World History › Section U · Life and labor in the industrial world › Topic U.3
Coerced and semicoerced labor
The nineteenth century abolished slavery across the Americas and serfdom in Russia, yet millions of people still worked under force, debt or contract terms they could not escape. This topic follows the end of the old systems and the rise of new ones.
A spectrum of unfreedom
Factory workers in industrial countries were legally free: no one could buy or sell them, and they could quit, even if poverty left them little real choice. Many other workers had far less freedom. Historians picture a spectrum. At one end stood chattel slavery, in which a person was owned as property. Then came serfdom, which bound peasants to the land, and indenture, in which a worker could not leave until a contract ended. Debt bondage held people until they repaid what they owed, and penal labour forced convicts to work. Several of these systems grew as slavery ended.
The end of slavery in the Americas
Abolition came in stages. Haitians freed themselves in the revolution described in Revolutions in America, France, and Haiti. Britain's Abolition Act of 1833 took effect in 1834, but freed people had to serve as unpaid apprentices until 1838, and Parliament compensated slaveholders, not the enslaved. France abolished slavery for good in 1848, the Netherlands in its Caribbean and South American colonies in 1863, and the United States with the Thirteenth Amendment in 1865. Spain ended slavery in Cuba in 1886. Brazil, the largest slaveholding society in the Americas, was the last, in 1888.
Worked example: why Brazil abolished slavery last
Explain a slow, contested abolition. 1. Pressure from outside: under heavy British naval pressure, Brazil banned the import of enslaved Africans in 1850. 2. Gradual laws: the Free Womb Law of 1871 freed children born to enslaved mothers from then on, and an 1885 law freed those aged sixty and over, after up to three more years' work. 3. Black activism: abolitionists included the formerly enslaved, self-taught lawyer Luís Gama, who won freedom for hundreds in court, and the engineer André Rebouças. 4. Self-liberation: in 1887 and 1888, enslaved people fled São Paulo's coffee estates in large numbers. 5. Result: the Golden Law of 13 May 1888 ended slavery outright. 6. Limits: it gave freed people no land or compensation.
The end of serfdom in Russia
Russia held most of Europe's remaining serfs. By most estimates, about 23 million people were owned by nobles in the 1850s, and millions more state peasants also lived under heavy obligations. After defeat in the Crimean War, Tsar Alexander II abolished serfdom in 1861. Freedom came with conditions. Former serfs stayed temporarily obligated, owing their lords labour or dues, until redemption began, which for some took until a law of 1881. They received land, often less than they had farmed before, which they had to pay for in redemption payments spread over 49 years. Land usually went to the village commune, not to individuals, and household serfs received none.
Indentured labour from India
When British colonies lost their enslaved workforce, planters turned to India. From 1834 to 1917, more than a million Indians signed indenture contracts, usually for five years, to work on sugar and other plantations in Mauritius, the Caribbean, Natal, Fiji and elsewhere. Recruiters often misled them about pay and conditions. Labour laws made leaving a crime, and workers could be jailed for absence. The historian Hugh Tinker called the system a new form of slavery; others stress that many migrants chose it to escape poverty, and that many settled abroad. Campaigns by Indian nationalists helped end it in 1917.
Chinese contract labour
Chinese migrants travelled under two very different systems. Many who went to California, Australia or Southeast Asia paid their fare on credit and repaid it from wages, which left them indebted but legally free. In contrast, the so-called coolie trade shipped an estimated 125,000 Chinese labourers to Cuba and about 100,000 to Peru between the late 1840s and 1874. Many had been tricked or kidnapped in southern China, and many died at sea. In Cuba they worked beside enslaved Africans on sugar estates, and in Peru they dug guano and built railways. Portugal stopped the trade through Macau in 1874.
Worked example: the Cuba Commission of 1874
Analyse an unusual source that recorded workers' own voices. 1. Origin: in 1874 the Qing government sent a commission led by the official Chen Lanbin to investigate the treatment of Chinese workers in Cuba. 2. Method: it collected over a thousand sworn statements and many petitions from labourers. 3. Content: witnesses described being deceived or kidnapped, beaten, and forced to sign new contracts when old ones ended. 4. Limits: the testimony passed through interpreters, and the commission wanted evidence to pressure Spain. 5. Corroboration: other reports, including deaths at sea, support its picture. 6. Outcome: an 1877 treaty between China and Spain ended the trade. 7. Conclusion: coerced workers could make their testimony count.
Pacific Islanders in Queensland
From 1863 to 1904, sugar planters in Queensland, Australia, brought in an estimated 60,000 or more Pacific Islanders, mostly from the New Hebrides (now Vanuatu) and the Solomon Islands, on contracts usually lasting three years. Some came willingly, some were deceived, and some were kidnapped, a practice called blackbirding. Pay was low and death rates were high. When the new Commonwealth of Australia adopted its White Australia policy in 1901, a law ordered most Islanders deported, and thousands were sent back in the following years, though some won the right to stay.
Debt bondage
Debt could be as binding as a chain. In the US South after emancipation, sharecroppers bought seed and food on credit from landlords' stores at high interest, and a poor harvest left them owing more each year. Some employers paid wages in scrip, a token money usable only in the company store. On the henequen estates of Mexico's Yucatán, Maya workers and Yaqui people deported from Sonora were held by debts they could never repay. In Japan, poor families signed contracts that sent daughters to textile mills, or sometimes brothels, in return for advances that the girls had to work off.
Penal labour
States also forced convicts to work. Britain transported about 160,000 convicts to Australia between 1788 and 1868, where they built roads and public buildings or worked for settlers. Russia's katorga system sent convicts, including political prisoners, to mines and logging camps in Siberia; Peter Kropotkin described its floggings in 1887. France sent prisoners to French Guiana and New Caledonia. In the US South, vagrancy laws made it easy to arrest Black men, and states leased prisoners to mines, railways and plantations. The writer Douglas Blackmon has called this convict leasing slavery by another name.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming abolition meant freedom at once; apprenticeship, debt and vagrancy laws limited it. Second, treating all Asian migrants as coerced; many travelled on credit and chose to migrate, while others were kidnapped. Third, forgetting that enslaved people helped end slavery, by flight, revolt, lawsuits and activism, as in Brazil. Fourth, believing Russian serfs received free land in 1861; they paid for it over decades. Fifth, equating indenture with slavery in every respect; contracts ended, but while they ran, workers had little power to leave or bargain.
Key takeaways
Unfree labour ran along a spectrum from slavery through serfdom, indenture and debt bondage to penal labour. Slavery ended across the Americas between 1834 and 1888, with Brazil last after British pressure, gradual laws, Black activism and mass flight. Russia freed its serfs in 1861 on costly terms. Indian indenture, the Chinese coolie trade to Cuba and Peru, and Pacific Islander labour in Queensland supplied plantations, often through deception. Debt peonage, scrip and convict leasing kept many nominally free workers bound.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Owning a person as property who can be bought and sold
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which country in the Americas was the last to abolish slavery, and when?
Question 2 of 5
On what terms were Russia's serfs freed in 1861?
Question 3 of 5
What made indentured labourers from India less free than ordinary wage workers?
Question 4 of 5
Why is the Cuba Commission's report of 1874 valuable to historians?
Question 5 of 5
How did debt keep many sharecroppers in the US South bound to the land?
