US History › Section A · Worlds meet › Topic A.5
Religious upheaval and challenges to Spain
In the 1500s, a quarrel over church practice split western Christianity and turned Europe's kingdoms against one another. This topic explains the Protestant Reformation and how Protestant England, France's traders and the Dutch began to challenge Spain's hold on the Atlantic world.
Martin Luther's challenge
By 1500 the Catholic Church had united western Christianity for centuries, though critics had long attacked its wealth and corruption. In 1517 Martin Luther, a monk and professor at Wittenberg in Germany, issued his Ninety-five Theses against the sale of indulgences, documents that promised to reduce the punishment souls faced after death for sins. The famous story that he nailed them to a church door may be a later embellishment. Luther came to teach that people are saved by faith alone and that scripture, not the pope, is the final authority. Excommunicated in 1521, he translated the Bible into German, and printed pamphlets spread his ideas quickly.
John Calvin and predestination
John Calvin, a French lawyer turned theologian, fled Catholic France, settled in Geneva in 1536 and, after a brief exile, led its reform movement. His Institutes of the Christian Religion, first published that year, stressed God's absolute power and predestination: the belief that God has already chosen who will be saved, the elect, and who will not. Geneva became a model godly city, governed by church discipline. Calvinist ideas spread to the Netherlands, to Scotland, where they shaped the Presbyterian church, to France, whose Protestants were called Huguenots, and to England, where they inspired the Puritans.
England breaks with Rome
England's break began over a marriage. Henry VIII wanted a male heir, and when his wife, Catherine of Aragon, daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella, bore only a surviving daughter, he sought an annulment. The pope refused, so in 1534 the Act of Supremacy made Henry head of a new Church of England. His son Edward VI pushed Protestant reform; his daughter Mary I, who reigned from 1553 to 1558, restored Catholicism and had nearly three hundred Protestants burned. Elizabeth I, from 1558 to 1603, settled on a Protestant church that kept bishops and some old rituals. Puritans wanted it purified further, and Separatists wanted to leave it altogether.
Catholic renewal and religious war
The Catholic Church answered with its own Catholic Reformation. The Council of Trent, meeting between 1545 and 1563, reaffirmed Catholic teaching and tightened discipline, and the Jesuit order, founded in 1540, sent missionaries to the Americas and Asia. Philip II of Spain, who reigned from 1556 to 1598, made himself Catholicism's champion. In the Spanish Netherlands, Calvinist and other rebels rose in 1568, and in 1581 the rebel provinces renounced Philip's rule, founding what became the Dutch Republic, though Spain did not recognise it until 1648. In France, the St. Bartholomew's Day Massacre of 1572 killed thousands of Huguenots.
The Spanish Armada
Philip II saw Protestant England, which was helping the Dutch rebels and raiding Spanish ships, as a threat. In 1588 he sent the Armada, a fleet of about 130 ships, to clear the Channel for an invasion army waiting in the Netherlands. English fireships scattered the fleet off Calais, English guns battered it at Gravelines, and storms wrecked many ships as they fled around Scotland and Ireland. England's own counter-armada of 1589 also ended in disaster. The war dragged on until 1604. Spain remained powerful, but it could not crush the Protestant states.
Worked example: from a church quarrel to an Atlantic rivalry
Trace how religion reshaped the race for colonies. 1. In 1517 Luther challenged indulgences, and by the 1530s whole states had turned Protestant. 2. In this age a ruler's faith was usually expected to be the kingdom's faith, so religious difference became political enmity. 3. Spain, Catholicism's chief defender and richest power, fought Protestant England and the Dutch rebels. 4. Those rivals struck back where Spain was rich but stretched: its silver fleets and its thinly guarded Caribbean. 5. Colonies became a way to weaken Spain and to spread one's own faith, from Puritan New England to Catholic New France. 6. Conclusion: the Reformation helped turn the Atlantic into a contest among empires as well as faiths.
England's privateers and Roanoke
England was slow to colonise. John Cabot, sailing for Henry VII, reached North America in 1497, but for decades English fishermen, not settlers, crossed the ocean. Elizabeth I licensed privateers, private captains allowed to raid enemy shipping. Francis Drake plundered Spanish silver near Panama in 1573 and sailed round the world between 1577 and 1580. In 1585 Walter Raleigh's backers planted a colony at Roanoke Island, in today's North Carolina, among Algonquian-speaking peoples such as the Secotan and Croatoan. A second group of about 115 settlers arrived in 1587 under John White, who sailed home for supplies; war with Spain kept him away until 1590.
Worked example: weighing the evidence from Roanoke
When White returned in 1590, the colonists were gone. 1. Evidence: the word CROATOAN was carved on a post, and the houses had been taken down, not burned. 2. Prior agreement: the colonists were to carve a cross if they left in distress, and White found none. 3. Hypothesis A: they moved to Croatoan Island, home of allied Croatoan people, about 80 kilometres south. 4. Hypothesis B: some moved inland towards Albemarle Sound or the Chesapeake. 5. Hypothesis C: they died of hunger or in conflict. 6. Conclusion: the evidence points to an orderly move and absorption into Native communities, but archaeologists still debate the finds, so the case stays open.
Joint-stock companies and first footholds
English merchants found a new way to fund colonies: the joint-stock company, in which many investors bought shares, pooling money and spreading the risk of loss. The Virginia Company, chartered in 1606, founded Jamestown in 1607 in the lands of the Powhatan paramount chiefdom; most early colonists died, but the colony survived. The English also took Bermuda after a shipwreck in 1609 and settled Caribbean islands such as St. Kitts in 1624 and Barbados in 1627, which turned to sugar in the 1640s. Religious migrants followed: Separatists founded Plymouth in 1620, and Puritans founded Massachusetts Bay in 1630.
France and the Dutch Republic
Jacques Cartier made three voyages up the St. Lawrence between 1534 and 1542, meeting St. Lawrence Iroquoians at Stadacona and Hochelaga, but no lasting colony followed. In 1608 Samuel de Champlain founded Quebec and allied with the Wendat (Huron), Algonquin and Innu against the Haudenosaunee. New France grew on the fur trade, supplying beaver for fashionable hats, and France took Guadeloupe and Martinique in 1635. The Dutch East India Company, chartered in 1602, hired Henry Hudson, who explored the Hudson River in 1609. New Netherland followed, with Fort Orange on Mohican land and New Amsterdam on Lenape land, and in 1628 the Dutch West India Company's Piet Heyn captured a Spanish silver fleet off Cuba.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying indulgences were sold as permission to sin; officially they reduced punishment for sins already forgiven, though preachers often oversold them. Second, assuming Luther meant to found a new church; he first hoped to reform the old one. Third, confusing Puritans, who wanted to reform the Church of England, with Separatists, who left it. Fourth, believing the Armada's defeat ended Spanish power; Spain stayed a great power for decades. Fifth, treating Roanoke as an unsolvable mystery rather than a case with evidence to weigh.
Key takeaways
Luther's protest of 1517 and Calvin's teaching on predestination split western Christianity, while Henry VIII's Act of Supremacy of 1534 created the Church of England. Catholic Spain led the fight back, but the Dutch revolted, the Armada failed in 1588, and religious hatred fuelled massacres. Spain's rivals then challenged it in the Americas: English privateers, Roanoke and Jamestown, French alliances and fur trading from Quebec, and Dutch companies in New Netherland and the Caribbean.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Luther's protest against the sale of indulgences
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Luther's Ninety-five Theses chiefly attack?
Question 2 of 5
What is predestination, as Calvin taught it?
Question 3 of 5
Why did Henry VIII break with the Roman Catholic Church?
Question 4 of 5
What did John White find at Roanoke when he returned in 1590?
Question 5 of 5
What helped France build New France in the early 1600s?
