US History › Section F · Westward expansion and the cotton South › Topic F.6
The economics of cotton
Between 1800 and 1860 cotton became the most valuable thing the United States sold to the world, and enslaved people grew and picked most of it. Following that crop explains how slavery expanded, why the South grew rich, and how deeply the North and Britain were tied to the system.
From a minor crop to king
In the 1780s American planters grew tobacco, rice and indigo, and cotton was a small crop. Two changes transformed it. British textile mills, powered by new machines, wanted ever more raw cotton. And in 1793 Eli Whitney built a cotton gin, a simple device that pulled seeds from the fibre of short-staple, or upland, cotton far faster than hand cleaning; some historians suggest enslaved workers' ideas fed into the design. Upland cotton could grow across the interior South, not just the coast. Output rose from a few million pounds in the 1790s to about two billion pounds a year by 1860.
Land taken for cotton
Cotton needed rich soil and a long frost-free season, and it wore out fields quickly, so planters kept moving west. The best new land, the dark-soiled Black Belt of Alabama and Mississippi and the river bottoms of the lower Mississippi Valley, belonged to the Creek, Choctaw, Chickasaw and Cherokee until Indian Removal forced them out in the 1830s. Enslaved people did the dangerous work of clearing forests and draining swamps. By 1860 cotton was grown from the Carolinas to Texas, and nine new slave states had joined the Union since 1789.
Work in the cotton fields
Most cotton plantations used the gang system: groups of enslaved people worked in rows under a driver from dawn to dark, with the pace set by force. On Low Country rice plantations, by contrast, many worked under a task system, with a set daily job, after which time was partly their own. Cotton was planted in spring, weeded through the summer and picked from late summer into winter, often going over the fields several times. Each picker's sack was weighed every evening. Falling short of the expected weight meant whipping, and beating it often meant a higher target the next day.
Worked example: why did picking rates rise?
Between 1800 and 1860 the amount of cotton an enslaved person picked in a day rose roughly fourfold, by one widely cited estimate. 1. Hypothesis one: historian Edward Baptist argued that planters drove the rise through systematic torture, raising each picker's quota and whipping those who missed it. 2. Hypothesis two: economic historians Alan Olmstead and Paul Rhode argued that new cotton varieties, such as the Mexican-derived Petit Gulf, had bolls that were much easier to pick. 3. Test: seed improvements are well documented, and so is widespread violence in the fields. 4. Conclusion: the two explanations are not exclusive, and the debate continues over how much each mattered.
The domestic slave trade
Congress banned the import of enslaved Africans from January 1, 1808, though smuggling continued on a small scale. Afterwards the enslaved population grew mainly by natural increase, from about 900,000 in 1800 to almost four million in 1860. As tobacco declined, slaveholders in Virginia, Maryland and Kentucky sold people south to the cotton states. Historians estimate that about one million enslaved people were moved from the Upper South to the Lower South between 1790 and 1860, a majority of them through sale. Many call this forced migration the second middle passage. It tore apart countless families.
Slavery as capital
Enslaved people were not only workers but also property with a market price, and that made them the South's largest form of wealth. Slaveholders borrowed money using enslaved people as collateral, insured them, rented them out and left them in wills. Prices rose sharply in the 1850s as cotton demand climbed. Economic historians estimate that by 1860 the market value of all enslaved people in the United States was greater than the combined value of the country's railroads and factories. That wealth helps explain why slaveholders resisted any threat to slavery so fiercely.
Worked example: following a bale
Trace one bale of cotton in the 1850s. 1. Grown and picked by enslaved people on a Mississippi plantation, then ginned and pressed into a bale of several hundred pounds. 2. Carried by steamboat to New Orleans, the South's greatest port and the largest slave market in the country. 3. Sold through a cotton factor, an agent who also lent money to the planter, often with credit arranged through New York or London. 4. Shipped, perhaps on a northern-owned ship and insured by a northern firm, to Liverpool. 5. Spun and woven in Lancashire or New England mills. 6. Conclusion: profits from slave-grown cotton flowed through many regions, not only the South.
A national and global crop
Cotton was the country's leading export, worth more than half the value of all American exports by the late 1850s, and Britain bought most of it. Roughly three-quarters of the raw cotton used in British mills in that decade came from the American South. New England's textile factories, such as those at Lowell, also ran on southern cotton. In 1858 Senator James Hammond of South Carolina boasted that "Cotton is king": no power, he claimed, would dare make war on the South. His confidence would be tested in the Civil War, when Britain found other sources.
A dependent economy
Cotton made many planters rich, but it also tied the South to others. The region bought much of its pork and corn from the Midwest, cheap clothing and tools for enslaved people from northern factories, and fine furniture and books from the North and Europe. Southern banking, shipping and insurance relied heavily on northern and British firms. Because capital went into land and enslaved people, the South built fewer factories, railroads and towns than the North. Historians debate whether this was simple economic choice or a sign that slavery held the region's development back.
Common mistakes to avoid
Do not say the cotton gin reduced the need for enslaved labour: by making cotton profitable it greatly expanded slavery. Do not assume the 1808 ban ended the slave trade within the United States; the domestic trade grew enormously afterwards. Do not treat slavery as a purely southern business, since northern mills, banks, shippers and insurers profited too. And do not picture the South as economically self-sufficient; it depended on other regions for food, goods and credit.
Key takeaways
British demand and the 1793 cotton gin turned upland cotton into the South's dominant crop. Cotton spread west onto lands taken from Native nations, worked by enslaved people under the gang system. After 1808 the domestic slave trade moved an estimated one million people from the Upper South to the cotton states. Enslaved people were the South's largest form of wealth. Cotton was the nation's leading export, feeding British and New England mills and enriching northern businesses, while making the South dependent on outside markets and credit.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Machine that separates seeds from short-staple cotton fibre
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What was the main effect of the cotton gin on slavery?
Question 2 of 5
What happened to the trade in enslaved people after the 1808 import ban?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement best describes the debate over rising cotton-picking rates?
Question 4 of 5
Why do historians say northerners profited from slavery too?
Question 5 of 5
In what way was the cotton South economically dependent?
