US History › Section B · Colonial societies and the English empire › Topic B.7

The Great Awakening and the Enlightenment

Two movements swept the British Atlantic in the 1700s. The Great Awakening stirred intense, personal religious feeling; the Enlightenment urged people to trust reason and observation. They pulled in different directions, but both taught colonists to question established authority.

Two movements, one Atlantic world

Both movements began in Europe and crossed the Atlantic through travelling preachers, letters, books and newspapers, so they tied colonists more closely to Britain. Yet they offered different answers to the question of how a person comes to truth. The Great Awakening, a wave of Protestant revivals that peaked in the colonies around 1740, said it came through a heartfelt experience of God. The Enlightenment, an intellectual movement also called the Age of Reason, said it came through reason, evidence and experiment. Many colonists were touched by both.

Revival begins

By the early 1700s many ministers worried that colonists had grown cold towards religion, and that worship had become formal and routine. In the 1720s Theodorus Frelinghuysen, a Dutch Reformed minister in New Jersey, began preaching for heartfelt conversion, and the Presbyterian Tennent family trained revivalist ministers at a small academy in Pennsylvania nicknamed the Log College. In Northampton, Massachusetts, Jonathan Edwards led a revival in 1734 and 1735. His most famous sermon, "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God", preached at Enfield in 1741, warned listeners that God held them over hell "much as one holds a spider" over a fire, and only his mercy kept them from falling.

George Whitefield, the travelling preacher

The best-known revivalist was George Whitefield, an English Anglican minister who toured the colonies from 1739 to 1741 and returned several times. He was itinerant: instead of serving one church, he preached in fields, streets and any building that would hold the crowds. His dramatic voice and gestures drew enormous audiences; Benjamin Franklin, no revivalist himself, calculated that more than 30,000 people could hear him at once. Whitefield used newspapers and printed sermons to advertise his tours, making him perhaps the first celebrity known throughout the colonies. He also defended slavery and pressed for it to be legalised in Georgia.

A message for everyone

Revivalists stressed the new birth: a sudden, emotional conversion in which a sinner felt God's grace. Edwards and Whitefield were Calvinists, who held that salvation came only through God's grace, but they insisted that anyone could have that experience regardless of learning or rank. This drew in many who felt shut out by formal churches: women, the young, the poor, and enslaved and free Black people, some of whom became preachers and church members. Native converts joined too. Samson Occom, a Mohegan, converted in the 1740s and became an ordained minister. His success inspired his teacher, Eleazar Wheelock, to open a school for Native students that led to Dartmouth College, founded in 1769.

New Lights and Old Lights

The revivals split churches. New Lights embraced them; Old Lights, including many established ministers such as Charles Chauncy of Boston, condemned their emotional outbursts as disorder. In 1740 Gilbert Tennent preached that ministers who had never been truly converted were a danger to their flocks, inviting ordinary people to judge their own pastors. Some revivalists went further: in 1743 James Davenport led followers in New London, Connecticut, in burning books and fine clothes. New Lights founded colleges to train their ministers, including the future Princeton, Brown and Dartmouth, and Baptist and Presbyterian churches grew while established churches lost influence.

Worked example: did the Awakening prepare the Revolution?

Weigh a historians' debate. 1. The claim: some historians argue that the revivals helped prepare colonists for revolution a generation later. 2. Evidence for: ordinary people learned to challenge ministers they judged unworthy, shared an experience that crossed colony lines, and joined voluntary churches by choice. 3. Evidence against: others argue the revivals were scattered, uneven and short-lived rather than one great awakening, and that many revolutionary leaders were not evangelicals. 4. Timing: the peak around 1740 came decades before 1776, so any effect was indirect. 5. Conclusion: a balanced answer is that the Awakening encouraged habits of questioning authority, without directly causing the Revolution.

The ideas of the Enlightenment

Enlightenment thinkers held that human reason could understand the world and improve society. Isaac Newton's laws of motion and gravitation, published in 1687, suggested that nature followed rational laws anyone could discover. John Locke argued that knowledge comes from experience and that government rests on consent. Key ideas included rationalism, trust in reason; empiricism, knowledge from observation; a belief in progress; and cosmopolitanism, seeing oneself as a citizen of the world. Some colonists adopted deism, the belief in a God who created the universe and its laws but does not intervene in it, valuing moral conduct over church doctrine. Clubs, Masonic lodges and learned societies spread these ideas.

Benjamin Franklin, the American example

Benjamin Franklin, born in Boston in 1706, became the colonies' best-known Enlightenment figure. Apprenticed to his brother, a printer, he taught himself to write by imitating the Spectator's essays, then ran away to Philadelphia at seventeen. There he published the Pennsylvania Gazette and, from 1732, Poor Richard's Almanack, full of short, practical sayings praising thrift and hard work. He leaned towards deism, valuing good works over doctrine. He helped found a subscription library in 1731, the American Philosophical Society in 1743, an academy that became the University of Pennsylvania, and Pennsylvania Hospital in 1751.

Worked example: the lightning rod

Use Franklin's electrical work to see the Enlightenment method. 1. Observe: lightning resembled the sparks produced by electrical experiments, and it tended to strike tall, pointed and metal objects. 2. Hypothesise: lightning is electricity, so a pointed iron rod might draw it away safely. 3. Test: Franklin proposed experiments with rods and kites, which were carried out in France and America in 1752. 4. Share: he published his findings in Experiments and Observations on Electricity, from 1751, and won fame in Europe. 5. Apply: grounded lightning rods protected wooden houses and churches from fire. 6. Check: the key steps were observation, testing and useful application, with no appeal to authority.

Georgia: a planned colony

Enlightenment hopes of reform shaped Georgia. In 1732 King George II granted a charter to a board of trustees led by James Oglethorpe, a member of Parliament and reformer. Georgia had two purposes: to give England's worthy poor a fresh start on small farms, and to act as a military buffer between South Carolina and Spanish Florida. In 1733 Oglethorpe arrived with about 114 colonists and laid out Savannah on a planned grid. Parliament helped pay for the settlement. The trustees banned slavery and hard liquor, but settlers protested, many wanting the plantation wealth of South Carolina, and the ban on slavery ended in 1751.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating the Great Awakening and the Enlightenment as simple enemies; both spread through print and both encouraged questioning authority. Second, assuming revivalists rejected Calvinism; Edwards and Whitefield held to it. Third, imagining the Awakening only reached White colonists, when Black and Native people joined and preached. Fourth, claiming the Awakening directly caused the Revolution; historians see an indirect influence at most. Fifth, assuming Georgia stayed free of slavery; the ban ended in 1751.

Key takeaways

The Great Awakening, peaking around 1740, spread a religion of emotional conversion through Edwards, Whitefield and others, reaching women, the poor, and Black and Native people, and splitting churches into New Lights and Old Lights. The Enlightenment championed reason, observation and progress; Franklin embodied it through print, civic institutions and science. Georgia, founded in 1732 as a reformers' colony and a buffer, soon abandoned its ban on slavery. Both movements taught colonists to question established authority.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Great Awakening

Wave of Protestant revivals peaking in the colonies around 1740

Emotional, personal conversion.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

What did revivalist preachers mean by the new birth?

Question 2 of 5

Why did Old Lights oppose the revivals?

Question 3 of 5

Which is the strongest evidence that the Great Awakening encouraged questioning of authority?

Question 4 of 5

Which best shows the Enlightenment method in Franklin's work on lightning?

Question 5 of 5

What were the two main purposes of founding Georgia?

← Previous topicNext topic →