World History › Section K · The medieval West and the Crusades › Topic K.1

The post-Roman West in the early Middle Ages

After Roman rule ended in the west, Germanic kings, Christian clergy and Roman landowners built a new society together. This topic follows that society from the Ostrogoths and Franks to Charlemagne, the Vikings, the bonds of lord and vassal, and the very different world of al-Andalus.

Three traditions, one new society

As the topic on the eastward shift of late antiquity showed, the western empire broke into kingdoms during the fifth century. The early Middle Ages, roughly 500 to 1000, are sometimes still called the "Dark Ages", but most historians now avoid the label. Cities shrank and trade thinned, but the period also saw a new society form from three traditions: Roman law, Latin and landholding; the Christian Church; and the warrior customs of the Germanic peoples, whose leaders won followers by sharing out land and loot.

Theodoric and the Ostrogoths

Theodoric, king of the Ostrogoths, ruled Italy from 493 until his death in 526. He kept Roman officials, repaired aqueducts and city walls, and employed Roman aristocrats such as the scholar Boethius. Yet a gap remained: the Goths were Arian Christians, who held that the Son was not equal to the Father, while most Italians were Catholics. Late in his reign Theodoric had Boethius executed on a charge of treason. After his death, Justinian's long war of reconquest and then the Lombard invasion of 568 wrecked his kingdom.

Clovis and the Franks

The most lasting kingdom was that of the Franks. Clovis, of the Merovingian dynasty, became king in about 481 and by his death in 511 ruled most of Gaul, defeating the Visigoths at Vouillé in 507. Unlike most Germanic kings he converted directly to Catholic Christianity, the faith of his Gallo-Roman subjects, so bishops and landowners backed him. His successors divided the kingdom among their sons, which bred civil wars. Real power passed to officials called mayors of the palace. One of them, Charles Martel, defeated a Muslim army from al-Andalus near Tours and Poitiers in about 732.

Worked example: Gregory of Tours on Clovis

Our main account of Clovis's conversion comes from Gregory, bishop of Tours, who wrote his Histories in the late sixth century. 1. Note the gap: Gregory wrote about eighty years after Clovis died. 2. Read the story: Clovis's Catholic wife Clotilde urged him to convert, and he vowed to do so if Christ gave him victory in a desperate battle against the Alamanni. 3. Spot the model: Gregory calls Clovis a new Constantine, echoing the vision story told of that emperor. 4. Check the date: Gregory implies about 496, but a letter from a bishop of the time leads many historians to prefer about 508. 5. Conclude: the conversion is real, but its details were shaped to teach a lesson about Catholic kingship.

Pepin, the pope and Charlemagne

In 751 the mayor Pepin the Short deposed the last Merovingian king, with the approval of Pope Zacharias, and in 754 Pope Stephen II anointed him. In return Pepin defeated the Lombards and gave the pope lands around Rome, the Donation of Pepin, the basis of the Papal States. His son Charlemagne (king 768 to 814) campaigned almost every year, conquering the Lombards in 774 and forcing the Saxons to accept Christianity after decades of brutal war. His court revived learning: the scholar Alcuin of York led schools, and scribes copied classical texts in a clear new script, Carolingian minuscule.

Worked example: the coronation of 800

On Christmas Day 800, Pope Leo III crowned Charlemagne emperor in St Peter's, Rome. 1. The pope's need: Leo had been attacked by Roman enemies in 799 and depended on Frankish protection. 2. The Byzantine angle: Constantinople was ruled by the empress Irene, and some in the west argued that a woman could not hold the imperial throne. 3. Charlemagne's view: his biographer Einhard claims he would not have entered the church had he known the pope's plan, though historians doubt he was truly surprised. 4. Effects: Byzantium was offended, recognising him as emperor only in 812, and popes later argued that emperors received their crown from them.

Monks, missions and minorities

Benedict of Nursia wrote a rule for monks in the sixth century that balanced prayer, work and study; monasteries copied books, ran schools and farmed large estates. Women also led religious lives: Radegund, a Frankish queen, left her husband and founded a convent at Poitiers. Pope Gregory the Great sent the monk Augustine to Kent in 597, where King Æthelberht, whose Frankish wife Bertha was already Christian, accepted baptism. Jewish communities lived under Christian kings with growing insecurity; Visigothic Spain passed laws forcing Jews to convert or leave.

The empire divides; raiders arrive

Charlemagne's son Louis the Pious struggled to control his sons, and in 843 the Treaty of Verdun split the empire into western, middle and eastern kingdoms, roughly the seeds of France and Germany. Raiders then struck a weakened west. Vikings from Scandinavia sacked the monastery of Lindisfarne in 793, conquered much of England after 865, and settled Normandy in 911; they were also traders and settled Iceland and Greenland. Magyar horsemen from the steppe raided until Otto I defeated them at Lechfeld in 955, and Muslim raiders from North Africa took Sicily and sacked churches outside Rome in 846.

Lords, vassals and serfs

Insecurity pushed people into bonds of protection. A lord granted land, a fief, to a vassal, who swore loyalty and owed military service, and great lords were in turn vassals of kings. Historians traditionally call this feudalism, but scholars such as Elizabeth Brown and Susan Reynolds have argued that the label imposes a neat system on practices that varied widely by region and century. On the manor, most peasants were serfs: unlike enslaved people they could not be sold, but they were tied to the land, owed labour on the lord's fields, and needed his permission to leave or marry.

Al-Andalus and the convivencia debate

In 711 Muslim armies from North Africa overran Visigothic Spain, though Christian kingdoms survived in the north. Abd al-Rahman I, an Umayyad prince who escaped the Abbasid takeover, became emir at Córdoba in 756, and Abd al-Rahman III proclaimed himself caliph in 929. Córdoba grew into one of Europe's largest cities. Christians and Jews were protected subjects who paid a special tax; many Christians adopted Arabic and were called Mozarabs. Historians debate how harmonious this was. Américo Castro popularised the term convivencia, "living together", while critics stress inequality and violence.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling the whole period a "Dark Age": learning, law and trade survived, and new institutions formed. Second, thinking Charlemagne was crowned emperor of a revived Roman state that Byzantium accepted: Constantinople objected. Third, treating feudalism as one uniform system: practices differed from place to place, and some historians reject the term. Fourth, confusing serfs with enslaved people. Fifth, seeing Vikings only as raiders: they also traded and settled. Sixth, imagining al-Andalus as either pure harmony or pure oppression: historians still argue.

Key takeaways

Post-Roman western Europe blended Roman, Christian and Germanic traditions. Theodoric ruled Ostrogothic Italy through Roman officials, but religious difference divided Goths and Italians. Clovis's Catholic conversion bound the Franks to their subjects. The Carolingians allied with the popes: Pepin's donation created the Papal States, and Charlemagne was crowned emperor in 800. After the empire split in 843, Viking, Magyar and Muslim raids encouraged bonds of lordship and serfdom. In al-Andalus, Córdoba flourished, and historians debate how peacefully its faiths coexisted.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Early Middle Ages

Roughly 500 to 1000 in western Europe

Historians now avoid the label "Dark Ages".

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why did Clovis's conversion matter more politically than the Christianity of the Goths?

Question 2 of 5

Gregory of Tours calls Clovis "a new Constantine". What should a historian conclude from this?

Question 3 of 5

Which factor helps explain why Pope Leo III crowned Charlemagne emperor in 800?

Question 4 of 5

Why do historians such as Susan Reynolds question the term "feudalism"?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about al-Andalus is best supported by the reading?

← Previous topicNext topic →