← Back to American Government

How the Supreme Court decides

The Supreme Court chooses which cases to hear, hears arguments, deliberates in private, and issues opinions that shape the law for the whole country.

Choosing cases

Most cases reach the Supreme Court through petitions for a writ of certiorari, asking the Court to review a lower-court decision. Under the 'rule of four', the Court grants review if at least four justices agree. The Court receives several thousand petitions each year but now hears only around 60 to 70 cases, choosing those involving important federal questions or disagreements among the circuits.

Briefs and oral argument

Parties submit written briefs setting out their arguments; outside groups and governments often submit amicus curiae ('friend of the court') briefs. Oral argument, traditionally 30 minutes per side for most cases, lets justices question lawyers. The solicitor general represents the United States government and is sometimes called the 'tenth justice' because of the influence of their office.

Conference and opinions

Justices meet in private conference to discuss and vote, with the chief justice speaking first. If the chief justice is in the majority, he assigns who writes the majority opinion; otherwise the most senior justice in the majority does. Opinions explain the reasoning and set precedent. Concurring opinions agree with the result for different reasons; dissenting opinions disagree and can influence future cases.

Unanimous and divided decisions

Some decisions are unanimous, as in Brown v. Board of Education (1954), which Chief Justice Earl Warren worked to make unanimous to strengthen its authority. Others are closely divided, 5 to 4 or 6 to 3. A considerable share of decisions in recent terms have been unanimous or nearly so, even as high-profile cases often divide the Court along ideological lines.

Influences on decisions

Legal factors include the text of the Constitution and statutes, precedent, and interpretive philosophies such as originalism and textualism. Political scientists also study ideology (the attitudinal model), strategic behaviour (justices anticipating colleagues, Congress, and public reaction), and public opinion, which the Court rarely departs from for long. The 'shadow docket', emergency orders decided without full briefing, has drawn growing attention.

Implementing decisions

Supreme Court rulings require others to implement them: lower courts, executive agencies, states, and sometimes the public. Compliance can be slow or resisted, as with school desegregation after Brown, which progressed little in some Southern states until the 1964 Civil Rights Act tied federal funds to integration. Congress can respond to statutory rulings by changing the law.

The Court and public trust

Public confidence in the Supreme Court has varied. Gallup polling found confidence falling to record lows in the early 2020s, with sharp partisan differences after major rulings. Debates continue over proposals such as term limits for justices, enforceable ethics rules, and changes to the Court's size, each requiring legislation or constitutional amendment.

Worked example

A circuit court split arises: the Fifth Circuit upholds a state law, while the Ninth Circuit strikes down a similar law. The losing party petitions for certiorari, and four justices vote to grant it. After briefs, amicus briefs from interest groups, and oral argument, the justices vote 6 to 3 in conference. The chief justice, in the majority, assigns the opinion; one justice writes a concurrence and another a dissent. The ruling now resolves the split nationwide.

Key takeaways

Cases reach the Court mainly through certiorari, granted under the rule of four; the Court now hears around 60 to 70 cases a year, prioritising important questions and circuit splits. Parties file briefs, amici add arguments, and oral argument lets justices question lawyers; the solicitor general represents the government. Justices vote in private conference; the chief justice or senior majority justice assigns opinions; concurrences and dissents follow. Some rulings are unanimous, as Brown (1954); many are divided. Law, ideology, strategy, and public opinion all influence decisions; the shadow docket draws scrutiny. Implementation depends on other actors. Public confidence fell to record lows in the early 2020s, prompting reform proposals.

Flashcard

Writ of certiorari

Order to review a lower-court decision

Cert petition.

Check your understanding

How many justices must agree for the Supreme Court to hear a case?

Take the unit quiz

← Previous lesson Next lesson →