World History › Section P · The early modern Islamic world › Topic P.1
A connected Islamic world
By 1500 Muslims lived under dozens of rulers, from West Africa to Southeast Asia, with no single caliph to lead them. This topic looks at what held that world together: scholars and law, Sufi brotherhoods, trade, pilgrimage and shared learning.
One faith, many rulers
After the Mongols destroyed the Abbasid caliphate in Baghdad in 1258, no single ruler could claim to lead all Muslims, and the Abbasid caliph kept in Mamluk Cairo had no real power. By about 1500 Muslim rulers governed from Morocco and West Africa's Songhai to the Swahili coast, Central Asia, India and island Southeast Asia. Three large empires dominated the centre: the Ottomans, the Safavids of Iran and, from 1526, the Mughals of India, whom Mughal India and international connections follows. This topic asks what held such a divided world together.
Ulama, law and learning
The ulama, scholars trained in the Quran, hadith and law, taught and applied sharia, Islamic law, through schools of legal interpretation: four main Sunni schools, the Hanafi, Maliki, Shafii and Hanbali, and a Twelver Shia school. A qadi, or judge, decided cases, while a mufti issued fatwas, legal opinions that advised but did not bind. Arabic remained the language of religion and scholarship everywhere; Persian became the language of courts and poetry from Anatolia to Bengal, a culture the historian Marshall Hodgson called Persianate. Students travelled far to study and carried home ijazas, teachers' licences to teach a text.
Sufi brotherhoods
Sufis sought direct, personal experience of God through prayer, chanting, music, poetry and self-discipline. By the 1300s most belonged to orders, or tariqas, each tracing a chain of teachers back to a founding master and, through him, to the Prophet. The Qadiri order spread widely from Baghdad; the Naqshbandi grew in Central Asia; the Mevlevi, famous for their whirling ritual, honoured the poet Rumi of Konya. Sufi lodges fed travellers and the poor, and saints' tombs drew pilgrims. Because Sufi teachers welcomed ordinary people and often accepted local customs, many historians see them as key carriers of Islam beyond its old heartlands.
Worked example: how did Islam reach Southeast Asia?
Islam came to island Southeast Asia largely without conquest. 1. Traders: Muslim merchants from Arabia, Gujarat and southern India settled in ports along the monsoon routes. 2. An outsider's report: Marco Polo, passing Sumatra in 1292, noted that one port had converted through contact with Muslim merchants. 3. Physical evidence: the gravestone of Sultan Malik al-Salih of Samudera-Pasai, in north Sumatra, is dated 1297. 4. A visitor's account: Ibn Battuta found a Muslim sultan there in the 1340s. 5. Courts: rulers such as those met in The Malacca Sultanate converted, and subjects often followed. 6. Conclude: trade, teachers and royal conversion spread Islam gradually.
Living alongside non-Muslims
Many Muslim rulers governed large non-Muslim populations: Orthodox Christians in the Balkans, Armenians in Anatolia and Iran, Jews in most cities, and Hindus, the large majority, in Mughal India. As The Arab-Islamic conquests and first Islamic states explained, Christians and Jews were dhimmis, protected subjects who kept their faith and community courts in return for the jizya tax. Rules limiting their dress, buildings or public worship existed but were enforced unevenly. Over time many people converted, from faith but also for tax relief, careers, business or marriage, since Muslim women could marry only Muslim men. Others kept their faiths for centuries.
Trade and trust
Islam was born among merchants, and trade bound its lands together. Monsoon winds carried ships between East Africa, Arabia, India and Southeast Asia; caravans crossed the Sahara and Central Asia. Shared law made long-distance deals safer. In a mudaraba partnership an investor funded a trader and the two split the profits; a suftaja, a written bill of exchange, let merchants move money without carrying coin. A market inspector, the muhtasib, checked weights, measures and fair dealing. Rulers and wealthy patrons built caravanserais about a day's journey apart. Armenian, Jewish and Hindu merchants worked within this system too, as partners and rivals.
Pilgrims and travellers
The hajj, the pilgrimage to Mecca that every Muslim who is able should make once, drew believers from the whole Islamic world; great caravans set out yearly from Cairo and Damascus, and pilgrims carried news, books and ideas home. The most famous traveller, Ibn Battuta of Tangier, left on pilgrimage in 1325 and spent nearly thirty years on the road, in Arabia, Anatolia, Central Asia, India, Mali and, he said, China, at times working as a judge. The scholar Ibn Juzayy wrote down his account, the Rihla, around 1355. Historians value it, but some suspect that parts, such as the China journey, borrow from other travellers' reports.
Slavery in the Islamic world
Trade routes also carried enslaved people. Islamic law forbade enslaving freeborn Muslims, so captives came from beyond Muslim lands: from sub-Saharan Africa across the Sahara and the Indian Ocean, from the Caucasus, and from eastern Europe through Crimean Tatar raids. Many were women and girls who served as domestic workers or concubines; some men laboured in fields or mines, and a few, like mamluks, became soldiers. The law praised freeing slaves, and a woman who bore her owner's child could not be sold and was freed at his death. These rules limited abuse but did not end it. The trans-Saharan slave trade looks closer.
Science for faith and travel
Religious duties drove science. Praying at set times and facing the qibla, the direction of Mecca, required astronomy and spherical trigonometry, and large mosques employed timekeepers. One, Ibn al-Shatir of Damascus, who died in 1375, built planetary models whose mathematics closely resembles that later used by Copernicus; whether Copernicus knew of them is debated. At Samarkand, Timur's grandson Ulugh Beg built an observatory in the 1420s whose catalogue listed about a thousand stars. Geography served travel and war: the Ottoman admiral Piri Reis made a world map in 1513 using, he wrote, a lost map by Columbus.
Worked example: are "gunpowder empires" a good label?
In The Venture of Islam, published in 1974, Marshall Hodgson grouped the Ottomans, Safavids and Mughals as "gunpowder empires", an idea he shared with William McNeill. 1. The claim: costly cannon and handguns favoured rulers who could pay for them, so large centralised states rose. 2. Support: all three used artillery and firearms, and Ottoman guns helped win at Chaldiran in 1514. 3. Problems: the Ottoman state was built before guns mattered much, and the Safavids lost at Chaldiran yet survived and grew. 4. Other shared features: Turkic and Mongol traditions of rule, Persianate court culture and religious legitimacy. 5. Conclude: the label is still debated; many historians keep it as a convenient grouping but doubt that it explains the empires' rise.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming the Islamic world had one ruler after 1258: it had many rival states. Second, thinking Islam spread mainly by conquest everywhere: in Southeast Asia and much of Africa, trade, teachers and royal conversions mattered most. Third, treating a fatwa as a binding command: it was a scholar's advisory opinion. Fourth, picturing Sufis as outside mainstream Islam: many Muslims, ulama included, took part in Sufi life. Fifth, assuming dhimmi rules were enforced the same way everywhere: practice varied widely. Sixth, imagining slavery under Islamic law was mild: its rules limited abuses but did not end them.
Key takeaways
After 1258 the Islamic world had many rulers but shared institutions. Ulama applied sharia through schools of law; Arabic carried scholarship and Persian court culture. Sufi orders helped carry Islam outward, as in Southeast Asia, where trade, teachers and royal conversion worked together. Dhimmis kept their faiths, while conversion brought advantages. Commercial law, bills of exchange and caravanserais supported trade, which also moved enslaved people. Hajj caravans and travellers such as Ibn Battuta linked regions. "Gunpowder empires" remains a debated label, often kept as a grouping rather than an explanation.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Scholars trained in the Quran, hadith and law
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What was a fatwa?
Question 2 of 5
Which evidence shows that Islam had reached north Sumatra by the 1290s?
Question 3 of 5
What did a suftaja allow merchants to do?
Question 4 of 5
Why do historians use Ibn Battuta's Rihla with some caution?
Question 5 of 5
Why do many historians doubt that gunpowder explains the rise of the Ottomans, Safavids and Mughals?
