World History › Section I · Islam and the caliphates › Topic I.1

The rise and message of Islam

In the early seventh century, while Rome and Persia exhausted each other, a merchant of Mecca began preaching a message of one God. This topic follows Muhammad's life and teaching, and asks how historians know what they know about it.

Mecca and the Hijaz

Earlier topics met Arabia's tribes, the Kaaba, Himyar's monotheism and the Lakhmid and Ghassanid buffer kingdoms. Islam took shape in the Hijaz, the western strip of the peninsula, in the oasis town of Mecca. Mecca's leading tribe, Quraysh, guarded the Kaaba, a shrine housing images of many gods. Pilgrims came in sacred months when fighting was forbidden, which made the town a safe place for markets. Quraysh merchants also ran caravans, though historians debate how large Mecca's trade really was. Jews and Christians lived in Arabia too, so ideas of one God, prophets and a final judgement were already familiar.

Two ways of telling the story

Muslims understand the rise of Islam as God's final revelation to humanity, and their tradition preserves rich accounts of it. Historians also try to reconstruct events from evidence they can test. The main sources are the Quran, which Muslims believe is the word of God revealed to Muhammad; the hadith, reports of his sayings and deeds; and the sira, his biography. The earliest surviving biography, by Ibn Ishaq, who died about 767, was written more than a century after the events and survives in a later edition by Ibn Hisham. This topic gives the traditional account while noting what historians debate.

Muhammad's early life and call

According to tradition, Muhammad was born in Mecca about 570, into the Hashim clan of Quraysh. His father died before his birth and his mother when he was about six, so his grandfather and then his uncle Abu Talib raised him. He worked in the caravan trade and married Khadija, a wealthy widow who employed him. Around 610, while meditating in a cave on Mount Hira, he reported that the angel Gabriel commanded him to recite. Khadija is remembered as the first to accept his message; his young cousin Ali and his friend Abu Bakr were among the earliest converts.

Opposition and the hijra

From about 613 Muhammad preached publicly: there is one God, idols are false, and on the Day of Judgement each person will answer for how they treated the poor, orphans and the weak. Many Quraysh leaders saw a threat to their gods, their shrine and their authority, and weaker believers were persecuted. In about 615 some Muslims took refuge with the Christian king of Aksum. After Khadija and Abu Talib died, Muhammad lost key protection. In 622 he and his followers emigrated to the oasis of Yathrib, later called Medina. This hijra, or emigration, marks year 1 of the Islamic calendar.

The community at Medina

In Medina, Muhammad became arbiter between feuding Arab clans and leader of a new community, the ummah. An agreement known as the Constitution of Medina bound the emigrants from Mecca, the Medinan converts and allied groups, including Jewish clans, to defend one another. Conflict with Mecca followed. Muslims won at Badr in 624, lost at Uhud in 625 and survived a siege of Medina in 627. Relations with Medina's Jewish tribes broke down: two were expelled, and Muslim sources report that the men of a third, Qurayza, were executed after the siege, though historians debate the details and numbers.

Return to Mecca

In 628 Muhammad agreed a truce with Quraysh at Hudaybiyya, which allowed Muslims to make pilgrimage the following year. When the truce broke down, Muslim forces approached Mecca in 630 and the town surrendered with little fighting. Muhammad removed the images from the Kaaba, which Muslims regard as a house of worship of the one God built by Abraham and his son Ishmael. Delegations from tribes across Arabia then came to make agreements with him. Muhammad died in Medina in 632, leaving a community that now dominated much of the peninsula but had no agreed successor.

The message of Islam

Islam means submission to God, and a Muslim is one who submits. Its central belief is that God, Allah in Arabic, is one. The Quran names earlier prophets, including Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses and Jesus, and calls Muhammad the seal of the prophets, the last of the line. Muslims revere him as a human messenger, never as divine. The Quran, in 114 chapters called suras, is in Arabic. Muslims summarise their core duties as the Five Pillars: the declaration of faith (shahada), daily prayer (salat), almsgiving (zakat), fasting in Ramadan (sawm) and, for those able, pilgrimage to Mecca (hajj).

Worked example: reading the Constitution of Medina

The text survives in later works, chiefly Ibn Ishaq's biography. 1. Identify it: an agreement among Muhammad's followers and the clans of Yathrib. 2. Note the content: it calls the believers one community, sets rules for blood-money and ransoms, and states that the Jews of named clans have their religion and the Muslims theirs, with both bound to defend the city. 3. Ask about reliability: it survives only in later copies, but its old-fashioned language and terms, which do not match later Muslim practice, persuade many historians that it is early, perhaps several agreements combined. 4. Conclude: it suggests a broad defensive alliance under Muhammad's leadership.

Worked example: testing the sources

How secure is the traditional story? 1. The gap: biographies come from the mid-eighth century onward, when disputes over leadership and law could shape memories. 2. The challenge: in Hagarism (1977), Patricia Crone and Michael Cook argued that the Muslim accounts could not be trusted and tried to rebuild events from outside sources. 3. Outside evidence: a Syriac chronicle written around 640 records a battle in 634 against the Arabs of Muhammad, confirming that he was remembered as their leader. 4. Physical evidence: radiocarbon tests date some Quran parchment fragments to the seventh century. 5. Conclude: most historians now accept the broad outline but treat details with care.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, imagining Islam began in a land with no knowledge of one God: Jews, Christians and Himyar's kings had brought monotheism to Arabia. Second, describing Muhammad as worshipped by Muslims: he is revered as a prophet, not as divine. Third, dating the Islamic calendar from Muhammad's birth or first revelation: it counts from the hijra of 622. Fourth, treating the traditional biography as an eyewitness record: it was written more than a century later. Fifth, assuming historians reject the tradition outright: most accept its outline while debating details. Sixth, confusing Islam's view of Jesus with Christianity's: the Quran honours him as a prophet.

Key takeaways

Islam arose in the Hijaz, where Quraysh guarded the Kaaba at Mecca. According to tradition, Muhammad, born about 570, began receiving revelations around 610, supported first by Khadija. Facing opposition, his followers emigrated to Medina in 622, the hijra that begins the Islamic calendar. There he led the ummah, fought and then made peace with Mecca, which surrendered in 630, and died in 632. Islam teaches one God, a line of prophets ending with Muhammad, the Quran and the Five Pillars. Historians balance the Muslim tradition, written down later, against outside sources and physical evidence.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Hijaz

The western strip of Arabia, home of Mecca and Medina

Where Islam took shape.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

From which event does the Islamic calendar count its years?

Question 2 of 5

Why do historians treat Ibn Ishaq's biography of Muhammad with some caution?

Question 3 of 5

What does the Constitution of Medina suggest about Muhammad's community there?

Question 4 of 5

How do Muslims regard Muhammad?

Question 5 of 5

Which piece of outside evidence supports the traditional account of Muhammad as a leader of the Arabs?

← Previous topicNext topic →