US History › Section L · The Great War and the 1920s › Topic L.4

Peace, the League debate, and demobilization

American troops helped end the war in 1918, but winning the peace proved harder. Wilson's League of Nations failed in the Senate, and at home a deadly pandemic, strikes, race riots and a Red Scare made 1919 one of the most turbulent years in the nation's history.

Arriving just in time

The first American troops landed in France in June 1917, but the army took months to train and equip. In March 1918, Russia's new Bolshevik government signed the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, a harsh peace that let Germany move divisions west for a huge spring offensive. General John J. Pershing, commander of the American Expeditionary Forces, insisted on building a separate American army rather than scattering his men among Allied units, though he lent some divisions in the emergency. By the summer of 1918, around 10,000 American soldiers were arriving each day, convincing Germany's generals that time was against them.

Americans in battle

Americans first attacked at Cantigny in May 1918, then helped stop the German advance on Paris at Château-Thierry and Belleau Wood in June and in the Second Battle of the Marne in July. In September they cleared the St. Mihiel salient, and from late September more than a million Americans fought in the Meuse-Argonne offensive, where about 26,000 were killed, making it the deadliest battle in US history. With its armies retreating and revolution breaking out at home, Germany's emperor abdicated, and an armistice took effect on 11 November 1918. About 116,000 Americans had died, roughly half of them from disease.

The Fourteen Points

In January 1918, Wilson set out his war aims to Congress in the Fourteen Points. He called for open diplomacy instead of secret treaties, freedom of the seas, lower trade barriers and reduced armaments. He supported national self-determination for some peoples of Europe's collapsing empires and an "impartial adjustment" of colonial claims. His final point proposed a "general association of nations" to guarantee the independence and borders of large and small states alike: the League of Nations. It partly answered the Bolsheviks, who had published the Allies' secret treaties.

The Paris Peace Conference

Wilson broke tradition by going to Paris himself, the first president to travel to Europe in office, but he took no leading Republican with him. He bargained with Georges Clemenceau of France, David Lloyd George of Britain and Vittorio Orlando of Italy, who wanted security, reparations and land. The Treaty of Versailles, signed on 28 June 1919, blamed Germany for the war, took its colonies and some land, and limited its army; reparations, fixed in 1921, came to about $33 billion. Many colonised peoples were disappointed: German colonies became mandates under Allied rule, and a Japanese proposal to affirm racial equality was blocked. Wilson won his main goal, the League.

Worked example: why the Senate rejected the treaty

1. Rule: treaties need a two-thirds vote in the Senate, and Republicans had won a narrow majority in the 1918 elections. 2. Opponents: a small group of "Irreconcilables", such as William Borah, rejected the League outright; "Reservationists" led by Henry Cabot Lodge would accept it with changes. 3. Issue: Article X committed members to protect each other's territory, which critics said could drag the country into war without a vote of Congress. 4. Wilson's choice: touring the country to rally voters, he collapsed in September 1919 and then suffered a severe stroke, yet he told Democrats to vote against the treaty with Lodge's reservations. 5. Result: it failed in November 1919 and again in March 1920. Conclusion: policy objections and Wilson's refusal to compromise together sank the treaty; the US made a separate peace with Germany in 1921.

The influenza pandemic

A new and unusually deadly strain of influenza swept the world in 1918 and 1919. Some of the first recorded American cases appeared at army camps such as Camp Funston, Kansas, in March 1918, though its origins are still debated. The worst wave struck in the autumn of 1918, spread by crowded camps and troopships, and it killed many healthy young adults. Cities closed schools and theatres, and some required masks. Estimates of American deaths run from roughly 550,000 to 675,000 or more, with about 675,000 the most widely cited figure, far more than died in combat. Worldwide estimates range from about 20 million to 50 million or more.

Strikes and inflation

The government lifted most wartime controls quickly, and prices raced ahead: by 1920 the cost of living was roughly double its 1914 level. Freed from the no-strike bargain, about four million workers went on strike in 1919, around one in five of the workforce. In February, a general strike briefly shut down Seattle. In September, most of Boston's police walked out, and Governor Calvin Coolidge became a national figure by declaring that there was no right to strike against public safety. A steel strike of about 350,000 workers failed after employers branded the strikers as radicals.

Red Summer and Tulsa

Racial violence peaked in the "Red Summer" of 1919, a name coined by the writer James Weldon Johnson, with riots in more than two dozen places. In Chicago that July, a Black teenager, Eugene Williams, drowned after whites stoned him for drifting towards a "white" beach; the riot that followed killed 23 Black and 15 white people. In Elaine, Arkansas, white mobs killed perhaps 100 or more Black people after sharecroppers organised a union. Many Black veterans fought back, demanding the democracy they had defended. In 1921, white mobs destroyed the prosperous Black Greenwood district of Tulsa, Oklahoma, killing an estimated 100 to 300 people.

Worked example: the Red Scare

Question: why did fear of radicals explode in 1919 and then fade? 1. Background: the Bolshevik revolution and a new international communist organisation promised world revolution. 2. Triggers: waves of strikes, and anarchist bombs; in June 1919, bombs exploded in eight cities, one wrecking the front of Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer's house. 3. Response: in November 1919 and January 1920, the Palmer raids arrested thousands of suspected radicals, mostly immigrants, many without warrants. The ship Buford, the "Soviet Ark", deported 249 people, including the anarchist Emma Goldman. 4. Backlash: Labor Department officials cancelled many deportations, and Palmer's prediction of a May Day uprising in 1920 proved false. 5. Conclusion: the scare faded quickly, but suspicion of immigrants and radicals lasted into the 1920s.

A return to "normalcy"

By 1920, many Americans were weary of war and reform. Republicans nominated Senator Warren G. Harding of Ohio, who promised "not nostrums, but normalcy", a calmer, less ambitious government. Democrats chose Governor James Cox of Ohio, with the young Franklin D. Roosevelt as his running mate, and defended the League. Harding won about 60% of the popular vote and 404 electoral votes to 127, the first presidential election in which women across the nation could vote. Eugene Debs, still in prison, won nearly a million votes as the Socialist candidate.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, saying the United States won the war alone; it arrived after years of Allied sacrifice, though its troops were decisive in 1918. Second, blaming the treaty's defeat on isolationists only; most senators would have accepted the League with reservations, and Wilson refused them. Third, thinking returning soldiers started the flu pandemic; it spread through camps and troopships during the war, and its worst wave came before the armistice. Fourth, citing one exact death toll for the flu or Tulsa; give ranges. Fifth, treating 1919 as a year of celebration; it brought strikes, riots and fear.

Key takeaways

American troops helped stop Germany's 1918 offensives and break its lines in the Meuse-Argonne, and the armistice came on 11 November 1918. Wilson's Fourteen Points promised a new world order, but the Treaty of Versailles reflected Allied demands. The Senate rejected it twice, over Article X and Wilson's refusal to compromise, so the United States never joined the League. At home, influenza killed about 675,000 Americans, and strikes, the Red Summer and the Red Scare shook the nation. Voters chose Harding's "normalcy" in 1920.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Brest-Litovsk

March 1918 treaty taking Russia out of the war

Freed German troops for the spring offensive.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which factor did most to sink the Treaty of Versailles in the US Senate?

Question 2 of 5

What is the best estimate of American deaths in the 1918-1919 influenza pandemic?

Question 3 of 5

Why did Pershing resist placing American soldiers permanently inside British and French units?

Question 4 of 5

Which event of 1919 is an example of the Red Scare rather than the Red Summer?

Question 5 of 5

What did Harding's landslide victory in 1920 suggest about voters' mood?

← Previous topicNext topic →