US History › Section P · From the Reagan era to today › Topic P.1
The Reagan Revolution
Ronald Reagan won the presidency in 1980 by arguing that the federal government had grown too large and too costly. His tax cuts, defence build-up and fight against inflation reshaped American politics for a generation, and historians still debate who gained and who paid.
A nation looking for a change
By 1980 many Americans felt the country had lost its way. Prices had risen by double digits for two years running, unemployment was high, and 52 Americans were held hostage in Iran. Ronald Reagan, the Republican nominee, offered a simple diagnosis: Washington taxed, spent and regulated too much. In his inaugural address in January 1981 he put it plainly: "government is not the solution to our problem; government is the problem." Supporters heard a promise of renewal; critics heard a threat to programmes that protected the poor and the old.
From Hollywood to Sacramento
Reagan, born in Illinois in 1911, moved to California in 1937 to act in films. He led the Screen Actors Guild, the actors' union, and later worked as a spokesman for General Electric. He began as a New Deal Democrat, but anti-communism and a dislike of high taxes pulled him rightwards, and he became a Republican in 1962. A televised speech for Barry Goldwater in 1964 made him a conservative star. As governor of California from 1967 to 1975 he attacked big government in his speeches, yet he also signed tax increases and large budgets when he judged them necessary: strong words, practical deals.
The 1980 coalition
Reagan won 489 electoral votes to Jimmy Carter's 49, and Republicans took the Senate for the first time since the 1950s. His coalition joined several groups. Economic conservatives wanted lower taxes and lighter regulation; the late-1970s tax revolt, led by California's Proposition 13 in 1978, showed their strength. The New Right included evangelical Christians, many organised by Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority (founded in 1979), who opposed legal abortion and feared the decline of traditional family values. Neoconservatives, often former liberals, wanted a tougher stand against the Soviet Union. Many white working-class voters, soon called Reagan Democrats, crossed party lines.
Supply-side economics
Reagan's programme, nicknamed Reaganomics, rested on supply-side theory, associated with the economist Arthur Laffer. Its claim was that high tax rates discourage work, saving and investment. Cut rates, especially the top ones, and people would invest more, businesses would expand, and jobs would follow. Growth might even raise total tax revenue despite the lower rates. Many economists doubted that last claim, and critics called the approach trickle-down economics, arguing that benefits to the wealthy would not reach ordinary workers. During the 1980 primaries George H. W. Bush, later Reagan's vice-president, had mocked it as voodoo economics.
Cutting taxes
In March 1981 Reagan survived an assassination attempt, and his calm humour in hospital lifted his popularity. Using that goodwill and his skill on television, which earned him the label the Great Communicator, he won over many Democrats in Congress. The Economic Recovery Tax Act of August 1981 cut income tax rates by roughly a quarter over three years and lowered the top rate from 70 to 50 percent. When deficits grew, Reagan signed several later laws that raised some taxes, including one in 1982. The bipartisan Tax Reform Act of 1986 then cut the top rate to 28 percent while closing many loopholes.
Spending, Social Security and the deficit
Cutting spending proved much harder than cutting taxes. Reagan trimmed programmes for low-income families, such as welfare payments, food stamps and housing aid, but those were a small share of the budget. Defence spending rose steeply as part of a Cold War build-up. In 1983 he and the Democratic Speaker, Tip O'Neill, agreed a rescue of Social Security that raised payroll taxes and gradually lifted the full retirement age from 65 to 67. With lower taxes and higher defence spending, deficits soared, and the national debt roughly tripled during his two terms, to almost $3 trillion.
Breaking inflation, at a price
The Federal Reserve, under Paul Volcker, whom Carter had appointed in 1979, pushed interest rates to record highs to squeeze inflation out of the economy. Reagan backed the policy even as it caused a severe recession. Unemployment peaked near 11 percent at the end of 1982, then the highest since the Great Depression, and farms and factories failed. But inflation fell from about 13.5 percent in 1980 to about 3 percent by 1983. Growth then returned strongly, and unemployment fell to about 5.5 percent by 1988. Running on the theme of "Morning in America", Reagan won 49 states in 1984.
Unions and deregulation
In August 1981 about 13,000 federal air traffic controllers went on strike, which was illegal for federal employees. Reagan fired more than 11,000 who refused to return, and their union was decertified. Private employers took note, and replacing strikers became more common. Union membership fell from about a fifth of workers in 1983 to about a sixth by 1989. The administration also loosened rules on banking, energy and the environment, extending deregulation begun under Carter. Looser oversight of savings and loan banks contributed to a wave of failures that cost taxpayers well over $100 billion.
Worked example: reading Reagan's words in context
Source: the inaugural line "government is not the solution to our problem; government is the problem" (1981). 1. Context: the full sentence opens with "In this present crisis", tying the claim to the economic troubles of the moment, not to every function of government. 2. Purpose: an inaugural address sets a tone, so the line signalled a break with the expanding government of the 1960s and 1970s. 3. Test against actions: Reagan protected Social Security, raised defence spending and created a new cabinet department for veterans. 4. Conclusion: the speech states a direction, but historians judge a president by both rhetoric and record, which here diverged.
Worked example: weighing the record
Question: did Reaganomics work? 1. Supporters' evidence: inflation was broken, growth averaged roughly 4 percent a year from 1983 to 1988, and millions of jobs were created. 2. Critics' evidence: deficits and debt soared, real wages for many workers stagnated, and income inequality widened, while young urban professionals, the yuppies, prospered. 3. Causes are tangled: the Federal Reserve, not tax policy, did most to end inflation, and military spending added a large stimulus. 4. Conclusion: the economy did recover, but whether supply-side tax cuts caused the recovery, and whether its gains were fairly shared, remain matters of debate among economists and historians.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying Reagan shrank the federal government: spending, debt and federal employment all grew on his watch. Second, crediting tax cuts alone for ending inflation; the Federal Reserve's high interest rates did most of that work, at the cost of a deep recession. Third, assuming Reagan never raised taxes; he signed several increases after 1981. Fourth, treating his coalition as one group, when it joined tax rebels, religious conservatives, anti-communist intellectuals and working-class Democrats. Fifth, forgetting that deregulation began under Carter.
Key takeaways
Reagan won in 1980 with a coalition of economic conservatives, the religious New Right, neoconservatives and Reagan Democrats. Supply-side theory justified the 1981 tax cuts, which lowered the top rate from 70 to 50 percent. Defence spending rose, some aid for low-income families was cut, Social Security was rescued in 1983, and the national debt roughly tripled. The Federal Reserve's high interest rates broke inflation but caused a deep recession before strong growth returned. The PATCO firings weakened unions. Historians still debate the gains and costs of Reaganomics.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Line from Reagan's 1981 inaugural address
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What was the central claim of the supply-side theory behind Reaganomics?
Question 2 of 5
Which factor did most to bring inflation down from about 13.5 percent in 1980 to about 3 percent by 1983?
Question 3 of 5
Why did the national debt roughly triple during Reagan's two terms?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement best describes Reagan's record on taxes?
Question 5 of 5
What was a lasting effect of Reagan's response to the 1981 PATCO strike?
