Federal money and its strings
Much of federalism today works through money. The national government uses grants to fund and influence state policies, sometimes attaching conditions.
Fiscal federalism
Fiscal federalism describes how money flows between levels of government. Federal grants make up a large share of state budgets, often around a third of state spending, funding health care, education, transport, and welfare. Grants let the federal government pursue national goals through state implementation, using its larger tax base.
Categorical grants
Categorical grants fund specific purposes with detailed conditions. Project grants are awarded competitively for particular projects, such as research or local infrastructure; formula grants are distributed according to formulas based on factors such as population or poverty. Medicaid, the joint federal-state health programme for low-income people, is the largest federal grant to states.
Block grants
Block grants provide money for broad purposes, such as community development or social services, with fewer restrictions, giving states more flexibility. Supporters of new federalism favour block grants to decentralise decisions; critics worry that broad grants allow funding to shrink over time and reduce national standards. Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), created in 1996, replaced an entitlement with a block grant.
Conditions of aid
Congress often attaches conditions to grants. In South Dakota v. Dole (1987), the Supreme Court upheld a law withholding a portion of highway funds from states that did not raise the drinking age to 21, ruling that conditions must be clear, related to the purpose of spending, and not coercive. By 1988, all states had adopted a drinking age of 21.
Limits on coercion
In National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius (2012), the Court upheld most of the Affordable Care Act but ruled that threatening to withdraw all existing Medicaid funding from states that refused to expand the programme was unconstitutionally coercive, 'a gun to the head'. Medicaid expansion therefore became optional, and states have made different choices.
Unfunded mandates
Unfunded mandates are federal requirements imposed on states without full funding, such as some environmental and disability-access rules. States complained about their costs, and the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 required Congress to estimate mandates' costs and made them harder to pass, though many requirements remain.
Federalism in emergencies
Crises test federalism. During the COVID-19 pandemic, states and localities issued most public health orders, such as mask rules and business closures, producing very different policies across states, while the federal government provided funding, vaccines, and guidance. Disasters such as hurricanes involve state-led responses supported by federal agencies such as FEMA.
Worked example
A state wants federal transport money for a new rail line. If the money comes through a categorical project grant, the state must meet federal conditions on safety, environmental review, and wages. If it comes through a block grant for transportation, the state has more freedom to choose between rail, roads, and buses. The choice of grant type determines how much control Washington has over a local decision.
Key takeaways
Fiscal federalism channels federal money, often around a third of state spending, to state programmes. Categorical grants, project or formula, fund specific purposes; Medicaid is the largest. Block grants give broad purposes and flexibility, as with TANF (1996). Conditions of aid were upheld in South Dakota v. Dole (1987), leading every state to a drinking age of 21 by 1988. NFIB v. Sebelius (2012) ruled coercive Medicaid conditions unconstitutional, making expansion optional. Unfunded mandates impose costs, curbed somewhat in 1995. Emergencies such as COVID-19 showed state-led responses with federal support.
Flashcard
Money flows between levels of government
Check your understanding
Why did every state adopt a drinking age of 21 by 1988?
