US History › Section F · Westward expansion and the cotton South › Topic F.4
The Mexican-American War
In just over two years, from 1846 to 1848, the United States fought Mexico and took about half of its territory. The war fulfilled expansionists' dreams of a nation stretching to the Pacific, and it immediately raised the question that would tear that nation apart: would the new lands allow slavery?
Manifest destiny
In 1845 the New York editor John O'Sullivan wrote of America's "manifest destiny" to spread across the continent. The phrase named a widespread belief: that God and history meant the United States to expand, carrying its democracy, Protestant faith and farms westward. The idea had a darker side. It assumed that Native nations and Mexicans were inferior peoples who would have to give way. Not all Americans agreed: many Whigs preferred economic growth at home to conquest, and antislavery northerners suspected expansion would mainly benefit slaveholders.
Polk, Texas and Oregon
In 1844 voters elected James K. Polk, a Tennessee Democrat and slaveholder, who promised to annex Texas and claim Oregon. Congress had already approved Texas annexation before he took office, and Texas became a state in December 1845. Oregon was jointly occupied by Britain and the United States. Expansionists demanded the whole territory up to latitude 54°40', but Polk, unwilling to fight Britain and Mexico at once, accepted a compromise. The Oregon Treaty of 1846 divided the region at the 49th parallel, which remains the border with Canada in the West.
The road to war
Mexico had never recognised Texas independence and warned that annexation would mean war. Polk also wanted California, with its Pacific harbours. Late in 1845 he sent John Slidell to Mexico City to buy California and New Mexico, but Mexico's government refused to receive him. Polk then ordered General Zachary Taylor's army to the Rio Grande. In April 1846 Mexican cavalry attacked an American patrol north of the river, killing or wounding about sixteen soldiers. Polk asked Congress for war, and in May 1846 Congress declared it by large majorities.
Worked example: the disputed strip
1. Identify the claims: Texas, and now the United States, said the border was the Rio Grande; Mexico said the Texas province had always ended at the Nueces River, well to the north. 2. Check the history: under Spain and Mexico, the Nueces had been the provincial boundary, and few Anglo Texans lived south of it. 3. Note the evidence for the American claim: Santa Anna's 1836 treaty as a prisoner, which Mexico rejected. 4. Locate the clash: the patrol was attacked in the land between the rivers. 5. Conclude: from Mexico's view, American troops had invaded Mexican soil, so where the first blood fell depended on whose border you accepted.
Worked example: Polk and Lincoln
Polk told Congress in May 1846 that Mexico had "shed American blood upon the American soil." 1. Purpose: a war message, written to unite Congress behind a war that had already begun. 2. Assumption: that the land between the rivers was American. 3. The challenge: in December 1847 Abraham Lincoln, a first-term Whig congressman from Illinois, introduced his Spot Resolutions, asking Polk to name the exact spot where the blood was shed and whether it was on American soil. 4. Effect: the resolutions were never passed, and many voters at home thought them unpatriotic. 5. Lesson: compare a leader's public justification with the facts it takes for granted.
The fighting
Americans fought on three fronts. Taylor won battles in northern Mexico, at Monterrey and Buena Vista, and became a national hero. General Stephen Kearny took Santa Fe with little resistance, though New Mexicans and Pueblo allies rose in revolt at Taos in 1847 and were harshly suppressed. In California, American settlers declared a Bear Flag Republic in 1846 and the navy seized the coast, but Californios fought back before surrendering in early 1847. General Winfield Scott landed at Veracruz in March 1847 and fought his way inland, capturing Mexico City in September after costly battles.
Opposition and costs
The war was popular in the South and West but bitterly opposed by many Whigs, abolitionists and New Englanders, who saw a land grab for slavery. Henry David Thoreau went to jail rather than pay a tax he linked to the war and slavery. About 13,000 American soldiers died, most of them from disease; Mexican military and civilian losses were probably larger but are uncertain. Mexicans remember the war as an American invasion, honouring the young cadets who died defending Chapultepec castle. Ulysses S. Grant, who fought as a young officer, later judged the war deeply unjust.
The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo
Signed in February 1848, the treaty fixed the border at the Rio Grande and ceded the Mexican Cession: present-day California, Nevada and Utah and most of Arizona and New Mexico, with parts of Colorado and Wyoming. With Texas, Mexico lost about half its territory. Some expansionists had demanded all of Mexico, but others, many of them southerners, refused to absorb its large Catholic and mestizo population. The United States paid $15 million and took over about $3.25 million of Mexican debts to American citizens. Mexicans who stayed could become US citizens, and their property was to be protected. In practice, many Californios and New Mexicans lost land through costly lawsuits and fraud in the following decades.
The California Gold Rush
Days before the treaty was signed, James Marshall found gold at John Sutter's sawmill in California. By 1849 tens of thousands of forty-niners were arriving from the eastern states, Latin America, Europe and China, and some 300,000 people came within a few years. Most miners found little, and companies soon took over the deeper deposits. For California's Native peoples the rush was catastrophic: violence, disease and starvation cut their numbers from perhaps 150,000 to about 30,000 by 1870, and many historians call the killing a genocide. California also taxed foreign miners, targeting Latin Americans and the Chinese.
Common mistakes to avoid
Do not say Polk annexed Texas by himself: Congress approved annexation under President Tyler, and Texas became a state under Polk in 1845. Do not say the war began over California; the spark was the disputed land between the Nueces and the Rio Grande. Do not confuse the Oregon settlement, reached peacefully with Britain at the 49th parallel, with the Mexican Cession won by war. Do not assume the treaty's promises to Mexican citizens were kept; many lost their land. And remember that most American deaths came from disease, not battle.
Key takeaways
Manifest destiny expressed a belief in continental expansion that dismissed Native and Mexican rights. Polk gained Oregon by treaty with Britain in 1846 and went to war with Mexico after a clash in the disputed land between the Nueces and the Rio Grande. Critics such as Lincoln questioned the war's justification. The 1848 Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo gave the United States the Mexican Cession for $15 million. The Gold Rush transformed California and devastated its Native peoples, and the new lands reopened the slavery question.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The belief that the United States was meant to spread across the continent
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What event led directly to Polk's request for a declaration of war in 1846?
Question 2 of 5
What were Lincoln's Spot Resolutions?
Question 3 of 5
How was the Oregon boundary with Britain settled?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement about the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo is accurate?
Question 5 of 5
What happened to California's Native population during and after the Gold Rush?
