World History › Section X · World War II › Topic X.1
An unstable peace
The settlement of 1919 promised a world kept peaceful by treaties and the League of Nations. This topic follows how Japan, Italy and Germany broke that order step by step in the 1930s, and how separate wars in Asia and Europe merged into one global war by December 1941.
Why the peace unravelled
The Treaty of Versailles and the League of Nations rested on a hope that disputes could be settled by talks and collective pressure. Germany and Italy resented the 1919 settlement, the Depression had pushed many voters towards extremes, and the League had no army of its own. Japan had its own grievance: at the Paris peace conference it proposed a clause affirming racial equality, which was blocked, with Australia and Britain leading the opposition. Many Japanese took this as proof that the West would never treat Asians as equals, a resentment nationalists later exploited.
Japan's war in China
After seizing Manchuria in 1931 and turning it into the puppet state of Manchukuo, Japan's army pressed south towards the Great Wall. In December 1936, China's Nationalist leader Chiang Kai-shek, detained by one of his own generals at Xi'an, agreed to a Second United Front with Mao Zedong's Communists against Japan. In July 1937, a clash at the Marco Polo Bridge near Beijing became full-scale war. Japanese troops took Shanghai and then Nanjing, where they massacred civilians and prisoners; estimates of the dead range from tens of thousands to about 300,000. In 1938, Chiang's forces broke the Yellow River dikes to slow the Japanese, and the floods killed hundreds of thousands of Chinese civilians.
Italy and Germany test the League
Mussolini invaded Ethiopia in October 1935. The League named Italy the aggressor and imposed sanctions, but they left out oil, and Italian forces used poison gas. In December, the British and French foreign ministers privately drafted the Hoare-Laval plan to hand Italy much of Ethiopia; it leaked and was dropped, but the League's credibility never recovered. Italy took Addis Ababa in May 1936. Hitler, meanwhile, left the League in 1933, announced rearmament in 1935 and, on 7 March 1936, sent troops into the demilitarised Rhineland. France, unwilling to fight alone, did not resist. In March 1938, German troops entered Austria, which was annexed in the Anschluss.
Worked example: the Munich bargain
Why did Britain and France accept Hitler's demands in 1938? 1. The demand: the Sudetenland, the border region of Czechoslovakia with about three million German speakers. 2. The deal: at Munich on 30 September, Neville Chamberlain, Édouard Daladier, Hitler and Mussolini agreed that Germany would take it; Czechoslovakia was not at the table. 3. The motives: fear of another great war, unready armed forces, distrust of the Soviet Union and no prospect of American help. 4. The result: in March 1939, Germany seized the rest of the Czech lands, and Britain and France then guaranteed Poland. 5. Interpretation: the 1940 pamphlet Guilty Men condemned the appeasers; later historians argued Chamberlain bought time to rearm, while R. A. C. Parker countered that he had real alternatives.
Persecution and closed doors
Inside Germany, persecution of Jews grew harsher each year. A law of April 1933 expelled Jews from the civil service, and the Nuremberg Laws of 1935 stripped them of citizenship and banned marriage with non-Jews. On 9 and 10 November 1938, during the attacks known as Kristallnacht, Nazis burned hundreds of synagogues, wrecked Jewish shops and homes, and sent about 30,000 Jewish men to concentration camps. Refuge was scarce: at the Évian conference in July 1938, almost none of 32 nations offered to take more refugees. Britain's Kindertransport brought about 10,000 children, most of them Jewish. Shanghai, which required no entry visa, received roughly 17,000 to 20,000 Jews; Chinese diplomats such as Ho Feng-Shan in Vienna issued Shanghai visas that helped Jews get permission to leave.
The Nazi-Soviet Pact and Poland
Hitler's goal was Lebensraum, "living space" in eastern Europe, where Germans would settle and Slavic peoples would be pushed out or subjugated. Poland stood in the way. On 23 August 1939, Germany and the Soviet Union shocked the world by signing a nonaggression pact. Its secret protocol divided eastern Europe: eastern Poland, Finland, Estonia, Latvia and Romania's Bessarabia fell in the Soviet sphere, with Lithuania added a month later. Stalin gained time and territory; Hitler avoided a two-front war. Germany invaded Poland on 1 September, Britain and France declared war on 3 September, and on 17 September the Red Army invaded from the east. Poland was crushed between them.
Blitzkrieg in the west
Germany's "lightning war" combined air strikes, fast tank columns and motorised infantry to break through and encircle slower enemies. After a winter lull, the Phoney War, Germany seized Denmark and Norway in April 1940. On 10 May it attacked the Low Countries and France, sending tanks through the Ardennes forest and around the fortified Maginot Line. From 26 May to 4 June, about 338,000 British and French troops escaped from Dunkirk by sea. France signed an armistice on 22 June. Marshal Philippe Pétain led a collaborating regime based at Vichy, while Charles de Gaulle rallied the Free French from London. Britain fought on under Winston Churchill, and in the Battle of Britain, from July to October 1940, the radar-guided Royal Air Force denied Germany the air control an invasion needed.
Worked example: why Barbarossa stalled
On 22 June 1941, Germany broke its pact and invaded the Soviet Union with more than three million German troops, joined by Romanian, Finnish, Hungarian, Italian and other forces. Why did it fail to win in 1941? 1. Early success: Stalin had ignored warnings, and the purges of 1937 to 1938 had stripped the Red Army of experienced officers, so millions of Soviet soldiers were killed or captured. 2. Strain: supply lines stretched over vast distances, and autumn rains turned roads to mud. 3. Resistance: Soviet troops fought on, and besieged Leningrad held out for about 872 days, at a cost of perhaps 800,000 or more civilian lives. 4. Winter: the cold hit troops lacking winter equipment. 5. Result: a Soviet counter-attack in December 1941 drove the Germans back from Moscow.
Japan turns south
Stalemate in China pushed Japan towards the oil, rubber and tin of Southeast Asia's European colonies. In 1940, its foreign minister promoted a Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere, presented as freeing Asia from Western rule but in practice an empire led by Japan. That September, Japan signed the Tripartite Pact with Germany and Italy and moved into northern French Indochina. When it occupied southern Indochina in July 1941, the United States froze Japanese assets, ending oil sales. Rather than withdraw from China, Japan's leaders chose war. On 7 and 8 December 1941, Japan struck Pearl Harbor, Malaya, Hong Kong, the Philippines and Guam, and the two wars became one.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, dating the war only from 1939: for China, full-scale war began in July 1937. Second, treating appeasement as simple cowardice; leaders faced real constraints, and historians still debate the alternatives. Third, forgetting that the Soviet Union was Germany's partner from August 1939 to June 1941 and also invaded Poland. Fourth, calling Germany's victories in 1940 the result of more tanks; France had at least as many, but Germany used them in concentrated, fast-moving formations. Fifth, accepting Japan's Co-Prosperity Sphere at face value; its "liberation" replaced Western rule with Japanese rule.
Key takeaways
The 1919 order lacked force, and Japan, Italy and Germany broke it piece by piece. Japan's war in China began in 1937 and brought the Nanjing massacre. The League failed over Ethiopia, and Hitler remilitarised the Rhineland and annexed Austria. At Munich in 1938, Britain and France gave up the Sudetenland. Nazi persecution of Jews intensified while most nations kept their doors closed. The Nazi-Soviet Pact opened the way to the invasion of Poland in September 1939. Blitzkrieg conquered France, Britain held out, Barbarossa stalled before Moscow, and Japan's attacks in December 1941 made the war global.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Japan's 1919 bid to have racial equality written into the peace settlement
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What event in July 1937 turned conflict between Japan and China into full-scale war?
Question 2 of 5
Why did the League of Nations' response to Italy's invasion of Ethiopia damage its credibility?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement about the Nazi-Soviet Pact of August 1939 is accurate?
Question 4 of 5
What best explains Germany's rapid defeat of France in 1940?
Question 5 of 5
Why did Japan decide on war with the Western powers in 1941?
