US History › Section A · Worlds meet › Topic A.2

Europe on the brink of change

In 1400, western Europe was a poor, plague-scarred corner of a world whose great powers and richest markets lay to the east. This topic explains how its society worked and why, within a century, Portugal and Spain were sending ships into the open Atlantic.

A small corner of a larger world

Historians use 'the Middle Ages' for the thousand years between the fall of the western Roman Empire in 476 and the Renaissance of the 1300s to 1500s. By 1400, western Europe was not the world's leading region: Ming China, the Ottoman Empire and the trading cities of the Indian Ocean rivalled or surpassed it in wealth and power. Europe was a patchwork of rival kingdoms, linked by one church and one learned language, Latin, on the far western edge of the great trade routes.

Lords, knights and serfs

Most Europeans were peasants living in villages around a lord's manor house and a parish church. In the arrangement historians loosely call feudalism, lords held land, knights gave military service in return for land of their own, and serfs farmed the lord's estates and owed him labour and dues. Serfs were not slaves, since they could not be sold apart from the land, but they could not leave it freely either. Life was short and hard: many children died young, and one bad harvest could bring famine. Historians stress how much these arrangements varied by region.

The Church at the centre

In 1054 Christianity split in the Great Schism: the Eastern Orthodox Church, led from Constantinople and worshipping in Greek, and the Roman Catholic Church, led by the pope and using Latin. In western Europe the Catholic Church was the one institution that reached every village. Its sacraments, from baptism to last rites, marked each stage of life, and it collected the tithe, a tenth of each person's produce or income. Monasteries copied and preserved books, and literate clergy read and explained scripture to a mostly illiterate population. Because the Church could excommunicate, cutting a person off from the sacraments, even kings hesitated to defy it.

The Black Death

In 1347, ships from the Black Sea brought plague to Sicily and the Italian ports, and within four years it had swept across Europe. The disease, caused by a bacterium carried by rat fleas, also spread directly between people in a form that attacked the lungs. Together these outbreaks are known as the Black Death. They killed an estimated one-third to one-half of Europe's population, and some villages vanished entirely. Terrified communities looked for someone to blame, and mobs massacred Jews in many towns, falsely accusing them of poisoning wells. Plague returned again and again for the next three centuries.

Worked example: how the plague loosened old bonds

Trace the effects as a chain. 1. Cause: millions of deaths left fields untended and labour suddenly scarce. 2. Surviving peasants could bargain, demanding higher wages or lower rents, or moving to lords who offered better terms. 3. Lords and rulers pushed back; England's Statute of Labourers of 1351 tried to hold wages at pre-plague levels. 4. Resentment fed uprisings, such as the English Peasants' Revolt of 1381. 5. Over the following century, serfdom faded in much of western Europe, though it hardened in parts of the east. 6. Conclusion: a catastrophe that killed millions also left survivors with more land and bargaining power, and Europe's population was growing again by the late 1400s.

Islam and Christendom

Islam began in Arabia, where Muhammad began receiving revelations around 610 that Muslims believe were collected in the Quran. He died in 632, and within a century Muslim rule stretched from Persia across North Africa. In 711, Muslim forces crossed into Iberia, and in 732 Charles Martel's Frankish army turned back a raid at the Battle of Tours. Muslim al-Andalus became a centre of learning, and its city of Córdoba was among the largest in Europe. Christian kingdoms in the north slowly pushed south, especially from the eleventh century, in the long series of wars called the Reconquista.

The Crusades and the lure of the East

In 1095, Pope Urban II called on Christians to seize Jerusalem, holy to Jews, Christians and Muslims, and Crusaders captured it in 1099 amid mass killing. Saladin retook the city in 1187, and the last Crusader stronghold, Acre, fell in 1291. The Crusades brought violence against Jews in Europe and deepened Christian-Muslim hostility. They also gave more Europeans a taste for Eastern goods: spices, silk, sugar and porcelain. Venice and Genoa grew rich carrying these goods, but by the time they reached Europe they had passed through many middlemen, each adding cost. A direct sea route to Asia promised enormous profits.

New tools and new ideas

Several changes made long ocean voyages possible. The Renaissance, beginning in Italy in the 1300s, revived the study of ancient Greek and Roman texts, including Ptolemy's geography. Around 1450, Johannes Gutenberg's printing press in Mainz made books cheaper, so maps and travel accounts spread quickly. Marco Polo's account of his travels to China in the late 1200s fed dreams of Asian wealth. At sea, the magnetic compass, probably first developed in China, and the astrolabe helped sailors fix direction and latitude. Portuguese shipbuilders developed the caravel, a light ship whose triangular lateen sails let it sail closer into the wind.

Iberia takes the lead

Portugal, a small kingdom of about a million people facing the Atlantic, led the way. Prince Henry, later nicknamed 'the Navigator', sponsored voyages down the African coast from the 1420s until his death in 1460, though he never sailed on them himself. Next door, Ferdinand of Aragon and Isabella of Castile married in 1469, joining two crowns that became the core of Spain. In 1478 they won papal approval for the Spanish Inquisition, which targeted converts from Judaism and Islam suspected of secretly keeping their old faith. In 1492 they conquered Granada, the last Muslim kingdom in Iberia, and ordered Jews who refused baptism to leave Spain.

Worked example: weighing Columbus's plan

Why did experts reject the Genoese sailor Christopher Columbus, and why was he lucky? 1. The shape: educated Europeans had known for centuries that the earth was round, so sailing west to Asia made sense in principle. 2. The numbers: Columbus shrank the earth's size and stretched Asia eastward, putting Japan only about 2,400 nautical miles west of the Canaries, under a quarter of the true distance. 3. The experts: royal advisers said the distance was far greater and no crew could carry enough supplies, and on that point they were right. 4. The luck: unknown continents lay roughly where he expected Asia. 5. The result: after about five weeks from the Canaries, he landed on 12 October 1492 on an island its Lucayan people called Guanahani.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, believing people in 1492 thought the earth was flat; the debate was about its size. Second, picturing medieval Europe as the world's leading civilisation; Ming China and the Ottomans rivalled or surpassed it. Third, confusing the Great Schism of 1054, between the Catholic and Orthodox churches, with the later Protestant Reformation. Fourth, treating 'God, glory and gold' as a quotation from the time; it is a modern shorthand for mixed motives. Fifth, forgetting the Norse, who briefly settled at L'Anse aux Meadows in Newfoundland about 1000 CE, centuries before Columbus.

Key takeaways

Medieval western Europe was a land of peasants, lords and a powerful Catholic Church, on the edge of a world economy centred further east. The Black Death killed an estimated third to half of Europeans but gave survivors more bargaining power. Wars with Islam built hostility and a taste for costly Eastern goods. Printing, the compass and the caravel made ocean voyages possible, and in 1492 a united, fiercely Catholic Spain conquered Granada, expelled its Jews and backed Columbus.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Middle Ages

Europe's era from the fall of Rome in 476 to the Renaissance

Roughly a thousand years.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What share of Europe's population did the Black Death kill, by current estimates?

Question 2 of 5

Why did royal experts reject Columbus's plan to sail west to Asia?

Question 3 of 5

Which was a long-term effect of the Black Death in western Europe?

Question 4 of 5

Which events all took place in Spain in 1492?

Question 5 of 5

The Great Schism of 1054 divided which two groups?

← Previous topicNext topic →