World History › Section T · Industry and empire › Topic T.2
Motives and means of imperialism
Between about 1870 and 1914, a handful of industrial powers took control of most of Africa and much of Asia and the Pacific. This topic asks why they wanted empires, how they justified them, and what made conquest possible.
A new imperialism
Imperialism means extending a state's rule or influence over other peoples and lands, whether directly or indirectly. Europeans had built empires since the 1400s, but historians call the burst of expansion after about 1870 the new imperialism. It was faster and wider: Britain, France, Germany, Belgium, Italy, the United States and Japan all joined in. Most of the new colonies were meant to be ruled and exploited, not settled. Exceptions such as Algeria and southern Africa drew many European settlers, but they were not the norm. Rule took several forms, from outright colonies to protectorates, where local rulers kept their thrones under foreign control.
Raw materials and new tastes
The Second Industrial Revolution, the previous topic, created hungry new industries. Tyres and electrical insulation needed rubber, wiring needed copper, tin cans needed tin, and machines needed palm oil as a lubricant. Textile mills still wanted cotton, especially after the American Civil War disrupted supplies. Consumer tastes mattered too. Workers drank more sweetened tea and coffee, chocolate became popular, and middle-class homes filled with ivory piano keys, combs and billiard balls. Much of this came from tropical lands that industrial countries could not supply themselves, and businesses wanted it at low prices.
Markets, investment and the economic argument
Industrialists also wanted protected markets for their goods and places to invest surplus capital. In Imperialism (1902), the British economist J. A. Hobson argued that empire served a narrow class of investors, not the nation. In 1917 the Russian revolutionary Vladimir Lenin went further, calling imperialism the highest stage of capitalism. Critics of this economic interpretation point out that most British overseas investment went to the United States, Latin America and the settler dominions, not the new tropical colonies, many of which cost more to run than they returned. Profit mattered, but it cannot explain everything.
Strategy, rivalry and prestige
Steamships needed coaling stations and ports, and navies needed bases. Britain guarded the sea route to India, its most valuable possession, which made Egypt and the Suez Canal vital. Rivalry fed on itself: a power might claim land mainly to stop a rival from taking it. Nationalism made colonies a mark of greatness, so newly unified Germany and Italy wanted their share. The historians Ronald Robinson and John Gallagher argued that crises on the spot, such as Urabi's revolt in Egypt in 1881-1882, often pulled Britain into new conquests, more than any master plan made in London.
Ideas of superiority
Racist ideas gave conquest a moral cover. Social Darwinism misapplied Charles Darwin's theory of evolution to peoples and nations, claiming that stronger races were meant to rule weaker ones. So-called race science ranked humanity by skull size and skin colour. The French spoke of a civilising mission: the duty, as they saw it, to spread their language, law and culture. In 1885 Jules Ferry, a former French prime minister, told parliament that superior races had a right over inferior ones because they had a duty to civilise them. Some imperialists sincerely believed this; for others it was a convenient excuse.
Missionaries and their converts
Catholic and Protestant missionaries followed and sometimes preceded the flag. They built schools and hospitals, translated the Bible into African and Asian languages, and campaigned against slavery. They also attacked customs they judged immoral, demanding that converts give up polygamy, ancestor veneration and traditional dress, which could split families. Converts were not passive. Many Africans read the Bible in their own way, and from the 1880s some founded independent churches led by Africans, rejecting missionary control while keeping the faith. Mission schools also trained many of the later leaders of anti-colonial movements.
Worked example: reading "The White Man's Burden"
Analyse a famous imperial source. 1. Author and date: the British writer Rudyard Kipling published the poem in 1899. 2. Audience: it urged Americans to rule the Philippines, which the United States had just taken from Spain. 3. Message: empire is a heavy, thankless duty that white nations owe to supposedly childlike and unruly peoples. 4. Silences: it says nothing of rubber, markets or bases, and gives the colonised no voice. 5. Reception: anti-imperialists answered it with parodies, and later critics read it as a summary of imperial racism. 6. Conclusion: the poem is strong evidence of how imperialists wished to see themselves, not of what colonised people experienced.
The tools of empire
The historian Daniel Headrick argued that new technologies made conquest cheap enough to be worth attempting. Malaria had long killed Europeans in tropical Africa. By the mid-1800s, doctors found that regular doses of quinine, from the bark of the Andean cinchona tree, could prevent the disease, and Dutch plantations in Java later made it plentiful. Shallow-draught steamboats pushed up rivers such as the Niger and the Congo, carried in pieces past waterfalls and reassembled. Railways moved troops and goods inland, and the telegraph let officials in London or Paris send orders to distant colonies within hours.
The firepower gap
Weapons changed fastest of all. By the 1870s European armies carried breech-loading rifles, soon followed by repeating rifles and smokeless powder. In 1884 Hiram Maxim, an American-born inventor working in Britain, built the first fully automatic machine gun, which could fire about 500 rounds a minute. In 1890 the European powers agreed at Brussels to limit sales of modern firearms to most of Africa. The poet Hilaire Belloc mocked this imbalance in satirical verse of 1898: "Whatever happens, we have got / The Maxim Gun, and they have not." Where Africans did acquire modern rifles, as Ethiopia did, the balance shifted.
Worked example: the Battle of Omdurman
Explain the result of a lopsided battle. 1. Context: in September 1898, an Anglo-Egyptian army under Herbert Kitchener met the forces of the Mahdist state near Omdurman in Sudan. 2. Numbers: the Mahdist army was roughly twice as large. 3. Weapons: Kitchener had Maxim guns, artillery, magazine rifles and gunboats on the Nile. 4. Result: an estimated 10,000 or more Mahdist fighters died, against fewer than 50 on Kitchener's side. 5. Qualification: most of his soldiers were Egyptian and Sudanese, and a railway he built across the desert supplied them. 6. Conclusion: industrial firepower decided the battle, but local troops and logistics made it possible.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, reducing imperialism to one motive: economics, strategy, prestige and racist ideas worked together, and historians weigh them differently. Second, treating Hobson's and Lenin's economic theory as settled fact. Third, assuming new colonies were settler colonies like those of earlier centuries; most were not. Fourth, picturing missionaries' converts as passive, when many reshaped Christianity and founded their own churches. Fifth, believing technology guaranteed victory everywhere; local soldiers, allies and supplies mattered, and Ethiopia showed that a well-armed African state could win.
Key takeaways
The new imperialism of about 1870-1914 brought most of Africa and much of Asia and the Pacific under industrial powers. Motives included raw materials, markets, investment, bases, rivalry and prestige; Hobson and Lenin stressed capitalism, while Robinson and Gallagher stressed crises on the spot. Social Darwinism and the civilising mission justified rule, and missionaries spread Christianity, which converts adapted. Quinine, steamboats, railways, the telegraph and the Maxim gun made conquest possible, as Omdurman in 1898 showed.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Extending a state's rule or influence over other peoples and lands
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
How did most colonies of the new imperialism differ from earlier settler colonies?
Question 2 of 5
What is the main criticism of Hobson's and Lenin's economic explanation of imperialism?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement about missionaries and their converts is best supported?
Question 4 of 5
Why is Kipling's "The White Man's Burden" weak evidence of colonised people's experience?
Question 5 of 5
What does the Battle of Omdurman in 1898 best illustrate?
