US History › Section P · From the Reagan era to today › Topic P.9

Political divides and social movements

The 2016 election revealed a deeply divided country and set off waves of activism on the left and the right, much of it organised through social media. This topic follows the textbook to 2017, then briefly summarises major events up to January 2025.

A polarised nation

By the 2010s Americans were more divided by party than at any time in decades. Pew Research Center surveys found partisans disagreeing more widely, and viewing each other more negatively, than in the 1990s. The parties had sorted ideologically, leaving few conservative Democrats or liberal Republicans. Cities leaned Democratic and rural areas Republican. Cable news and social media let people choose sources that matched their views, while local newspapers declined, and trust in institutions fell.

The campaign of 2016

Hillary Clinton, a former senator and secretary of state, became the first woman nominated for president by a major party, after a strong challenge from Senator Bernie Sanders. She promised to build on Obama's policies and proposed universal preschool and equal pay measures. Donald Trump, a businessman and television personality who had never held office, won a crowded Republican field. He pledged to build a wall on the Mexican border, ban Muslim immigration temporarily, renegotiate trade deals such as NAFTA, repeal the health law and cut taxes. Clinton faced an FBI inquiry into her use of a private email server; Trump faced a recording of crude remarks about women and allegations of misconduct, which he denied.

An outsider wins

Clinton led most polls, but Trump narrowly carried Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania, part of a so-called blue wall that Democrats had won in every presidential election since 1992. He took 304 electoral votes to her 227, though she won nearly 3 million more votes, about 48 to 46 percent. It was the fifth time a candidate had won the presidency while losing the popular vote. American intelligence agencies later concluded that Russia had tried to influence the election through hacking and social media campaigns; a 2019 special counsel report confirmed this but did not establish that the Trump campaign had conspired with Russia. In his first weeks, an order barring entry from several Muslim-majority countries brought airport protests and lawsuits; the Supreme Court upheld a revised version in 2018.

Worked example: winning without the popular vote

Question: how could Trump win the presidency with fewer votes nationally? 1. The rules: each state's electoral votes, except in Maine and Nebraska, go to its statewide winner, however narrow the margin. 2. Distribution: Clinton won California by over 4 million votes, but extra votes there brought no extra electors. 3. Margins: Trump won Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania by a combined total of about 78,000 votes, yet gained 46 electoral votes. 4. Coalition: he gained strongly among white voters without college degrees in industrial regions. 5. Conclusion: under the Electoral College, where votes are cast matters as much as how many.

Hashtag activism

Social media changed how movements formed. In 2014 the online Ice Bucket Challenge raised over $100 million for research into ALS. Black Lives Matter began as a hashtag in 2013, created by three Black women activists after a Florida jury acquitted George Zimmerman of killing the unarmed teenager Trayvon Martin, and grew into a protest movement after police killings such as that of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri, in 2014. Trump used Twitter to speak directly to millions of followers, bypassing journalists. Critics of hashtag activism argued that sharing a post cost little and changed less than organising on the ground.

Marches and counter-marches

The day after Trump's inauguration in January 2017, an estimated 500,000 people joined the Women's March on Washington, and millions more marched elsewhere. Conservatives mobilised too: Trump kept holding large rallies, and supporters praised his tax cuts, conservative judges and promise to put "America First". In August 2017 white supremacists and neo-Nazis held a "Unite the Right" rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, against removing a Confederate statue. They clashed with counter-protesters, and one rally-goer drove into a crowd, killing Heather Heyer and injuring many. Leaders of both parties condemned the violence, and many criticised Trump for saying there was blame on both sides, though he also condemned neo-Nazis and white nationalists.

Me Too

The activist Tarana Burke began using the phrase "Me Too" in 2006 to support survivors of sexual abuse, especially young women of colour. In October 2017, after reports accused the film producer Harvey Weinstein of decades of abuse, the actress Alyssa Milano invited people who had been harassed or assaulted to post the words online, and millions did so within days. Accusations led to firings and resignations in film, media, business and politics. Supporters saw a long-overdue reckoning; some critics worried that accusations were judged online before any investigation.

Beyond the textbook: 2017 to 2021

Trump's first term brought a 2017 tax law that cut the corporate rate from 35 to 21 percent, three Supreme Court justices, new tariffs, and the USMCA, which replaced NAFTA in 2020. The House impeached him in 2019 and again in 2021; the Senate acquitted him both times. In 2020 the COVID-19 pandemic closed schools and businesses and pushed unemployment from 3.5 to about 15 percent; it killed more than a million Americans by 2022, and vaccines, speeded by Operation Warp Speed, arrived in December 2020. The killing of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer in May 2020 sparked nationwide protests. Joe Biden won the 2020 election; Trump disputed it, but courts found no fraud that would change the result. On 6 January 2021, a crowd of his supporters stormed the Capitol to stop Congress certifying the result.

Beyond the textbook: 2021 to 2025

Biden signed a pandemic relief law, an infrastructure law and, in 2022, laws funding computer-chip manufacturing and clean energy. Inflation peaked at about 9 percent in 2022, a four-decade high, and migrant arrivals at the southern border hit record levels. Under a 2020 deal with the Taliban, US forces left Afghanistan in 2021 as the Taliban retook power; a bombing at Kabul airport killed 13 US service members. After Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, the United States sent large amounts of aid. Ketanji Brown Jackson became the first Black woman on the Supreme Court, and in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022) the court overturned Roe v. Wade, returning abortion law to the states. In 2024 Biden withdrew, and Trump defeated Vice-President Kamala Harris, returning in January 2025 as the second president, after Grover Cleveland, to serve non-consecutive terms.

Worked example: studying very recent history

1. Separate facts from claims: the date of an election and its certified count are facts; whether a policy succeeded is an interpretation. 2. Check the source: a viral post is not evidence until it is traced to a reliable origin. 3. Compare perspectives: read accounts by supporters and opponents. 4. Expect revision: memoirs, archives and data appear years later and can change judgements. 5. Admit limits: events of the last year or two are too recent for settled history. 6. Conclusion: careful history of the present states what is known and labels what is still debated.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking the popular-vote winner always becomes president; the Electoral College decided the outcome in 2016, as in 2000. Second, assuming activism came from only one side; liberals and conservatives both organised marches and rallies. Third, treating hashtag campaigns as purely online; Black Lives Matter and Me Too also led to protests and policy changes. Fourth, believing the Senate convicted Trump; it acquitted him twice. Fifth, presenting interpretations of very recent events as settled facts.

Key takeaways

Polarisation grew through ideological sorting, geography and fragmented media. In 2016 Trump won the Electoral College by narrowly carrying three Great Lakes states while Clinton won the popular vote. Social media fuelled Black Lives Matter and Me Too; the Women's March and Trump's rallies showed mobilisation on both sides; Charlottesville exposed violent extremism. Since then the country has seen two impeachments, a pandemic, nationwide protests, the 6 January attack, the Dobbs ruling, and Trump's return to office in 2025.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Polarisation

Growing distance and distrust between the parties

Fed by sorting, geography and media.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

How did Donald Trump win the presidency in 2016 despite losing the popular vote?

Question 2 of 5

What event led to the creation of the Black Lives Matter hashtag in 2013?

Question 3 of 5

Which statement about political activism in 2017 is most accurate?

Question 4 of 5

What did the Supreme Court decide in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022)?

Question 5 of 5

Why do historians treat events of the last year or two with special caution?

← Previous topic