World History › Section F · Life in the Roman Empire › Topic F.4
Religion in the Roman Empire and early Christianity
Romans shared their world with countless gods and welcomed new ones, yet they persecuted a small new faith. This topic explains how Roman religion worked, why Christians did not fit it, and how Christianity went from a suspect sect to the emperor's favoured faith.
Ritual, priests and the peace of the gods
Roman religion was polytheistic and practical. What mattered most was correct ritual, above all sacrifice and prayer, which kept the pax deorum, the peace between the gods and Rome. Belief and personal feeling mattered less than doing things properly. Many Roman gods were equated with Greek ones, such as Jupiter with Zeus. Priesthoods were held by politicians, and from 12 BCE the emperors held the post of pontifex maximus, chief priest, for nearly four centuries. Six Vestal Virgins tended the sacred fire of Vesta for at least thirty years; a Vestal found guilty of breaking her vow of chastity was buried alive, because her purity was tied to Rome's safety.
Religion at home
Every household had its own gods. The lares protected the house and family and the penates guarded the store cupboard, while the genius was the life-spirit of the head of the household. In Pompeii, many houses had a lararium, a small shrine, often painted with the household gods and a snake, where families made daily offerings of food, wine and incense. Private religion also had a darker side. People wrote curses on thin lead sheets asking gods to punish rivals or thieves; around 130 such tablets were recovered from the sacred spring of the goddess Sulis Minerva at Bath, in Britain, most of them about stolen goods.
Welcoming new gods, within limits
Polytheism made room for newcomers. In 204 BCE, during the war against Hannibal, Rome brought the goddess Magna Mater, the Great Mother, from Asia Minor in the form of a sacred black stone. Across the provinces, Romans paired local gods with their own, as in Sulis Minerva. Openness had limits, though. In 186 BCE the Senate cracked down on the worship of Bacchus, executing many worshippers, because secret night-time meetings outside the control of the state looked like conspiracy. The test was rarely whether a god was foreign. It was whether worshippers seemed loyal and orderly.
The imperial cult
After Julius Caesar's murder, the Senate declared him a god in 42 BCE, and Augustus and many later emperors were deified after death. Worship of the living emperor was handled more carefully, especially in Rome: people sacrificed for the emperor's welfare or honoured his genius, rather than treating him openly as a god. In the Greek east, where rulers had long received divine honours, cities built temples to Rome and Augustus and competed to show loyalty. Sacrifice in honour of the emperor became a test of political loyalty. Vespasian joked about the routine on his deathbed, Suetonius reports: "I think I am becoming a god."
Mystery cults
Some cults offered secret initiation and a personal bond with a god. Isis, an Egyptian goddess, won followers across the empire as a powerful, caring mother who promised help in this life and the next; Pompeii had a temple to her. Mithras, whose name came from Persia, was worshipped by men only, especially soldiers and officials, in small cave-like chambers showing the god killing a bull. Many scholars now see Roman Mithraism as largely a new creation of the empire rather than an imported Persian religion. Initiates rose through grades of membership, but they did not usually reject other gods: these cults added to traditional worship.
Jesus, Paul and the first Christians
Jesus of Nazareth, a Jewish preacher in the Roman province of Judaea, was crucified on the orders of the governor Pontius Pilate around 30 CE. His followers proclaimed that he had risen from the dead and was the Messiah. Paul, a Jew from Tarsus, carried the message to non-Jews in the cities of the eastern Mediterranean; his letters of the 50s CE are the oldest surviving Christian writings. Christians met in private homes for shared meals, prayer and baptism, and called one another brother and sister. The faith spread along trade routes and through urban Jewish communities, drawing women, the poor and the enslaved as well as some of the wealthy.
Why Romans distrusted Christians
Christians worshipped one god and refused to sacrifice to any other, including for the emperor. To Romans this looked like atheism and disloyalty that might break the peace of the gods, so Christians were blamed for disasters. Their private meetings fed rumours of crime. After a great fire in Rome in 64 CE, Tacitus writes, Nero blamed the Christians and had many put to death, some burned as human torches. For two centuries afterwards, persecution was mostly local and occasional, driven by governors and crowds rather than an empire-wide law.
Worked example: Pliny asks Trajan
Around 112 CE Pliny the Younger, governor of Bithynia in Asia Minor, wrote to the emperor Trajan about Christians. 1. Identify the source: official letters between a governor and an emperor. 2. Extract Pliny's practice: he executed those who would not deny being Christian, and freed those who sacrificed and cursed Christ. 3. Note his findings: two enslaved women called deaconesses, questioned under torture, revealed only that Christians met before dawn and sang a hymn to Christ as to a god. 4. Read Trajan's reply: do not hunt Christians or accept anonymous accusations, but punish those convicted who refuse to recant. 5. Conclude: the crime was obstinate refusal, not any proven wrongdoing.
From persecution to toleration
Christian texts honour martyrs such as Perpetua, executed in the arena at Carthage in 203. Empire-wide persecution came only in the third century. In 250, Decius ordered all inhabitants to sacrifice and obtain certificates proving it; examples survive from Egypt. Diocletian's Great Persecution began in 303, with churches destroyed and scriptures burned. Yet Christians kept growing, perhaps to around a tenth of the population by 300, by some estimates. Constantine credited the Christian god for his victory at the Milvian Bridge in 312, and in 313 he and his co-emperor Licinius granted freedom of worship and returned church property. Theodosius I made Nicene Christianity the official faith in 380.
Worked example: why did Christianity spread?
Weigh possible causes. 1. Community: congregations cared for widows, orphans, the sick and the poor, which Roman religion did not organise. 2. Message: a promise of salvation and life after death for anyone, whatever their status. 3. Networks: shared language, safe roads and sea routes, and Jewish communities across the cities helped the message travel. 4. Persecution: rather than stopping growth, martyrs' courage impressed some onlookers. 5. Imperial favour: support after 313 sped growth, but Christians were already numerous. 6. Conclude: most historians see several reinforcing causes.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking Romans persecuted foreign gods as such: they welcomed many and punished only worship that seemed disloyal or disorderly. Second, picturing three centuries of constant, empire-wide persecution: before 250 it was mostly local and sporadic. Third, saying Constantine made Christianity the official religion: he legalised and favoured it; Theodosius I made it official in 380. Fourth, treating mystery cults as exclusive faiths: initiates kept honouring other gods. Fifth, assuming Roman Mithraism was simply Persian religion moved west.
Key takeaways
Roman religion centred on correct ritual that kept the peace of the gods, through public priesthoods, the Vestals, household gods and private magic. Rome absorbed new gods, such as Magna Mater, but punished worship that looked disloyal. Emperors were deified after death and honoured in life. Mystery cults of Isis and Mithras added personal devotion. Christians, who refused sacrifice, faced local persecution from Nero onward and empire-wide persecution under Decius and Diocletian, yet grew until Constantine's toleration of 313 and Theodosius I's establishment of Christianity in 380.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The peace between the gods and Rome
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What did Roman religion treat as most important?
Question 2 of 5
Why did the Roman Senate suppress the worship of Bacchus in 186 BCE?
Question 3 of 5
According to Trajan's reply to Pliny, how should a governor treat Christians?
Question 4 of 5
What best describes persecution of Christians before 250 CE?
Question 5 of 5
What did Constantine and Licinius do in 313?
