US History › Section C · Toward independence › Topic C.3

The Townshend Acts and colonial resistance

A year after the Stamp Act's repeal, Parliament tried again with taxes on imported goods and tougher enforcement. The result was a second boycott, an army in Boston, and five deaths on a winter night in 1770 that both sides would fight to define.

Parliament tries again

Having claimed in the Declaratory Act that it could bind the colonies in all cases, Parliament soon acted on that claim. William Pitt formed a government in 1766 but was often too ill to lead it, so much of the work fell to his Chancellor of the Exchequer, Charles Townshend. Landowners in Parliament had just forced a cut in the land tax at home, so Townshend looked to America for revenue. In 1767 he steered through a package of laws, the Townshend Acts, that combined new duties with tougher enforcement.

The duties and the external-tax gamble

The Revenue Act of 1767 placed duties on glass, lead, paint, paper and tea imported into the colonies. Townshend hoped colonists would accept them because they were external taxes, collected on trade at the ports, rather than internal taxes like the stamp duty. In 1766 Benjamin Franklin had told the House of Commons that colonists objected to internal taxes, while accepting duties that regulated commerce. Townshend took that distinction at face value. But these duties were openly designed to raise money, and that, for many colonists, made them taxes without consent all the same.

Salaries, searches and a customs board

How the money would be spent mattered as much as how it was raised. Part of the revenue would pay the salaries of royal governors and judges, who had depended on colonial assemblies for their pay. Freed from that dependence, officials could enforce unpopular laws without fear of losing their income. The act also confirmed writs of assistance, general search warrants that let customs officers search for smuggled goods without naming a place. A new American Board of Customs Commissioners sat in Boston, and new vice-admiralty courts followed. Separately, the New York Restraining Act threatened to suspend that colony's assembly until it obeyed the Quartering Act; New York gave way before it took effect.

Dickinson's answer

The most widely read reply came from John Dickinson, a Pennsylvania lawyer, in a series of essays called Letters from a Farmer in Pennsylvania, printed in newspapers across the colonies in 1767 and 1768. Dickinson accepted that Parliament could regulate the trade of the empire, even with duties. What it could not do was levy any tax, internal or external, whose purpose was to raise revenue from people who had no say in it. He urged firm but peaceful resistance and loyalty to Britain. His argument closed the loophole Townshend had relied on: the test was the purpose of a tax, not where it was collected.

Worked example: why the external-tax gamble failed

1. The assumption: colonists would accept port duties because they had objected mainly to internal taxes. 2. The evidence behind it: Franklin's 1766 testimony separating internal taxes from trade duties. 3. What changed: the Revenue Act stated plainly that it was meant to raise revenue, not just regulate trade. 4. The colonial response: Dickinson argued that a revenue tax was unconstitutional however it was collected. 5. The aggravating factor: using the money to pay governors and judges threatened the assemblies' strongest check on royal officials. 6. Conclusion: by focusing on the form of the tax, Townshend missed what colonists cared about most, consent and control over their own officials.

The Circular Letter and a second boycott

In February 1768 the Massachusetts House of Representatives sent other assemblies a letter, drafted largely by Samuel Adams, arguing that the duties violated colonists' rights and urging joint action. Its tone was respectful, but Lord Hillsborough, Britain's new Secretary of State for the Colonies, ordered Massachusetts to withdraw it and threatened to dissolve any assembly that endorsed it. The House refused, by 92 votes to 17, and was dissolved. The threat pushed other colonies to Massachusetts's side. Merchants in Boston, New York and Philadelphia pledged to stop ordering British goods, while women again spun homespun cloth and gave up British tea. Wearing homespun became a public political statement.

Soldiers in Boston

Boston resisted hardest. In June 1768 customs officers seized John Hancock's ship Liberty on suspicion of smuggling, and a crowd attacked the officials, who fled to a fort in the harbour. At Hillsborough's direction, about 1,000 British troops landed in October 1768, and reinforcements brought the total to roughly 2,000 by the end of the year. Bostonians resented a peacetime army in their streets. Off-duty soldiers took part-time jobs at low wages, competing with local labourers, and brawls became common. The Sons of Liberty kept up a campaign of harassment and newspaper stories about soldiers' misconduct.

The Boston Massacre

On the evening of 5 March 1770, a crowd gathered around a lone sentry outside the Custom House on King Street, throwing snowballs, ice and insults. Captain Thomas Preston arrived with a small group of soldiers. In the confusion the soldiers fired, killing five men. Among them was Crispus Attucks, a sailor of African and Native American descent. To calm the town, the troops were moved out to the harbour fort. At the trials that autumn, the lawyer John Adams, a critic of British policy, defended the soldiers. Preston and six soldiers were acquitted, and two were convicted only of manslaughter.

Worked example: reading Revere's engraving

Paul Revere, a Boston silversmith and Son of Liberty, sold a famous print of the shooting within weeks, adapted from a design by Henry Pelham. 1. Identify the source: a mass-produced engraving by a committed opponent of British policy, made to be sold and displayed. 2. Describe it: a neat line of soldiers fires on command into a calm, well-dressed crowd, and the officer appears to order the volley. 3. Compare with other evidence: trial testimony described a hostile crowd, missiles and confusion, with no clear order to fire. 4. Identify the purpose: to show the soldiers as deliberate killers and the victims as innocent martyrs. 5. Conclusion: the print is weak evidence of what happened, but strong evidence of how Patriot leaders wanted it remembered.

Partial repeal

The boycotts worked. British exports to the colonies fell sharply in 1769, and merchants again pressed Parliament for relief. Townshend had died suddenly in 1767. Lord North, prime minister from 1770, proposed repealing most of the duties, and by coincidence he did so on 5 March 1770, the day of the shooting in Boston. Parliament dropped the duties on glass, lead, paint and paper but kept the duty on tea, to preserve the principle that it could tax the colonies. The customs board and the courts also stayed. Most colonial merchants abandoned non-importation during 1770, and trade with Britain quickly recovered.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, the Townshend duties were external taxes on imports, not stamps on documents; their revenue purpose was what colonists rejected. Second, Dickinson did not deny Parliament's power over trade; he denied its power to tax for revenue. Third, the Boston Massacre was not a planned attack on a peaceful crowd, as Revere's print suggests, nor a simple riot: it grew out of months of friction. Fourth, John Adams defended the soldiers because he believed everyone deserved a fair trial, not because he backed British policy. Fifth, repeal was partial: the tea duty remained.

Key takeaways

The 1767 Townshend Acts put duties on imported glass, lead, paint, paper and tea, used part of the revenue to pay royal officials, and strengthened customs enforcement from Boston. Dickinson's Letters from a Farmer argued that any tax meant to raise revenue was unconstitutional. The Massachusetts Circular Letter and Hillsborough's threats spread a second boycott, backed by women's homespun. Troops sent to Boston in 1768 bred friction that ended in the Boston Massacre of 5 March 1770, which Revere's engraving turned into propaganda. Parliament repealed every duty except the tax on tea.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Charles Townshend

Chancellor of the Exchequer who designed the 1767 duties

Died suddenly later in 1767.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did Charles Townshend expect colonists to accept his new duties?

Question 2 of 5

What was John Dickinson's main argument in Letters from a Farmer in Pennsylvania?

Question 3 of 5

Why did using Townshend revenue to pay governors' and judges' salaries alarm colonists?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about Paul Revere's engraving of the Boston Massacre is best supported?

Question 5 of 5

What did Parliament do with the Townshend duties in 1770?

← Previous topicNext topic →