Civil liberties: the First Amendment
Civil liberties are protections against government interference with individual freedoms. The First Amendment protects religion, speech, press, assembly, and petition.
Liberties and rights
Civil liberties are freedoms protected from government interference, such as speech and religion, mostly found in the Bill of Rights. Civil rights are protections against discrimination and guarantees of equal treatment. The Bill of Rights originally limited only the national government (Barron v. Baltimore, 1833).
Incorporation
The 14th Amendment's due process clause, through selective incorporation, has been used by the Supreme Court to apply most Bill of Rights protections to state governments, case by case, beginning with free speech in Gitlow v. New York (1925). Recent incorporations include the right to bear arms (McDonald v. Chicago, 2010) and the ban on excessive fines (Timbs v. Indiana, 2019).
The establishment clause
The establishment clause forbids government to establish a religion, which Jefferson described as building 'a wall of separation between church and state'. Engel v. Vitale (1962) banned official school prayer. For decades courts used the Lemon test (1971); in Kennedy v. Bremerton School District (2022), the Court replaced it with an approach focused on historical practices and understandings.
Free exercise
The free exercise clause protects religious practice, though not every religiously motivated act. In Employment Division v. Smith (1990), the Court held that neutral, generally applicable laws can apply to religious conduct. Congress responded with the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (1993), requiring the federal government to justify substantial burdens on religion with a compelling interest.
Freedom of speech
Speech protection is strongest for political expression. In Brandenburg v. Ohio (1969), the Court held that advocacy of force or law-breaking is protected unless it is directed to inciting imminent lawless action and likely to produce it. Symbolic speech, such as wearing armbands (Tinker v. Des Moines, 1969) or burning the flag (Texas v. Johnson, 1989), is also protected.
Limits on speech
Some speech receives less or no protection: obscenity (defined in Miller v. California, 1973), true threats, incitement, defamation, and fighting words. Governments may impose reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions that are content-neutral. Public officials suing for libel must prove 'actual malice', knowledge of falsehood or reckless disregard for truth (New York Times v. Sullivan, 1964).
Press, assembly, and petition
Freedom of the press protects publication without prior restraint, government censorship before publication. In New York Times v. United States (1971), the Court allowed publication of the Pentagon Papers, a classified history of the Vietnam War. Freedoms of assembly and petition protect peaceful protest and lobbying, subject to reasonable regulation, such as permits for large marches.
Worked example
A high school student wears a T-shirt protesting a war. Under Tinker (1969), students do not 'shed their constitutional rights at the schoolhouse gate', so the school may restrict the shirt only if it would cause substantial disruption. If the shirt advocated illegal drug use, Morse v. Frederick (2007) allows schools more leeway. If a student made a true threat against a classmate, it would not be protected at all.
Key takeaways
Civil liberties protect freedoms from government; civil rights guarantee equal treatment. The Bill of Rights originally bound only the national government (Barron, 1833), but selective incorporation through the 14th Amendment, from Gitlow (1925) to McDonald (2010) and Timbs (2019), applies it to states. The establishment clause bars state religion (Engel, 1962; Kennedy v. Bremerton, 2022, replaced Lemon). Free exercise allows neutral laws (Smith, 1990), with RFRA (1993) adding protection. Brandenburg (1969) protects advocacy short of imminent incitement; Tinker and Texas v. Johnson protect symbolic speech. Obscenity, threats, and defamation have limits; Sullivan (1964) requires actual malice. Prior restraint is disfavoured (Pentagon Papers, 1971).
Flashcard
Freedoms protected from government interference
Check your understanding
Under Brandenburg v. Ohio (1969), when may government punish advocacy of violence?
