The dual court system
The United States has two parallel court systems, federal and state. Understanding which courts hear which cases explains how legal disputes move through the system.
Two systems
Each state has its own courts, and there is a separate federal court system. Most cases, including most criminal prosecutions, contracts, family law, and traffic offences, are heard in state courts, which handle the overwhelming majority of the country's tens of millions of cases each year. Federal courts hear cases involving federal law, the Constitution, the United States as a party, and disputes between citizens of different states above a monetary threshold.
The federal court structure
The federal system has three main levels. District courts, 94 of them, are trial courts that hear evidence and decide facts, with juries in many cases. The courts of appeals, organised into 13 circuits (11 numbered, the D.C. Circuit, and the Federal Circuit), review district court decisions for legal errors. The Supreme Court sits at the top.
Original and appellate jurisdiction
Original jurisdiction is the authority to hear a case first, as a trial court; appellate jurisdiction is the authority to review decisions of lower courts. The Supreme Court has original jurisdiction in a few cases, such as disputes between states, but almost all its cases come through appellate jurisdiction.
Criminal and civil cases
In criminal cases, the government prosecutes someone accused of breaking the law, and guilt must be proved 'beyond a reasonable doubt'. In civil cases, parties dispute rights and obligations, such as contracts or injuries, and the plaintiff usually needs to prove the case by a 'preponderance of the evidence'. Most cases in both systems are settled or resolved by plea bargains rather than trials.
State court systems
State systems typically have trial courts, intermediate appellate courts, and a state supreme court (in New York, confusingly, the 'Supreme Court' is a trial court and the Court of Appeals is the highest). Many state judges are elected, unlike federal judges, raising debates about judicial independence and campaign spending in judicial elections.
Federal judicial selection
Federal judges are nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate. Senators' input, especially through the traditional 'blue slip' for district courts in their state, influences nominations. Presidents consider legal qualifications, ideology, and diversity. Because judges serve for life, appointments are among a president's most lasting legacies.
Specialised courts
Some federal courts handle specialised matters: the Court of International Trade, the Court of Federal Claims (money claims against the government), bankruptcy courts, tax courts, military courts, and the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, which reviews government surveillance applications. Tribal courts serve many Native American nations under tribal sovereignty.
Worked example
A woman in Ohio is injured by a product made by a company based in Texas and sues for 200,000 dollars. Because the parties are from different states and the amount exceeds the 75,000-dollar threshold, she may sue in federal district court under diversity jurisdiction, or in Ohio state court. If she loses in federal court, she may appeal to the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals, and then petition the Supreme Court, which is unlikely to take the case.
Key takeaways
The United States has parallel state and federal court systems; state courts handle the vast majority of cases. Federal courts include 94 district courts (trials), 13 courts of appeals (legal review), and the Supreme Court. Original jurisdiction means hearing a case first; appellate jurisdiction means reviewing it. Criminal cases require proof beyond a reasonable doubt; civil cases usually a preponderance of the evidence; most cases settle or end in plea bargains. Many state judges are elected. Federal judges are nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate, with senators' influence. Specialised federal courts and tribal courts handle particular matters. Diversity jurisdiction applies above 75,000 dollars between citizens of different states.
Flashcard
Parallel state and federal courts
Check your understanding
What is the standard of proof in a criminal trial?
