World History › Section I · Islam and the caliphates › Topic I.3
Islamization and religious rule
In 750 a revolution replaced the Umayyads with the Abbasids, who built Baghdad and sponsored a great age of learning. This topic follows how religious authority, the Sunni-Shia divide and the slow conversion of a mostly non-Muslim population took shape.
The Abbasid revolution
In 747 a revolt broke out in Khurasan, led by Abu Muslim, a figure of uncertain origin, under black banners. The movement promised rule by a member of Muhammad's family, and many of Ali's supporters joined it. Power went instead to the descendants of Muhammad's uncle al-Abbas. Abu al-Abbas was proclaimed caliph in Kufa in 749, and in 750 his forces crushed the Umayyads at the Zab River. Most of the Umayyad family was killed, but one prince, Abd al-Rahman, escaped to Spain and founded an Umayyad emirate at Córdoba in 756.
Baghdad and Persian ways
In 762 the caliph al-Mansur founded a new capital, Baghdad, on the Tigris in Iraq. Its core was a walled Round City with the palace and great mosque at the centre. The capital now lay near Iran, whose people had backed the revolution, and Persian traditions shaped the court: elaborate ceremony, a secluded caliph and powerful ministers called viziers, such as the Barmakid family under Harun al-Rashid, who ruled from 786 to 809. Baghdad grew into a vast city at the meeting point of trade from the Persian Gulf, Syria and Central Asia.
The translation movement
From the late eighth to the tenth century, caliphs, officials and wealthy families paid scholars to translate Greek, Syriac, Persian and Sanskrit works into Arabic. Paper, made in the Islamic world from the eighth century, made books cheaper. Translators, many of them Christians, rendered Aristotle, Galen, Euclid and Ptolemy; the Christian physician Hunayn ibn Ishaq, who died in 873, translated much of Galen's medicine. Scholars did not just copy. Around the 820s al-Khwarizmi wrote a book on solving equations whose title gave Europe the word algebra; his name gave us algorithm. The House of Wisdom of the caliph al-Ma'mun was probably a palace library rather than a university.
Worked example: why translate?
1. Practical needs: officials wanted astronomy for calendars and prayer times, mathematics for surveying and taxes, and medicine for the court. 2. Ideology: the historian Dimitri Gutas argues that early Abbasids presented themselves as heirs of the Persian kings, who in Persian tradition had gathered the world's wisdom. 3. Debate: Muslims arguing with Christians and others about God found Aristotle's logic useful. 4. Prestige: patrons competed to fund rare books. 5. Means: paper, wealth and multilingual scholars existed in one empire. 6. Conclude: translation met the needs of a new imperial society, not merely a love of old books.
Sunni and Shia
The dispute over leadership hardened into two main traditions. The Shia, from shiat Ali, "the party of Ali", held that leadership belonged to Ali and his descendants with Fatima, Muhammad's daughter. In 680 Ali's son Husayn was killed with a small band of followers at Karbala in Iraq by an Umayyad army, an event Shia Muslims mourn every year on Ashura. Shia Muslims came to follow a line of imams, divinely guided leaders from Ali's family. The Sunni, from sunna, the practice of the Prophet, accepted the first caliphs and looked to scholars for religious guidance. Both share the Quran and the Five Pillars; Sunnis are the large majority today.
The ulama and the caliph
Religious authority passed to the ulama, scholars of the Quran, hadith and law, known as sharia. In the ninth century they collected and sifted hadith; al-Bukhari, who died in 870, compiled the most respected Sunni collection. Schools of law formed around great teachers. A test case came in 833, when al-Ma'mun began the mihna, an inquisition requiring judges and scholars to declare that the Quran was created rather than eternal. The scholar Ahmad ibn Hanbal refused and was imprisoned and flogged. The caliphs abandoned the policy by about 850. Afterwards caliphs governed, but the ulama, not the caliph, defined belief and law for Sunni Muslims.
A caliphate in pieces
The Abbasids never ruled Spain, and from the ninth century local dynasties took over provinces while still naming the caliph. Caliphs came to rely on Turkish slave soldiers, moving the capital to Samarra from 836 to 892, but the soldiers often controlled the caliphs. In 909 the Fatimids, Shia rulers claiming descent from Fatima, declared a rival caliphate in North Africa and later founded Cairo in 969. In 945 the Buyids, a Shia dynasty from northern Iran, took Baghdad itself. Abbasid caliphs survived, mostly as figureheads, until the Mongols sacked Baghdad in 1258, yet Islamic culture flourished across these many courts.
Life as a dhimmi
For centuries most people under Muslim rule were Christians, Jews or Zoroastrians. As dhimmis they paid the jizya and ran their own affairs; community courts judged family law. Restrictions grew over time. The so-called Pact of Umar, attributed to the second caliph but probably shaped later, forbade new churches, public processions and bearing arms, and required distinctive dress; enforcement varied by ruler and place. Marriage law favoured conversion: a Muslim man could marry a Christian or Jewish woman, and their children were Muslim, whereas the law forbade a Muslim woman to take a non-Muslim husband.
Worked example: counting converts
How fast did people convert? 1. The problem: no census records religion. 2. The method: the historian Richard Bulliet studied family trees in medieval biographical dictionaries and noted when families switched from Persian or Christian names to distinctively Muslim ones, such as Muhammad and Ahmad. 3. The result: in Iran, conversion started slowly, sped up in the ninth century and produced a Muslim majority by about the tenth. 4. The limits: the dictionaries record mostly urban, educated families, so peasants may have converted at a different pace. 5. Conclude: conversion took centuries, and Muslims long ruled a non-Muslim majority.
Arabic and Islam: two processes
Islamization, adopting the faith, and Arabization, adopting the language, did not always move together. In Egypt and Syria, Arabic spread faster than Islam: Christians spoke and wrote it daily while keeping Coptic or Syriac for worship. In 854 Paul Alvarus, a Christian of Córdoba, complained that young Christians preferred Arabic poetry to Latin learning. Iran shows the reverse. Most Iranians became Muslim, yet Persian survived, written in Arabic script, and around 1010 the poet Ferdowsi completed the Shahnameh, a Persian epic of Iran's kings. Many non-Muslims also took up the elite's fashions, Arabic names and Islamic building styles, to the unease of their religious leaders.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking the Abbasids rewarded Ali's family: they took power for al-Abbas's line, disappointing many Shia. Second, imagining the conquered lands became Muslim at once: conversion took centuries. Third, treating Arabization and Islamization as the same: Christians adopted Arabic, while Iranians adopted Islam but kept Persian. Fourth, picturing the House of Wisdom as a university: it was probably a library. Fifth, assuming Muslims only preserved Greek learning: they corrected and extended it, as algebra shows. Sixth, assuming every rule in the Pact of Umar was always enforced.
Key takeaways
The Abbasids overthrew the Umayyads in 750 with support from Khurasan and founded Baghdad in 762, where Persian traditions shaped the court. Their elite funded the translation of Greek, Persian and Indian learning into Arabic, which scholars such as al-Khwarizmi extended. The Sunni-Shia divide deepened after Karbala in 680, and the failed mihna left religious authority with the ulama. The caliphate split among rival dynasties, including the Shia Fatimids. Dhimmis kept their faiths under growing restrictions as conversion slowly advanced. Arabic spread faster than Islam in some lands, while Iran became Muslim but kept Persian.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Caliphal dynasty from 750, descended from Muhammad's uncle al-Abbas
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why were many of Ali's supporters disappointed by the Abbasid revolution?
Question 2 of 5
According to Dimitri Gutas, which motive helped drive the Abbasid translation movement?
Question 3 of 5
What was the long-term result of the mihna that began in 833?
Question 4 of 5
What did Richard Bulliet's study of names suggest about conversion in Iran?
Question 5 of 5
Which example shows that Arabization and Islamization could happen separately?
