US History › Section J · Cities and Gilded Age politics › Topic J.2

The Great Migration and new European immigration

Two streams of newcomers filled the growing cities: millions of immigrants from southern and eastern Europe, and Black Southerners leaving the rural South. Both were pushed by hardship at home, pulled by wages, and met by suspicion when they arrived.

Two streams into the cities

The previous topic showed cities straining under rapid growth. Much of that growth came from two groups who had played little part in earlier urban expansion. One was a vast wave of immigrants from southern and eastern Europe. More than 20 million immigrants of all origins arrived between 1880 and 1920. The other was Black Southerners, who began leaving farms and plantations for Southern and Northern cities. Historians analyse both movements with the same tool: push factors that drove people from home, and pull factors that drew them to a destination.

Old and new immigration

Before about 1880, most European immigrants came from northern and western Europe: Ireland, Germany, Britain and Scandinavia. Many Germans and Scandinavians had some savings and moved on to buy farmland in the Midwest. From the 1880s the main sources shifted to Italy, Austria-Hungary, the Russian Empire, Greece and the Balkans. Most of these new immigrants were Catholic, Orthodox or Jewish, spoke little English and arrived with little money. They stayed in the port and industrial cities where work was waiting. Arrivals peaked between 1901 and 1910, when nearly 9 million people came.

Pushed from Europe, pulled to America

Rural Europe was under strain. Populations had grown, farms were divided into tiny plots, and cheap American and Russian grain lowered crop prices. Many young men also wanted to avoid years of compulsory military service. Jews in the Russian Empire faced discriminatory laws and waves of violent attacks, called pogroms, from 1881 onwards. The pull was steady wages in mills, mines and construction, described in letters from relatives already abroad. Steamships cut the Atlantic crossing to about one or two weeks in crowded, cheap steerage. Many migrants planned to return, and a large share of some groups, especially southern Italians, did go home.

Worked example: one migrant's decision

Consider a hypothetical farm labourer in southern Italy in 1900. 1. Push: his family's plot is too small to divide among his brothers, and falling grain prices have cut his day wages. 2. Pull: a cousin in Pittsburgh writes that labourers earn several times more per day in the steel mills. 3. Means: the cousin sends money for a steamship ticket. 4. Plan: he intends to work a few years, save and buy land at home, which made him one of the so-called birds of passage. 5. Outcome: some such men returned; others sent for their families and stayed. 6. Conclusion: migration was often a family strategy, not a single permanent leap.

Ellis Island

The federal government took over immigrant inspection from the states and opened a station on Ellis Island in New York harbour in 1892. Most European immigrants entered there. Doctors checked arrivals for contagious diseases such as trachoma, and inspectors asked questions to screen out people judged likely to need public support. Laws passed in 1882 and 1891 listed groups to exclude. Most people passed through in a few hours, and only about 2% were sent back. The 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act, by contrast, barred almost all Chinese labourers, and it was not repealed until 1943.

Building ethnic neighbourhoods

Newcomers settled near relatives and people from their home villages, creating neighbourhoods such as New York's Little Italy and the Jewish Lower East Side. There they found familiar food, churches and synagogues, and newspapers in their own language. Mutual aid societies collected dues to pay for sickness, unemployment and funerals. Italian labour brokers, called padrones, found jobs for new arrivals but often cheated them. These enclaves eased the shock of arrival and kept traditions alive, but they also packed more people into the poorest districts.

Black migration before 1915

For Black Southerners, the push was severe. The collapse of Reconstruction had left most of them trapped in sharecropping and debt, and from 1890 Southern states stripped Black men of the vote and imposed segregation. Lynching peaked: in several years of the early 1890s, more than a hundred Black Americans were lynched. In 1879, thousands of migrants called Exodusters moved to Kansas, encouraged by Benjamin "Pap" Singleton. Others moved to Southern cities such as Atlanta, or to Northern ones. Still, about 90% of Black Americans lived in the South in 1900.

Life in Northern cities

Black migrants to Northern cities met discrimination there too. Most men were kept to unskilled labour or service work, as waiters, labourers or Pullman sleeping-car porters. Most women worked as domestic servants or laundresses. Landlords charged them high rents for poor housing, and white homeowners and some immigrants resisted Black neighbours; restrictive covenants spread in the early 1900s. Why move? Wages were higher than in the South, schools were better funded, Black men could vote, and crowded cities offered a freedom from the daily deference that Southern custom demanded.

Worked example: when did the Great Migration begin?

Some textbooks apply the term Great Migration to Black movement from 1865 onwards. 1. Evidence for an early start: Exodusters, steady movement to cities and growing Black districts in Chicago, Philadelphia and New York. 2. Evidence for a later start: in 1900 about 90% of Black Americans still lived in the South. 3. The turning point: from about 1915, the First World War cut off European immigration and Northern factories recruited Black workers. 4. Scale: about six million Black Southerners left between 1915 and 1970. 5. Conclusion: most historians date the Great Migration from about 1915 and treat earlier movement as its roots.

Nativism and the push for restriction

Many native-born white Protestants answered the new immigration with nativism, hostility to immigrants. Josiah Strong's bestselling book Our Country (1885) warned that immigrants, Catholicism and city life threatened the nation. The American Protective Association, founded in 1887, campaigned against Catholics, and the Immigration Restriction League, founded in 1894, pressed for a literacy test. Presidents vetoed that test several times until Congress passed it over Woodrow Wilson's veto in 1917. The Dillingham Commission (1907-1911) ranked immigrants by supposed race, and its report helped justify the national-origins quotas of 1921 and 1924. Some historians argue that many Americans did not yet see these Europeans as fully white.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming all immigrants intended to stay; many planned to return, and many did. Second, treating Ellis Island as harsh for most arrivals; about 2% were refused. Third, dating the Great Migration to the 1870s; earlier movement was small, and the mass movement began around 1915. Fourth, imagining the North as free of racism; Black migrants met job and housing discrimination there. Fifth, confusing nativist groups: the American Protective Association targeted Catholics, while the Immigration Restriction League pushed the literacy test.

Key takeaways

From the 1880s, immigration shifted from northern and western Europe to southern and eastern Europe, peaking in 1901-1910. Rural poverty, persecution and conscription pushed people out; wages and family letters pulled them in. Ellis Island opened in 1892, and ethnic neighbourhoods and mutual aid societies helped newcomers adjust. Black Southerners fled sharecropping, disfranchisement and lynching for higher wages and greater freedom, but met discrimination in the North; the mass Great Migration began around 1915. Nativism produced the literacy test of 1917 and the quotas of the 1920s.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Push and pull factors

Conditions that drive people from home and draw them to a destination

Used to explain both European and Black migration.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How did the new immigrants of the 1880s-1910s differ from most earlier European immigrants?

Question 2 of 5

Which of these was a pull factor for an Italian labourer emigrating in 1900?

Question 3 of 5

About what share of immigrants arriving at Ellis Island were refused entry?

Question 4 of 5

Why do most historians date the start of the Great Migration to about 1915?

Question 5 of 5

What did the Immigration Restriction League campaign for?

← Previous topicNext topic →