Voting: who votes and why
Voting is the most common form of political participation, but many eligible Americans do not vote. Who votes, and why, shapes who wins and which policies follow.
Expanding the electorate
The right to vote expanded over time: property requirements for white men were largely removed by the mid-nineteenth century; the 15th Amendment (1870) banned racial discrimination in voting, though Jim Crow laws undermined it; the 19th Amendment (1920) enfranchised women; the 24th Amendment (1964) banned poll taxes in federal elections; the Voting Rights Act (1965) enforced voting rights; and the 26th Amendment (1971) lowered the voting age to 18.
Turnout
Turnout is the share of eligible people who vote. In presidential elections, turnout of the voting-eligible population was about 66% in 2020, the highest since 1900, and remained high in 2024 at around 64%. Turnout is typically much lower in midterm elections, often 40% to 50%, and lower still in primaries and local elections. US turnout is lower than in many other democracies.
Who votes
Turnout rises with education, income, and age; older, wealthier, and more educated citizens vote at higher rates than younger, poorer, and less educated ones. Residential stability and civic engagement also predict voting. Differences in turnout matter because elected officials may respond more to groups that vote.
Why people vote or not
The rational choice paradox notes that a single vote almost never decides an election, yet millions vote. People vote from civic duty, identity, social pressure, and the desire to express views. Non-voters often cite lack of interest, dislike of candidates, inconvenience, or registration barriers. Being contacted by campaigns or friends increases turnout.
Registration and access
Most states require voters to register in advance, a barrier unusual among democracies. Reforms include the National Voter Registration Act (1993, the 'Motor Voter' law), same-day registration, and automatic registration through government agencies. Early voting and mail voting expanded greatly, especially during the 2020 pandemic, when a large share of ballots were cast by mail.
Voting rules debates
States set most election rules, leading to debates over voter ID requirements, mail voting, early voting periods, and voter roll maintenance. Supporters of strict rules cite election security; opponents argue they reduce access, particularly for minorities, students, and the poor. In Shelby County v. Holder (2013), the Supreme Court struck down the formula used to require federal pre-approval of voting changes, allowing affected states to change rules without it.
Other participation
Participation goes beyond voting: contacting officials, donating to campaigns, volunteering, attending protests, signing petitions, joining interest groups, running for office, and engaging online. Robert Putnam's Bowling Alone (2000) argued that civic engagement and social capital declined in late twentieth-century America, though others point to new forms of participation.
Worked example
A state has 5 million voting-eligible residents. In a presidential year, 3.3 million vote (66% turnout); in the following midterm, 2.3 million vote (46%). If older voters make up a much larger share of midterm voters, candidates may emphasise issues such as Social Security and Medicare in midterm campaigns. Changes in who turns out, not just in opinions, can swing outcomes between elections.
Key takeaways
Voting rights expanded through the 15th (1870), 19th (1920), 24th (1964), and 26th (1971) amendments and the Voting Rights Act (1965). Presidential turnout was about 66% in 2020, the highest since 1900, and about 64% in 2024; midterm and local turnout is lower. Turnout rises with education, income, and age. People vote from duty, identity, and social pressure despite the rational choice paradox. Registration barriers are reduced by Motor Voter (1993), same-day, and automatic registration; mail voting expanded in 2020. Shelby County v. Holder (2013) ended pre-clearance under the old formula. Participation also includes donating, protesting, and organising; Putnam (2000) documented declining civic engagement.
Flashcard
Share of eligible people who vote
Check your understanding
Which groups typically vote at the highest rates in the United States?
