World History › Section T · Industry and empire › Topic T.4

Exploitation and resistance

Colonial rule was built to extract wealth, and it often did so through violence, hunger and disease. Colonised peoples answered in many ways: working within the system, petitioning, boycotting and taking up arms. This topic looks at both sides.

Profit, force and response

The topics Motives and means of imperialism and Colonial empires showed why and where empires were built. Once in place, colonial governments needed revenue, labour and exports, and they had the guns to demand them. Yet colonised people were never simply victims. Some cooperated for safety or advantage, many resisted quietly by working slowly or fleeing, and others fought. Historians now study these responses as choices made by people with their own goals, not just as reactions to Europeans.

The Congo Free State

Leopold II ruled the Congo Free State as his personal property from 1885 to 1908. When world demand for rubber soared in the 1890s, his officials and concession companies set village quotas for wild rubber. Soldiers of the Force Publique, an African army under European officers, held women and children hostage until men delivered, flogged the slow and killed resisters, cutting off hands as proof. No census exists, so estimates of the population loss from violence, famine and disease range from about one million, in some demographers' work, to the ten million suggested by the writer Adam Hochschild. The African American historian George Washington Williams protested in 1890, and later campaigns by E. D. Morel and Roger Casement led Belgium to annex the colony in 1908.

Taxes, forced labour and hunger

The Congo differed from other colonies in degree more than in kind. Across Africa, governments demanded hut or head taxes payable in cash, which pushed people into mines, plantations or cash-crop farming; in Sierra Leone the hut tax sparked an armed rising in 1898. French officials required unpaid labour on roads and railways. Cash crops took land from food. In India, droughts in 1876-1878 and 1896-1902 brought famines that killed many millions; the historian Mike Davis puts the toll at about 12 to 29 million. He argues that colonial policy, such as continuing grain exports, turned drought into mass death; others give more weight to the droughts' severity, though few defend the relief policies.

Disease and ecological disaster

Empire moved microbes as well as goods. Measles, brought to Fiji in 1875, killed an estimated quarter of the population. In India, railways and steamships helped spread cholera and, from 1896, bubonic plague. Rinderpest, a cattle disease, is commonly traced to cattle shipped into the Horn of Africa by Italian forces around 1887. By estimates, it killed some 80 to 90 percent of cattle across much of eastern and southern Africa in the 1890s, starving herding peoples such as the Maasai. As herds and people vanished, bush spread, and with it the tsetse flies that carry sleeping sickness.

Cooperation and intermediaries

Empires could not run without local people. Clerks, interpreters, teachers, police and soldiers, such as Indian sepoys and African askaris, made up most of the colonial state. Under indirect rule, which Frederick Lugard used in northern Nigeria, chiefs and emirs governed for the British. People cooperated for many reasons: fear, pay, education for their children, protection from stronger neighbours, or sincere Christian faith. Some used their positions to shield their communities; others exploited them. Historians therefore prefer the word intermediaries to the blunter collaborators, and note that many later nationalists came from this educated group.

Worked example: Moshoeshoe writes to the governor

In 1858, Moshoeshoe I, king of the Basotho in southern Africa, wrote to Sir George Grey, the British governor at the Cape, after war with Boer settlers. 1. Author: a skilled ruler who had built a kingdom by diplomacy and war. 2. Audience: the governor, who had agreed to arbitrate between the Basotho and the Boers. 3. Claim: Moshoeshoe says he had ordered that no farms be burnt, and struck back only after Boers burned villages and crops. 4. Purpose: to appear restrained and reasonable, and so win a fair settlement. 5. Outcome: after losing land in later wars, he sought British protection, granted in 1868. 6. Conclusion: diplomacy was a form of resistance; his kingdom survives as Lesotho.

Armed resistance in Africa

Many Africans fought. Samori Touré resisted the French in West Africa until his capture in 1898. In German South West Africa, the Herero rose in 1904 and the Nama soon after. General Lothar von Trotha ordered the Herero driven into the desert and killed, and survivors were held in camps; historians estimate that between half and 80 percent of the Herero and about half of the Nama died. Germany formally called it genocide in 2021. In German East Africa, the Maji Maji war of 1905-1907 united many peoples against forced cotton growing, inspired by sacred water believed to turn bullets. German forces burned crops, and an estimated 75,000 to 300,000 people died, mostly of famine.

China: the Boxers and the 1911 revolution

By the 1890s many northern Chinese resented foreign privileges, missionaries' interference in local disputes, and cheap imports, while drought brought hunger. In 1899 the Righteous and Harmonious Fists, called Boxers by foreigners, began attacking missionaries and, above all, Chinese Christians, killing tens of thousands. In June 1900 the Qing court backed them and declared war; an eight-nation force relieved the besieged Beijing legations after about 55 days. The Boxer Protocol of 1901 imposed an indemnity of 450 million taels. Many Chinese concluded the dynasty could not defend them, and in 1911 revolutionaries overthrew it; Sun Yat-sen became provisional president of the new republic in 1912.

The Philippine-American War

Filipinos had rebelled against Spain from 1896, and in June 1898 Emilio Aguinaldo declared independence. When the United States decided to keep the islands, war broke out in February 1899. After defeats in open battle, Filipino forces turned to guerrilla war, and American troops burned villages, tortured captives and forced civilians into guarded zones. Aguinaldo was captured in 1901, and Washington proclaimed the war ended in 1902, though fighting went on in some regions. About 4,200 US soldiers died; estimates of Filipino deaths, most of them civilians killed by violence, hunger and disease, commonly run to 200,000 or more.

Worked example: Naoroji's drain argument

Analyse how educated Indians challenged British rule. 1. Author: Dadabhai Naoroji, a Parsi merchant and scholar, a founder of the Indian National Congress in 1885, elected to the British Parliament in 1892. 2. Claim: in Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901) he argued that Britain drained India's wealth through salaries, pensions and interest paid in Britain. 3. Method: he used official statistics and appealed to British ideals of fair play. 4. Debate: economic historians still argue over how large the drain was and what India got in return. 5. Effect: such ideas fed protests, and after Britain partitioned Bengal in 1905, Congress backed a swadeshi boycott of British goods. 6. Conclusion: argument and economic pressure became powerful weapons.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating the Congo as unique: it was extreme, but taxes, forced labour and violence were common across colonies. Second, quoting a single, exact Congo death toll; estimates vary widely. Third, picturing colonised peoples as passive, when they petitioned, boycotted, fled and fought. Fourth, labelling every intermediary a traitor; motives varied. Fifth, assuming the Boxers mainly killed foreigners, when most victims were Chinese Christians. Sixth, placing Gandhi at the head of the 1905 swadeshi campaign; he was then in South Africa and returned to India in 1915.

Key takeaways

Colonial rule extracted labour and wealth, most brutally in Leopold's Congo, but also through taxes, forced labour and cash crops elsewhere. Famine, measles, plague and rinderpest followed empire. Local intermediaries ran much of the colonial state for many reasons. Resistance took many forms: Moshoeshoe's diplomacy, the Herero, Nama and Maji Maji wars, the Boxers and the 1911 revolution in China, the Philippine-American War, and the Indian National Congress, Naoroji's drain argument and the swadeshi boycott.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Congo Free State

Leopold II's personal colony, 1885-1908

Rubber quotas enforced by terror.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why do historians give a range rather than one figure for population loss in the Congo Free State?

Question 2 of 5

How did hut or head taxes payable in cash serve colonial economies?

Question 3 of 5

Why do historians often prefer the word intermediaries to collaborators?

Question 4 of 5

Who were most of the people killed by the Boxers in 1899-1901?

Question 5 of 5

What did Dadabhai Naoroji's drain argument claim?

← Previous topicNext topic →