World History › Section H · Empires of faith › Topic H.1
The eastward shift of late antiquity
Between the third and sixth centuries the Roman Empire was rebuilt around a Christian emperor and a new capital in the east, while its western half broke into kingdoms. This topic follows that shift and the debate over whether Rome fell or transformed.
What historians mean by late antiquity
Late antiquity is the name historians give to the period from roughly the third century to the eighth, between the classical world and the Middle Ages. The term owes much to Peter Brown, whose book The World of Late Antiquity (1971) argued that this was an age of creative change, not just decline. The Roman state turned Christian, its centre of gravity moved east, and new kingdoms and faiths took shape. Edward Gibbon, in the eighteenth century, had told this story as a long decline and fall.
The crisis of the third century
Between 235 and 284, some two dozen men were recognised as emperor, most of them generals raised up by their troops and soon killed. Invaders crossed the Rhine and Danube, and in the east the new Sasanian Persian empire attacked, capturing the emperor Valerian in 260. For a time the empire split three ways, as a breakaway Gallic empire held the west and Palmyra controlled much of the east. As the topic on the Roman economy showed, emperors debased the coinage to pay their armies, and prices soared. The emperor Aurelian reunited the empire by 274, but stability returned only with the reforms that followed.
Diocletian and the tetrarchy
Diocletian, a soldier from the Balkans, took power in 284. Judging the empire too large for one ruler, he took a co-emperor, Maximian, and in 293 added two junior emperors, each with the title caesar. This rule of four, the tetrarchy, placed emperors near the threatened frontiers, in cities such as Trier, Milan and Nicomedia, rather than in Rome. Diocletian also split provinces into smaller units grouped into larger regions called dioceses, separated civil from military commands and enlarged the army. In 305 he and Maximian did something unheard of: they retired. The orderly succession they planned collapsed into civil war within two years.
Constantine
Constantine, son of the tetrarch Constantius, was proclaimed emperor by his troops at York in 306. In 312 he invaded Italy and defeated his rival Maxentius at the Milvian Bridge outside Rome. Two Christian writers describe a sign before the battle, but differently: Lactantius tells of a dream instructing Constantine to mark a Christian symbol on his soldiers' shields, while Eusebius, writing after Constantine's death, reports a cross of light in the sky with the words "By this, conquer." Constantine favoured Christians from then on, became sole emperor in 324, and was baptised only on his deathbed in 337.
Worked example: reading the Arch of Constantine
The Senate dedicated an arch near the Colosseum to Constantine in 315. 1. Describe it: much of its sculpture was taken from earlier monuments of Trajan, Hadrian and Marcus Aurelius, with the old emperors' heads recut as Constantine. 2. Read the inscription: it credits his victory to "the inspiration of the divinity" and his own greatness of mind, without naming any god. 3. Ask who wrote it: a Senate still largely pagan, honouring a Christian-leaning emperor. 4. Interpret: the vague wording let Christians and pagans each read their own god into it, and the reused sculptures linked Constantine to Rome's best emperors. 5. Conclude: the arch shows a careful balancing act, not a clean break.
A new capital in the east
Constantine refounded the old Greek city of Byzantium on the Bosporus as Constantinople and dedicated it in 330. The site was easy to defend, commanded the straits linking the Black Sea to the Aegean, and lay between the two most pressured frontiers, the lower Danube and the Euphrates. It received a senate, a hippodrome, churches and statues gathered from across the empire. Its Greek-speaking eastern hinterland was richer and more urban than the west. In the early fifth century, massive land walls made the city almost impregnable; they protected it for about a thousand years.
Emperors and the Church
Christian emperors took charge of Church unity. In 325 Constantine summoned the Council of Nicaea, the first council meant to speak for the whole Church, to settle a dispute over the teaching of the priest Arius that the Son was created by God the Father. The council condemned Arius and issued a creed declaring the Son of the same substance as the Father. Constantine's nephew Julian tried to revive the old cults during his short reign of 361 to 363. Theodosius I made Nicene Christianity the official faith in 380 and banned pagan sacrifice in the early 390s. The Theodosian Code of 438, ordered by Theodosius II, gathered imperial laws issued since Constantine.
Goths, Huns and Vandals
In 376, Goths fleeing the Huns, steppe nomads who had swept west, were allowed across the Danube; mistreated by Roman officials, they revolted and in 378 killed the emperor Valens and much of his army at Adrianople. Rome increasingly made treaties with such groups, settling them as federated allies, foederati, who fought for Rome under their own leaders. In 410 the Gothic leader Alaric sacked Rome itself, shocking the Mediterranean world. Vandals and others crossed the Rhine in about 406, and the Vandals took Carthage in 439. Roman rule in Britain ended around 410. Attila's Hun empire raided both halves before collapsing after his death in 453.
Two halves, two fates
After Theodosius I died in 395, his sons divided rule: Arcadius in Constantinople and Honorius in the west, which was soon governed from Ravenna. The halves were never formally separated, but their fortunes diverged. The west lost province after province, and with them its tax revenue, while generals of mixed or non-Roman origin held real power. In 476 the general Odoacer deposed the boy emperor Romulus Augustulus and sent the imperial regalia to Constantinople, a date later treated as the end of the Western Empire. Franks, Visigoths, Vandals and Ostrogoths ruled the west, while the Eastern Empire, which historians call Byzantine, lasted until 1453.
Worked example: why did the West fall but not the East?
Weigh the main explanations. 1. Geography: the east's vulnerable river frontier was shorter, and Constantinople was nearly impossible to capture. 2. Wealth: the eastern provinces were richer and more urban, so the east could pay armies and buy off invaders. 3. A spiral of loss: each province lost in the west, such as Vandal Africa, cut revenue and made defence harder. 4. Politics: western emperors were often figureheads for rival generals. 5. Interpretation: Peter Brown stresses transformation, while Peter Heather and Bryan Ward-Perkins argue that invasions caused a real, violent collapse with falling living standards. 6. Conclude: most historians combine these causes rather than naming one.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, treating 476 as the end of the Roman Empire: the eastern half lasted until 1453 and called itself Roman. Second, imagining two separate empires from 395: the halves were administrative divisions of one empire. Third, thinking Constantine made Christianity the official religion: Theodosius I did, in 380. Fourth, picturing the Huns as the main invaders of Rome itself: their pressure pushed Goths into the empire. Fifth, assuming everyone agrees Rome simply declined: historians still debate decline, transformation and violent collapse.
Key takeaways
Late antiquity, roughly the third to the eighth century, saw the Roman world remade. After the third-century crisis, Diocletian's tetrarchy and reforms restored order, and Constantine, victor at the Milvian Bridge in 312, favoured Christianity and dedicated Constantinople in 330. Emperors ran Church councils from Nicaea in 325, and Theodosius I made Nicene Christianity official in 380. After 395 the richer, better-defended east survived, while the west, pressed by Goths, Vandals and Huns, fragmented into kingdoms after 476. Historians debate whether this was decline, transformation or collapse.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Roughly the third to the eighth century CE
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What was the main idea behind Diocletian's tetrarchy?
Question 2 of 5
Why is the inscription on the Arch of Constantine worded so vaguely about religion?
Question 3 of 5
Which advantage helps explain why the eastern half of the empire survived?
Question 4 of 5
What happened in 476 CE?
Question 5 of 5
How do Peter Heather and Bryan Ward-Perkins differ from Peter Brown on the end of the western empire?
