World History › Section Q · The Atlantic world and a global economy › Topic Q.5
European colonization in the Americas
Between 1500 and 1700, five European powers planted colonies across the Americas, and no two looked alike. This topic compares Spanish, Portuguese, English, French and Dutch colonies, explains why they took such different shapes, and follows the many ways Indigenous peoples responded.
Many kinds of colony
European colonies in the Americas followed a few broad patterns. In Mexico and the Andes, Spain conquered dense, settled populations and lived off their labour, tribute and silver. In Brazil and the Caribbean, plantations worked by enslaved Africans grew sugar for export. English migrants arrived in large numbers to farm the Atlantic coast of North America, pushing Native peoples off the land. French and Dutch colonies to the north stayed small and relied on trading furs with Native partners. Each pattern reflected the land, the Indigenous societies already there and the aims of the home country.
Spain's labour systems
Spain rewarded conquistadors with encomiendas: grants of the labour and tribute of particular Indigenous communities, not of land. The holder, or encomendero, was meant to protect the people and teach them Christianity, but in practice the system licensed brutal exploitation. A few Indigenous allies received grants too, including some Tlaxcalans and Malintzin, Cortés's interpreter. Bartolomé de las Casas, who gave up his own encomienda in 1514, campaigned against the abuses, and the New Laws of 1542 limited the grants. The crown increasingly relied instead on repartimiento, a rotating labour draft, and in the Andes from the 1570s on the mit'a, which forced men to work the silver mines of Potosí.
Governing Spanish America
Spain ruled its American empire through the Council of the Indies in Spain, created in 1524, and two great viceroyalties: New Spain, from 1535, governed from Mexico City, and Peru, from 1542, governed from Lima. Courts called audiencias heard appeals and checked officials. The Catholic Church was a partner in rule, building churches on the sites of Mexica and Inca temples and sending friars to convert Indigenous people. Colonial society was ranked by birth and ancestry, with Spanish-born peninsulares at the top, American-born criollos below them, and people of mixed descent, Indigenous people and Africans lower still. Historians stress that this order was always contested and more fluid in practice than in law.
Portuguese Brazil
Pedro Álvares Cabral claimed Brazil in 1500, but for decades Portugal mainly cut brazilwood, a source of red dye, along the coast. In the 1530s the crown divided the coast among hereditary captains, and in 1549 it sent a governor-general to found Salvador, along with the first Jesuit missionaries. Sugar plantations spread across the north-east, worked at first by enslaved Indigenous people and then, increasingly, by enslaved Africans; by about 1600 Brazil was the world's leading sugar producer. The Dutch West India Company held the north-east from 1630 to 1654. In the 1690s gold strikes in Minas Gerais drew settlers and enslaved workers inland.
Worked example: why colonies took different shapes
Explain why Spanish Mexico, English Virginia and French Canada differed so much. 1. Indigenous societies: Mexico had millions of farmers already paying tribute to the Mexica, so Spaniards could take over an existing system of labour and taxes. 2. Resources: Mexico had silver, while Virginia had good soil for tobacco but no precious metals. 3. Labour: Virginia's planters, lacking a large subject population, imported servants and then enslaved Africans. 4. Climate and furs: Canada's long winters deterred farmers, but its beaver drew traders, who depended on Native hunters and allies. 5. Interpretation: the economists Kenneth Sokoloff and Stanley Engerman argued that such starting conditions shaped how unequal each society became. 6. Conclusion: land, people and aims combined; geography alone did not decide.
English settler colonies
England colonised late but sent far more settlers than its rivals. The Virginia Company founded Jamestown in 1607 on Powhatan land; tobacco, exported from 1614, made the colony pay. Planters relied first on indentured servants, then increasingly on enslaved Africans, the first of whom arrived in 1619. Virginia's laws hardened over the century: a law of 1662 made children inherit their mother's status, so slavery became hereditary. Further north, religious migrants founded Plymouth in 1620 and Massachusetts Bay in 1630, arriving as families. In the Caribbean, Barbados turned to sugar in the 1640s, and England seized Jamaica from Spain in 1655, building some of the harshest slave societies in the Americas.
French and Dutch trading colonies
Samuel de Champlain founded Quebec in 1608 as a fur-trading post. New France drew few colonists, so it survived by allying with the Wendat, Algonquin and Innu, who supplied beaver pelts and fought beside the French. Many French traders married Native women, and Jesuit missionaries, arriving in 1625, learned Native languages to seek converts. In 1663 Louis XIV made New France a royal colony. The Dutch West India Company, chartered in 1621, built New Amsterdam on Manhattan and Fort Orange up the Hudson to trade for furs, relying partly on enslaved African labour. England captured New Netherland in 1664, but the Dutch held on to Caribbean bases such as Curaçao and gained Suriname in 1667.
Indigenous responses
Indigenous peoples made their own choices in a changing world. Many allied with one European power against rivals, as the Tlaxcalans did with Spain and the Wendat with France. Others traded on their own terms, adapting metal tools, cloth and guns. Some adopted Christianity, often blending it with older beliefs. Many resisted by force. The Mapuche of southern Chile destroyed Spanish towns after a victory at Curalaba in 1598 and kept their independence for nearly three centuries. In 1680 the Pueblo peoples of New Mexico drove out the Spanish for twelve years. Horses, spreading from Spanish herds, let the Comanche build a powerful mounted society on the southern Plains.
Worked example: reading Guaman Poma
Around 1615 Felipe Guaman Poma de Ayala, an Andean noble, completed a letter of nearly 1,200 pages to King Philip III of Spain, with almost 400 drawings. 1. Author: a Christian, Quechua-speaking man who had worked with Spanish officials and churchmen. 2. Content: he praised Andean history and showed corrupt magistrates, priests and encomenderos abusing Andean people, and he asked the king to let Andean lords govern under the crown. 3. Purpose: to win royal reform, and perhaps to support his own family's claims to land and status. 4. Fate: it probably never reached the king, and it lay unknown in a Copenhagen library until 1908. 5. Conclusion: a rare Indigenous view of colonial rule, best read alongside Spanish records.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating the encomienda as a land grant; it gave rights to Indigenous labour and tribute. Second, imagining all colonies alike, when Spanish, English, French and Dutch colonies differed in size, economy and relations with Native peoples. Third, assuming slavery arrived fully formed in English colonies; laws hardened during the 1600s. Fourth, picturing Indigenous peoples as passive victims, when they allied, traded, adapted and fought. Fifth, mistaking European claims on maps for real control: Native nations held most of the continent for long after 1700.
Key takeaways
Spain extracted labour, tribute and silver from conquered Mexico and Peru through the encomienda, repartimiento and mit'a, ruling through viceroyalties, the church and a contested social hierarchy. Portuguese Brazil became a sugar colony worked by enslaved Africans. England sent many settlers, built tobacco and sugar economies on servants and then slavery, and founded religious colonies in New England. France and the Netherlands ran small fur-trading colonies dependent on Native partners. Land, resources, Indigenous societies and imperial aims shaped each colony, and Indigenous peoples responded with alliance, adaptation and resistance.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Spanish grant of the labour and tribute of an Indigenous community
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did a Spanish encomienda grant its holder?
Question 2 of 5
Why did New France stay small yet still survive?
Question 3 of 5
Which factor best explains why Spain could draw huge wealth from Mexico so quickly?
Question 4 of 5
What did Virginia's law of 1662 establish?
Question 5 of 5
Guaman Poma's letter of about 1615 criticised Spanish officials and priests. What is it best evidence of?
