenship, summed up in Abraham Lincoln's 1863 phrase "government of the people, by the people, for the people". A sociological question is how closely practice matches that ideal for people of different classes, races, genders and ages.

A right won in stages

When the Constitution took effect in 1789, states set voting rules, and most limited the vote to adult men who owned property or paid taxes, nearly all of them White. The Fifteenth Amendment (1870) barred denying the vote because of race, but many Southern states soon used poll taxes, literacy tests and violence to keep Black citizens from voting. The Nineteenth Amendment (1920) barred denial on the basis of sex. Congress declared Native Americans citizens in 1924, though some states blocked them from voting for decades more. The Twenty-fourth Amendment (1964) banned poll taxes in federal elections, the Voting Rights Act of 1965 suspended literacy tests and similar devices where discrimination was worst (a 1970 amendment banned literacy tests nationwide), and the Twenty-sixth Amendment (1971) lowered the voting age to 18.

One person, one vote

Equal voting rights mean little if some votes count for more than others. By the mid-twentieth century many state legislative districts had not been redrawn for decades, so thinly populated rural districts elected as many representatives as crowded urban ones. In Reynolds v. Sims (1964), the Supreme Court ruled that seats in both houses of a state legislature must represent roughly equal numbers of people, a principle known as one person, one vote. A ruling the same year, Wesberry v. Sanders, applied the same idea to congressional districts. Districts are now redrawn after each ten-year census to keep populations roughly equal.

Worked example: unequal districts

Suppose a state elects one senator from each of two districts. District A has 40,000 residents and District B has 400,000. 1. Seats per person: A has 1 seat per 40,000 people; B has 1 seat per 400,000. 2. Compare: \(400{,}000 \div 40{,}000 = 10\), so a resident of A has about ten times the voting weight of a resident of B. 3. Social effect: if A is rural and B is urban, rural interests are heavily over-represented in the legislature. 4. The remedy under Reynolds v. Sims: redraw the lines so that each district holds about 220,000 people, half of the combined 440,000. 5. Check: after redrawing, each senator answers to the same number of residents, so each vote carries equal weight.

Voting rules after 2013

The Voting Rights Act required states and counties with histories of discrimination, mostly in the South, to obtain federal approval before changing voting rules. In Shelby County v. Holder (2013), the Supreme Court struck down the formula that decided which places were covered, so that requirement no longer applies unless Congress passes a new formula. Several states then adopted or tightened rules such as photo identification requirements. Supporters argue these rules protect the integrity of elections and public confidence in them. Opponents argue they burden eligible voters who lack ID, who are disproportionately poor, older or members of minority groups. Researchers generally find proven voter impersonation rare, and studies disagree about how much ID laws change turnout.

Who votes

Turnout is measured against the voting-eligible population: citizens aged 18 or over who are not barred, for example by a felony conviction under state law. Estimates from the University of Florida Election Lab put turnout at about 66% in the 2020 presidential election, the highest in more than a century, and about 64% in 2024. Midterm elections draw far fewer voters: about 50% in 2018 and about 46% in 2022, and only about 37% in 2014. Low turnout matters because voters are not a random sample of citizens. If some groups vote much more than others, elected officials hear their preferences more loudly.

Class, education and the turnout gap

The clearest pattern in American turnout is by class. In the Census Bureau's survey of the November 2024 election, about 77% of citizens with a bachelor's degree reported voting, against about 53% of those whose highest qualification was a high school diploma. Sociologists offer several explanations. Voting costs time, and workers in low-paid service jobs often have rigid hours, long commutes and no paid childcare. Obtaining required documents can add more costs. Political scientists Sidney Verba, Kay Schlozman and Henry Brady argued in 1995 that participation grows from resources such as time, money and civic skills learned at work, in school and in voluntary groups. Attitudes matter too: people who doubt that their vote changes anything are less likely to cast it.

Worked example: from turnout to the electorate

Imagine a town with 1,000 eligible citizens who hold a bachelor's degree and 1,000 whose highest qualification is high school, voting at the 2024 national rates. 1. Votes cast by graduates: \(0.772 \times 1{,}000 = 772\). 2. Votes cast by high school graduates: \(0.525 \times 1{,}000 = 525\). 3. Total votes: 1,297. 4. Graduates' share of voters: \(772 \div 1{,}297 \approx 0.60\), or about 60%. 5. Interpret: the two groups are equal in size, yet graduates make up about 60% of the people who actually vote, so candidates seeking votes have reason to pay them more attention. 6. Caveat: these are self-reported survey figures, which tend to overstate turnout.

Representation and other voices

Legal equality has not produced a Congress that mirrors the population. Women and most racial and ethnic minority groups hold a smaller share of seats than their share of Americans, though the gap has narrowed. Barack Obama became the first Black president in 2009, and Kamala Harris the first woman vice president in 2021. Voting is not the only voice: citizens contact officials, volunteer, give money, join interest groups, protest and run for office. Money is contested. In Citizens United v. FEC (2010), the Supreme Court ruled that corporations and unions may spend unlimited amounts on independent political advertising. Supporters see this as protecting free speech; critics fear it amplifies wealthy interests. The American Government topic "Who governs? Elitism, pluralism, and tradeoffs" weighs the evidence.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating the vote as won in 1789 or 1870 for everyone: legal barriers fell in stages, with major changes as late as 1965 and 1971. Second, measuring turnout against the whole population, which includes children and non-citizens; use the voting-eligible population. Third, comparing a midterm with a presidential election as if they were alike. Fourth, assuming non-voters simply do not care: rigid work hours, missing documents and low confidence that a vote matters all play a part. Fifth, reading one side of the voter ID debate as settled fact; both its supporters and its critics make empirical claims that research continues to test.

Key takeaways

Sociologists study politics to see how power and wealth are distributed and whose voices are heard. Voting rights expanded through the Fifteenth (1870), Nineteenth (1920), Twenty-fourth (1964) and Twenty-sixth (1971) Amendments and the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Reynolds v. Sims (1964) established one person, one vote. Shelby County v. Holder (2013) ended federal pre-approval under the old formula, and voter ID rules remain contested. Turnout was about 66% in 2020 and 64% in 2024, and far lower in midterms. Education and class strongly predict who votes, so voters are not a mirror of citizens.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Sociology of politics

Using politics to reveal a society's norms, values and distribution of power

Political science focuses on citizen-government interaction.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did the Supreme Court decide in Reynolds v. Sims (1964)?

Question 2 of 5

A district of 50,000 people and a district of 250,000 people each elect one legislator. Compared with a resident of the larger district, a resident of the smaller one has about:

Question 3 of 5

Which pattern in US turnout does the reading describe as the clearest?

Question 4 of 5

Why do analysts measure turnout against the voting-eligible population rather than the total population?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about voter ID laws matches the reading?

← Previous topicNext topic →