US History › Section B · Colonial societies and the English empire › Topic B.2
Dutch and French colonial ambitions
While Spain built a vast empire, the Dutch and the French planted small colonies whose real business was furs. Few Europeans settled in them, so both depended on Native trading partners and allies, and both were drawn into Native wars over the beaver trade.
Small colonies, big trade
Compared with Spain's empire, the seventeenth-century colonies of New Netherland and New France were modest. Each was above all a commercial venture built around the fur trade, and neither drew large numbers of migrants. Beaver fur was the prize: European hatters pressed it into a fine, waterproof felt, and beaver hats were fashionable across Europe. Because so few Europeans arrived, traders relied on Native hunters to supply pelts, on Native guides to reach the interior, and on Native allies for protection. Native nations, for their part, sought European metal tools, cloth, kettles and guns, and they used these trading partners in their own rivalries.
New Netherland and its company
The Dutch Republic was Europe's leading commercial power in the 1600s, with fleets trading from the Baltic to Asia. In 1609 Henry Hudson, an English captain hired by the Dutch East India Company, sailed up the river that now bears his name. The Dutch West India Company, chartered in 1621, then built trading posts at Fort Orange, near present-day Albany, and New Amsterdam on Manhattan Island. In 1626 the director Peter Minuit arranged to buy Manhattan from local Lenape people for trade goods. The company controlled all commerce, and for most of the colony's life its main purpose was to send furs down the Hudson to Amsterdam.
Worked example: who sold Manhattan?
A Dutch official's letter of 1626 reported that Manhattan had been bought from the local people for goods worth 60 guilders. 1. Author and audience: Peter Schaghen, who had not been to the colony, was passing on news from a returning ship to the States General, the Dutch Republic's governing assembly, which wanted to hear that the venture was lawful and succeeding. 2. What it shows: the Dutch believed they had acquired the island outright. 3. What it cannot show: how the Lenape understood the deal. 4. Context: in many Native societies land was used and shared, not sold forever, so historians argue that the Lenape probably thought they were granting use rights and receiving gifts that sealed an alliance. 5. Conclusion: the famous bargain may rest on two different ideas of what an agreement over land meant.
Growing slowly under Stuyvesant
Peter Stuyvesant, director-general from 1647 to 1664, extended Dutch control onto Long Island and up the Hudson, and in 1655 seized the small colony of New Sweden on the Delaware River. A defensive wall at the northern edge of New Amsterdam, built partly by enslaved African labourers, later gave Wall Street its name. Even so, by 1664 the colony held only an estimated 9,000 people. Brutal wars with neighbouring Native peoples in the 1640s and the company's tight grip on trade discouraged migrants. To attract settlers, the company offered patroonships: huge estates whose owners governed their tenant farmers. The largest, Rensselaerswijck around Fort Orange, created a sharp gap between landlord and tenants.
A diverse and enslaving colony
Short of labour, New Netherland admitted almost anyone willing to come: Walloons, Germans, Scandinavians, English and others. Visitors reported many languages spoken in New Amsterdam's streets. The Dutch Reformed Church was the official church, and toleration had limits. When Jewish refugees arrived in 1654, Stuyvesant tried to exclude them, but the company overruled him. In 1657 residents of Flushing protested against his persecution of Quakers. The company also imported enslaved Africans to do heavy work. Some won a status called half-freedom in 1644: they could farm their own land but still owed the company labour and payments, and their children stayed enslaved. In 1664 an English fleet took the colony, which became New York.
New France on the St Lawrence
Jacques Cartier explored the St Lawrence in the 1530s, but France made no lasting colony until Samuel de Champlain founded Quebec in 1608 as a fur-trading post. Canada's long winters deterred migrants, and by 1640 only a few hundred French colonists lived there. Most were habitants, farmer-settlers who worked narrow strips of land along the river. Traders and explorers pushed far inland: Jacques Marquette and Louis Jolliet travelled down the Mississippi in 1673, and René-Robert Cavelier de La Salle claimed its whole basin for France in 1682, naming it Louisiana. These claims looked vast on European maps, but the land remained under Native control.
Alliances and the Beaver Wars
The French survived by allying with Native nations: the Wendat (Huron), Algonquin and Innu, who traded furs and fought beside them. Their great rivals were the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) Five Nations, who traded with the Dutch at Fort Orange. Many French traders married Native women, and these families linked the two trading worlds. Historians call the long conflicts that followed the Beaver Wars. Fighting spread across the Great Lakes region for much of the century, and in 1649 Haudenosaunee attacks scattered the Wendat confederacy.
Worked example: what drove the Beaver Wars?
Trace the causes. 1. Demand: European markets paid well for beaver, so furs bought tools, cloth and guns. 2. Depletion: by the 1640s beaver in the Haudenosaunee homeland had been heavily hunted, pushing hunters to seek pelts in rivals' territory. 3. Weapons: Dutch guns armed the Haudenosaunee, while the French armed their Wendat and Algonquin allies, raising the stakes of every clash. 4. Disease: epidemics killed many people in every nation, and the Haudenosaunee tradition of mourning war, raiding to take captives who replaced the dead, intensified. 5. Check: the wars were not simply European proxies; Native nations fought for their own economic and social goals, using European trade.
Jesuits and the Jesuit Relations
Members of the Society of Jesus, a Catholic order founded in 1540, arrived in New France in 1625 to convert Native peoples. Their numbers stayed small. Each year they sent reports home, printed in France as the Jesuit Relations, describing Native customs, epidemics and their own efforts. Historians use these as rich sources, though written by outsiders who saw Native beliefs as errors to correct. Kateri Tekakwitha, a Mohawk convert who died in 1680, was revered by Jesuits for her piety and was canonised as a saint by the Catholic Church in 2012.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, imagining New Netherland and New France as large settler colonies like the English ones; both had few colonists and depended on trade. Second, treating Native nations as pawns of Europeans, when they pursued their own aims. Third, assuming the Manhattan purchase meant the same thing to both sides. Fourth, calling New Netherland fully tolerant: its toleration was practical and limited, and it held enslaved Africans. Fifth, confusing French claims on maps with real control, which stayed with Native nations.
Key takeaways
New Netherland and New France were small, trade-driven colonies built on the beaver trade and on partnerships with Native nations. The Dutch West India Company ran New Netherland from New Amsterdam and Fort Orange; diverse but small, the colony relied partly on enslaved labour and fell to England in 1664. New France, founded at Quebec in 1608, had few habitants but far-ranging traders, explorers and Jesuit missionaries. Competition over furs, guns and captives fuelled the Beaver Wars between French-allied nations and the Haudenosaunee.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Waterproof felt for fashionable European hats, made from beaver fur
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did both New Netherland and New France depend so heavily on Native peoples?
Question 2 of 5
What do historians argue about the 1626 purchase of Manhattan?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement about New Netherland's population is accurate?
Question 4 of 5
Which factor helped intensify the Beaver Wars?
Question 5 of 5
What is the main limitation of the Jesuit Relations as a source on Native life?
