The media and politics
The media inform citizens, scrutinise leaders, and shape what people think about. A changing media environment brings new opportunities and dangers for democracy.
Functions of the media
Media in a democracy inform citizens about public affairs, act as watchdogs investigating wrongdoing, provide forums for debate, and set the agenda by deciding what to cover. The Watergate investigation by Washington Post reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, which contributed to President Nixon's resignation in 1974, is a classic example of the watchdog role.
The evolution of media
American political media evolved from partisan newspapers in the early republic to the penny press, mass-circulation newspapers, radio (Franklin Roosevelt's 'fireside chats' from 1933), and television, which made the 1960 Kennedy-Nixon debates a landmark. Cable news, beginning with CNN in 1980, created 24-hour coverage, and the internet and social media now dominate how many people get news.
Agenda setting, framing, and priming
Agenda setting means the media influence which issues people consider important, telling people 'what to think about'. Framing is how a story is presented, such as describing a tax as 'relief' or as 'cuts for the wealthy', influencing interpretation. Priming means media coverage affects the standards people use to evaluate leaders, such as judging a president mainly on the economy.
Media bias
Many Americans believe the media are biased, and perceptions divide along partisan lines. Research finds some outlets have clear ideological slants, and audiences increasingly choose outlets that match their views. Structural biases also exist: news favours conflict, novelty, and personalities over complex policy, which can distort public understanding.
Social media and the information environment
Social media let politicians communicate directly with voters and let citizens share and create content, but platforms' algorithms can amplify sensational and false information. Misinformation (false information spread without intent) and disinformation (deliberately false information) spread quickly; studies found that false news stories spread faster than true ones on some platforms. Foreign influence operations targeted US elections, as investigations of 2016 documented.
Local news decline
Local newspapers have declined sharply: since 2005, the United States has lost over a third of its newspapers, according to researchers at Northwestern University, creating 'news deserts' with little local coverage. Research links such losses to lower voter turnout, fewer candidates running for office, and higher government borrowing costs, because officials face less scrutiny.
Regulation and freedom of the press
The First Amendment strongly protects the press, but broadcast media have faced more regulation because they use public airwaves, regulated by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). The Fairness Doctrine, requiring balanced coverage of controversial issues, was abolished in 1987. Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act (1996) largely shields online platforms from liability for users' posts, a provision now hotly debated.
Worked example
Two outlets cover the same jobs report. One headlines 'Unemployment falls to record low' and features workers who found jobs; the other headlines 'Wages fail to keep up with prices' and features struggling families. Both are factually accurate but frame the economy differently, priming viewers to judge the government on different standards. Audiences who watch only one outlet may form sharply different views of the same facts.
Key takeaways
Media inform, investigate, host debate, and set the agenda; Watergate reporting exemplified the watchdog role. Media evolved from partisan papers through radio, television (1960 debates), cable (CNN, 1980), and social media. Agenda setting shapes what people think about, framing shapes interpretation, and priming shapes evaluation standards. Perceived bias divides by party, and structural biases favour conflict. Social media enable direct communication but spread misinformation and disinformation, including foreign operations. Over a third of US newspapers closed since 2005, creating news deserts. Broadcast regulation by the FCC, the end of the Fairness Doctrine (1987), and Section 230 (1996) shape the media landscape.
Flashcard
Investigating wrongdoing by the powerful
Check your understanding
Media coverage that leads voters to judge a president mainly on foreign policy is an example of:
