World History › Section Q · The Atlantic world and a global economy › Topic Q.3

The mercantilist economy

Why did European states fight over trade routes, ban foreign cloth and insist that colonies trade only with them? The answer lies in mercantilism, a set of ideas that treated trade as a contest for a fixed stock of wealth and shaped empires from the 1500s to the late 1700s.

Wealth as a contest

Most European statesmen of the 1500s to 1700s shared a set of assumptions that later writers called mercantilism. Adam Smith named it the mercantile system in 1776, and the word mercantilism came later still. Its core ideas were simple. A state's power rested on its stock of gold and silver, or bullion, which paid for armies and navies. The world's wealth was roughly fixed, so one country's gain was another's loss. To grow rich, a country needed a favourable balance of trade: selling abroad goods worth more than those it bought, so that the difference flowed in as bullion.

The tools of policy

Because trade was seen as a contest, mercantilists expected governments to manage it. They taxed imports with high tariffs and sometimes banned foreign goods outright to shelter home industries. They paid bounties on exports, granted monopolies to favoured companies, and subsidised new workshops so the country could make goods it once bought. Raw materials were to stay at home for domestic manufacturing. Strong navies and merchant fleets protected shipping and kept the profits of carrying goods in national hands. Wages, many mercantilists argued, should stay low, so that goods remained cheap to sell abroad.

Colonies in the system

Colonies fitted this logic neatly. They could supply raw materials that the home country lacked, such as sugar, tobacco, timber, furs and dyes, so no bullion had to be spent buying them from rivals. Colonists in turn formed a protected market for the home country's manufactured goods. To keep these gains, each empire tried to make its colonies trade only with the home country and to stop them making finished goods of their own. The ideal colony produced what the home country needed and bought what the home country made.

Spain's closed fleet system

Spain built the most tightly controlled system. From 1503 the Casa de Contratación in Seville licensed and taxed all trade with the Americas. From the 1560s, armed convoys sailed each year, one to Veracruz in Mexico and one to the Caribbean coast of South America; they met at Havana to sail home together, laden with silver. The crown took a royal fifth of mined silver and controlled mercury, needed to refine it. Silver from Potosí, found in 1545, made Spain rich. The historian Earl Hamilton argued in 1934 that this silver caused Europe's sixteenth-century price rise; many historians now give population growth an equal or larger role.

Colbert's France

France under Louis XIV offers the classic example. Jean-Baptiste Colbert, the king's leading minister from 1661 and controller-general of finances from 1665, raised tariffs on foreign goods in 1664 and 1667 and set up royal manufactures, such as the Gobelins tapestry works and a mirror-glass works that lured craftsmen from Venice. He imposed strict quality rules so French goods would command high prices, founded the French East India Company in 1664, and built up the navy and merchant shipping. An absolute monarch, ruling without a powerful parliament, could direct the economy in ways many rulers could not. This state-led approach is still called Colbertism.

England and the Navigation Acts

England applied mercantilist ideas through Parliament. The Navigation Act of 1651, renewed and extended in 1660, required that goods entering England or its colonies travel in English or colonial ships with mainly English crews. The 1660 act listed enumerated goods, including sugar, tobacco, cotton and indigo, which colonies could ship only to England or other English colonies. A further act in 1663 forced most European goods bound for the colonies to pass through England first. The acts aimed above all at the Dutch, who dominated European shipping, and England fought three wars with the Dutch Republic between 1652 and 1674.

The Dutch and the trading companies

The Dutch Republic was small and short of raw materials, but it became Europe's leading trading nation in the 1600s. Its merchants pioneered the chartered joint-stock company. The Dutch East India Company, or VOC, founded in 1602, held a state monopoly on Dutch trade with Asia and could make treaties, build forts and wage war; its shares traded on the Amsterdam exchange. England's East India Company, chartered in 1600, and the Dutch West India Company of 1621 followed similar models. Monopoly companies stopped national merchants competing against each other abroad, though historians debate how far the Dutch, with their relatively open trade, were mercantilists at all.

Worked example: reading Thomas Mun

Thomas Mun, a director of England's East India Company, wrote England's Treasure by Forraign Trade in the 1620s; his son published it in 1664. 1. Claim: a kingdom grows rich only by selling more to foreigners each year than it buys from them. 2. Context: critics attacked his company for shipping silver to Asia, so Mun argued that only the overall balance mattered, since Asian goods re-exported to Europe brought back more silver than had left. 3. Purpose: he was defending his own company's trade. 4. Value: he states the balance-of-trade idea clearly. 5. Conclusion: the text is a classic statement of mercantilist theory and also a piece of business advocacy.

Worked example: from trade rules to war

Trace how mercantilist rules bred conflict in the Caribbean. 1. Rule: Spain allowed its colonies to trade only through its own licensed fleets, so goods were scarce and dear there. 2. Response: Dutch, English and French smugglers, working from islands such as Curaçao and Jamaica, sold cheaper goods illegally. 3. Opening: the Treaty of Utrecht of 1713 gave Britain the asiento, the right to sell enslaved Africans in Spanish America, plus one shipload of goods a year, which traders used as cover for more smuggling. 4. Enforcement: Spanish coastguards searched British ships; in 1731 one cut off the ear of a captain, Robert Jenkins. 5. Result: in 1739 Britain went to war, the War of Jenkins' Ear. 6. Conclusion: closed markets created both the profits and the anger behind the war.

The critics

In the 1700s writers attacked mercantilism's foundations. In 1752 the Scottish philosopher David Hume argued that piling up bullion defeats itself: as gold and silver flow in, prices rise, exports become dearer and imports cheaper, and the metal flows out again. In The Wealth of Nations of 1776, Adam Smith argued that a nation's wealth lies in the goods and services its people produce, not in its stock of metal. Trade, he said, can benefit both partners, specialisation raises output, and monopolies and protective tariffs mainly enrich favoured merchants at consumers' expense. In 1817 David Ricardo added the theory of comparative advantage.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming mercantilists called themselves that; the label was applied later by critics and historians. Second, thinking mercantilism was a single written doctrine, when it was a loose set of shared assumptions applied differently by each state. Third, believing colonial trade rules always worked: smuggling was widespread. Fourth, crediting Adam Smith with comparative advantage, which David Ricardo set out in 1817. Fifth, forgetting the human cost: the drive to extract colonial wealth fell hardest on Indigenous workers and enslaved Africans.

Key takeaways

Mercantilism held that power rested on bullion, that wealth was fixed, and that states should seek a favourable balance of trade through tariffs, bans, subsidies and monopolies. Colonies were to supply raw materials and buy home manufactures. Spain ran a closed fleet system; Colbert's France directed industry; England's Navigation Acts targeted Dutch shipping; and chartered companies such as the VOC held trading monopolies. Closed markets bred smuggling and wars. Hume and Smith argued that bullion was not wealth and that trade could benefit both sides.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Mercantilism

Belief that state power rests on bullion won through trade surpluses

Dominant from the 1500s to the late 1700s.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

According to mercantilist thinking, how should a country grow richer?

Question 2 of 5

What was the main aim of England's Navigation Acts of 1651 and 1660?

Question 3 of 5

What was David Hume's main objection to piling up gold and silver?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement fits Adam Smith's view in The Wealth of Nations?

Question 5 of 5

Why did smuggling flourish in Spain's American colonies?

← Previous topicNext topic →