World History › Section V · World War I › Topic V.3
Total war
Industrial weapons, mass armies and global empires turned the war of 1914 into something new: a struggle that consumed whole societies and reached far beyond Europe. This topic follows the fighting, the colonial troops and labourers who served, and the genocide carried out under its cover.
What made the war total
In a total war, states commit their people, industry, science and public opinion, and the line between soldier and civilian blurs. Industry now mass-produced weapons of terrible power, conscription supplied armies of millions so that battles could last for months, and empires drew in soldiers, labourers and resources from every continent. Because defenders could move reserves by rail faster than attackers advanced on foot, neither side could win quickly, and the war became a contest of endurance.
The weapons of industrial war
Artillery caused most battlefield casualties, often firing for days before an attack. Machine guns, developed from Hiram Maxim's 1884 design, fired hundreds of rounds a minute, and barbed wire held attackers in their path. Germany used chlorine gas on a large scale near Ypres in April 1915, and both sides soon used phosgene and, from 1917, mustard gas. Gas killed an estimated 90,000 soldiers, a small share of the dead, but it was deeply feared. Britain introduced the tank on the Somme in September 1916, and aircraft moved from scouting to air combat.
Life in the trenches
On the Western Front, lines of trenches ran some 700 kilometres. Soldiers rotated between front-line, support and reserve trenches, usually spending only days at a time in the front line. Mud, rats, lice and cold were constant, and standing in water caused trench foot. Most days brought boredom broken by shelling and sniping. In December 1914, soldiers in parts of the British and German lines held an unofficial Christmas truce; commanders worked to prevent repeats, and only small ones followed. Many men suffered what doctors from 1915 called "shell shock", a psychological injury now linked to post-traumatic stress.
Worked example: the logic of attrition in 1916
1. The problem: breakthroughs failed, so commanders sought to wear the enemy down. 2. Verdun: Germany attacked in February 1916. Its commander, Erich von Falkenhayn, later claimed he had aimed to bleed France's army white, but no copy of the memorandum he cited has been found, so historians debate whether this was his plan or a post-war excuse. The battle ran until December, with roughly 700,000 casualties in all. 3. The Somme: launched on 1 July partly to relieve Verdun, it cost the British about 57,000 casualties on the first day, nearly 20,000 of them dead. 4. Result: by November, the Somme had cost over a million casualties for a few miles. Conclusion: attrition fell on both sides.
War at sea
From 1914 the Royal Navy blockaded Germany, cutting its imports of food and raw materials. The two battle fleets met only once in strength, at Jutland in the North Sea on 31 May and 1 June 1916. Britain lost more ships and men, but the German fleet seldom came out in strength again. Germany turned to U-boats, submarines that sank merchant ships without warning. After protests over sinkings such as the Lusitania in 1915, Germany held back, then resumed unrestricted submarine warfare in February 1917, gambling it could starve Britain first. Convoys cut losses, and the gamble helped bring the United States in, as the US History course explains.
Beyond the Western Front
In 1915 Britain and France tried to force the Dardanelles and knock the Ottomans out. Naval attacks failed, and Allied troops, including Australians and New Zealanders, landed at Gallipoli on 25 April, only to be pinned on the beaches. Ottoman defenders, among them the commander Mustafa Kemal, held firm, and the Allies withdrew by January 1916. Estimates of total casualties are around half a million. Italy fought Austria-Hungary in the Alps, where cold and avalanches killed many. In the Caucasus, an Ottoman winter offensive against Russia at Sarikamish in 1914 and 1915 cost tens of thousands of men.
Empires at war
About 1.3 to 1.5 million Indians served Britain, some in France in 1914 and 1915 and many more in Mesopotamia. France brought roughly half a million colonial soldiers, mainly from West and North Africa. About 140,000 Chinese labourers dug trenches and unloaded ships for Britain and France. Dominion troops fought battles their nations still commemorate, such as Gallipoli and, for Canada, Vimy Ridge in 1917. In East Africa, where a German force fought on until after the armistice, hundreds of thousands of African carriers moved supplies; estimates of their deaths run to 100,000 or more. Racism shaped all of it: colonial troops faced lower pay and closed paths to command.
Rival promises in the Arab lands
In June 1916 Sharif Hussein of Mecca launched the Arab Revolt against Ottoman rule, after letters with the British official Henry McMahon promised support for Arab independence in loosely defined lands. His son Faisal, aided by the British officer T. E. Lawrence, raided the Hejaz railway. Yet in the secret Sykes-Picot Agreement of May 1916, Britain and France planned to divide the region into their own zones of control. In November 1917 the Balfour Declaration announced British support for "a national home for the Jewish people" in Palestine, while promising not to prejudice the rights of its existing non-Jewish communities. These commitments pulled in different directions.
The Armenian Genocide
Armenians were a Christian people living largely in eastern Anatolia. After the defeat at Sarikamish, the Young Turk leaders accused them of siding with Russia. On 24 April 1915, Armenian community leaders in Constantinople were arrested, and most were later killed. From May, a deportation law sent whole communities on forced marches towards the Syrian desert. Men were often shot at the outset; women, children and the elderly died of massacre, starvation and exposure, and many women and children were forcibly converted or abducted. Estimates of Armenian deaths range from about 600,000 to 1.5 million, with many scholars citing about a million or more. Assyrian and Greek Christians were also targeted. Most historians and many governments recognise it as genocide; Turkey rejects the term.
Worked example: reading an ambassador's cable
Source: a telegram of 16 July 1915 from Henry Morgenthau, the US ambassador in Constantinople, reporting to Washington that "a campaign of race extermination is in progress" against Armenians. 1. Author: the envoy of a then-neutral country. 2. Date: written during the deportations, not afterwards. 3. Basis: reports from American consuls and missionaries across Anatolia. 4. Limits: Morgenthau saw little himself and relied on others. 5. Corroboration: reports by diplomats of Germany, the Ottomans' own ally, survivors' testimony, and Ottoman courts-martial in 1919 and 1920 that convicted leaders, including Talat, in their absence. Conclusion: independent sources agree on deliberate destruction.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, picturing the war as only trenches in France. Second, thinking gas was the main killer; artillery caused far more deaths. Third, forgetting the colonial soldiers and labourers from India, Africa and China. Fourth, citing one exact casualty figure: give attributed ranges. Fifth, calling the Armenian Genocide a by-product of wartime chaos; it was an organised campaign by the state. Sixth, assuming Britain's wartime promises in the Middle East were consistent; they contradicted one another.
Key takeaways
Industrial firepower, mass conscription and empire made the war total and favoured defenders. New weapons changed combat, and trench life brought mud, disease and shell shock. Attrition at Verdun and the Somme cost each well over half a million casualties. Blockade and U-boats made the sea a war on supply. Gallipoli and the Caucasus showed the war's reach, and Indian, African, Chinese and dominion manpower its global scale. Britain's promises to Arabs, France and Zionists conflicted. From 1915 the Ottoman government carried out the Armenian Genocide.
Flashcards
Flashcard
War in which states commit all their people, industry and opinion, blurring soldier and civilian
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why did attacks on the Western Front so rarely break through?
Question 2 of 5
Why do historians debate Falkenhayn's account of his aims at Verdun?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement about colonial participation in the war is accurate?
Question 4 of 5
Why did Britain's wartime commitments in the Middle East cause later conflict?
Question 5 of 5
In the source analysis, why does corroboration strengthen Morgenthau's 1915 report?
