US History › Section I · The West and big business › Topic I.2
Homesteading, mining, and cattle
Most newcomers to the West hoped to farm, while a smaller number chased gold or drove cattle. All three ways of life began with individual dreams and ended, by about 1900, dominated by capital, railways and distant markets.
Three ways to make a living
The previous topic showed how federal land and railways drew settlers west. Once there, most became homesteaders on the Plains and prairies. A smaller, mostly male minority went to mining camps hoping to get rich quickly, and others worked in the booming cattle business of Texas and the northern ranges. Each followed a similar arc: an early rush rewarded a few individuals, then costs rose, investors took over, and many independent owners became wage workers or moved on.
Farming a semi-arid land
Beyond about the 100th meridian, rainfall is too low for the farming methods easterners knew. A run of wet years in the 1870s and 1880s encouraged the false idea that "rain follows the plough". The explorer John Wesley Powell warned Congress in 1878 that the arid West needed irrigation and larger holdings than 160 acres, but he was largely ignored. With little timber, many families built sod houses from blocks of prairie turf. Drought, blizzards, prairie fires and swarms of Rocky Mountain locusts in the mid-1870s ruined crops, and many claims were abandoned before the five years were up.
New tools and bigger farms
Machines and methods slowly made Plains farming possible. John Deere's steel plough of 1837 and James Oliver's cheaper chilled-iron plough, developed in the 1860s, could cut the tough sod. Windmills pumped groundwater, and barbed wire fenced fields where wood was scarce. Mennonite immigrants from Russia brought hardy Turkey Red winter wheat to Kansas in 1874. Machinery was expensive, so the biggest gains went to bonanza farms in the Red River Valley of Dakota and Minnesota, some covering tens of thousands of acres. Federal irrigation funding came only with the Newlands Reclamation Act of 1902.
Worked example: the farmer's price trap
Follow the logic that squeezed Plains farmers. 1. The farmer borrows to buy seed, machinery and fencing, at high interest. 2. Railways, often the only line in the area, charge high rates to carry grain east. 3. Machines let each farm grow more, and millions of new acres come into production worldwide. 4. Supply outruns demand, so wheat prices fall, roughly halving between the early 1870s and the mid-1890s. 5. The farmer plants even more to cover fixed debts, adding to the glut. 6. Effect: many lose their land to foreclosure or become tenants. This anger fed the Grange movement and, later, the farmers' political revolt.
Women on the homestead
Farm women did a heavy share of the work: cooking, washing, sewing and preserving food, plus caring for poultry, cows and gardens that often supplied the family's only cash. Childbirth far from doctors was dangerous. Yet the West also opened doors. Single women and widows filed homestead claims in their own names, and widows commonly ran farms alone. Western territories led on voting rights: Wyoming Territory gave women the vote in 1869 and Utah Territory in 1870, and Wyoming, Colorado, Utah and Idaho all had women's suffrage by 1896. Historians debate why, citing partnership on the farm, the wish to attract settlers and local politics.
Mining rushes after California
The topic on the Mexican-American War covered the California Gold Rush. Similar rushes followed: to Colorado in 1858-1859, to Nevada's Comstock Lode, the first major American silver strike, in 1859, to Idaho and Montana in the 1860s, and to the Black Hills of Dakota in the 1870s, land guaranteed by treaty to the Lakota. Each began with placer mining, in which individuals panned or sluiced loose gold from streams. Once surface deposits ran out, ore lay deep in rock and needed costly shafts and stamp mills, while hydraulic jets washed away whole hillsides of gravel. Mining became an industry of large companies, and Butte, Montana, became a centre of copper for electrical wire.
Life in the mines
Corporate mining turned prospectors into wage workers. Underground, miners faced heat, poor air, cave-ins, fires and dynamite accidents, and lung disease shortened many lives. Most camps were overwhelmingly male and short-lived; when the ore gave out, they became ghost towns, though some, such as Denver, grew into lasting supply and banking centres. Miners organised, forming the Western Federation of Miners in 1893, and governors often sent militia or troops to break strikes, as in the Coeur d'Alene district of Idaho in 1892. Mining also scarred the land: a federal court in California restricted hydraulic mining in 1884 after its debris buried farms downstream.
The cattle kingdom
Millions of half-wild longhorns, descended from Spanish cattle, roamed Texas at the end of the Civil War. A steer worth a few dollars in Texas might sell for ten times as much in Northern cities. In 1867 the Illinois livestock dealer Joseph McCoy built stockyards at Abilene, Kansas, beside the new railway, and cowboys drove herds north along the Chisholm Trail to it, and later to other railheads such as Wichita and Dodge City. Cowboy work borrowed its tools and words from Mexican vaqueros: the lariat, chaps and the stock saddle. Historians estimate that a quarter or more of trail cowboys were Black or Mexican. The work was hard, dusty and poorly paid.
Worked example: why the open range ended
Explain the decline of the long drive by about 1890. 1. Cause: railways reached Texas, so herds no longer needed to walk north. 2. Cause: farmers and ranchers fenced the range with barbed wire, patented by Joseph Glidden in 1874, cutting off trails and water. 3. Cause: Kansas and other states banned Texas cattle that carried tick fever. 4. Cause: investors overstocked the northern ranges in the early 1880s, and prices fell. 5. Trigger: a dry summer in 1886 and a brutal winter in 1886-1887 killed vast numbers of cattle. 6. Effect: ranching became fenced, smaller in herd size, fed on hay and run as a business.
Range wars: myth and reality
Dime novels and later films made the West look ceaselessly violent. Some mining towns were truly dangerous, but the historian Robert Dykstra found only a few dozen killings in all of the main Kansas cattle towns between 1870 and 1885. Serious violence often came from conflicts over land and water. In Texas, the fence-cutting wars of 1883-1884 led the legislature to outlaw fence cutting while also banning fences across public land. In Wyoming's Johnson County War of 1892, large ranchers hired gunmen from Texas to kill alleged rustlers, among them small ranchers; the invaders killed two men before the army stepped in, and none were convicted.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming free land meant cheap farming; machinery, fencing and seed were costly. Second, imagining Plains farmers failed because they were lazy; low rainfall, falling prices and debt defeated many. Third, picturing every miner as an independent prospector; after the early rushes most were wage workers for large companies. Fourth, picturing cowboys as all white; many were Black or Mexican, and the craft came from vaqueros. Fifth, treating the Wild West as constant gunfights; killings clustered in certain mining towns and in fights over land.
Key takeaways
Homesteaders battled drought, locusts and debt on semi-arid land; new ploughs, windmills, hardy wheat and big bonanza farms helped some succeed. Women carried heavy workloads and won the vote first in western territories. Mining rushes moved from individual placer claims to corporate hard-rock mines with dangerous wage work. The cattle boom drove Texas longhorns to Kansas railheads, but barbed wire, railways, overstocking and the winter of 1886-1887 ended the open range. Conflicts over land produced real range wars.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Rough line west of which rainfall is too low for eastern-style farming
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did many Plains farmers fall deeper into debt even as their harvests grew?
Question 2 of 5
How did western mining change after the early rushes?
Question 3 of 5
Where did many of the cowboy's tools and techniques, such as the lariat and chaps, come from?
Question 4 of 5
Which development acted as the final trigger that ended the open-range cattle boom?
Question 5 of 5
What does the Johnson County War of 1892 show about violence in the West?
