Governing: the executive branch and presidential action
Presidents govern through a vast executive branch and use tools such as executive orders, vetoes, and public persuasion. Their success depends on bargaining as much as command.
The Executive Office of the President
Created in 1939, the Executive Office of the President (EOP) includes the White House staff, led by the chief of staff; the National Security Council, coordinating foreign and defence policy; the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), which prepares the budget and reviews regulations; and the Council of Economic Advisers. These advisers work closely with the president.
The cabinet
The cabinet consists of the heads of the 15 executive departments, such as State, Treasury, Defense, Justice (led by the attorney general), and Homeland Security, created in 2002, along with other officials the president includes. Secretaries are confirmed by the Senate and run their departments, though presidents vary in how much they rely on the cabinet as a group.
The bureaucracy
The federal bureaucracy employs over two million civilian workers in departments, independent agencies (such as NASA and the Environmental Protection Agency), regulatory commissions (such as the Federal Reserve and Securities and Exchange Commission), and government corporations (such as the US Postal Service). Most federal employees are hired through the merit-based civil service, created after the Pendleton Act (1883) curbed the spoils system.
Executive orders and actions
Presidents issue executive orders directing how agencies carry out laws, along with memoranda and proclamations. Examples include Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation (1863), Truman's order desegregating the armed forces (1948), and many orders on immigration, environment, and federal hiring. Executive orders can be overturned by courts, superseded by Congress, or reversed by later presidents.
Foreign affairs and war powers
Presidents lead foreign policy, negotiating treaties and, increasingly, executive agreements that do not require Senate ratification. Congress declares war, but the last formal declarations came in the Second World War; presidents have committed forces in Korea, Vietnam, and elsewhere without them. The War Powers Resolution (1973) requires presidents to notify Congress within 48 hours of deploying forces and to withdraw them within 60 days without authorisation, though compliance is contested.
Persuasion and the bully pulpit
Richard Neustadt's Presidential Power (1960) argued that presidential power is 'the power to persuade': presidents must bargain with Congress, agencies, and others who have their own sources of power. Theodore Roosevelt called the presidency a 'bully pulpit' for rallying public opinion. Presidents' approval ratings, honeymoon periods, and party control of Congress affect their success.
Signing statements, vetoes, and unilateral power
Presidents veto bills, and the threat of a veto shapes legislation. Signing statements express presidents' interpretations of laws they sign. Debates over the 'unitary executive' theory, which holds that the president controls the entire executive branch, including independent agencies, have grown, with Supreme Court cases addressing presidential removal powers and, in Trump v. United States (2024), immunity for official acts.
Worked example
In 1948, President Truman issued Executive Order 9981, ordering equality of treatment in the armed forces, effectively beginning their desegregation, after Congress had failed to act on civil rights. He used his authority as commander in chief. Full implementation took years, showing both the power of executive action to change policy quickly and its dependence on the bureaucracy's cooperation for results.
Key takeaways
The Executive Office of the President (1939) includes White House staff, the National Security Council, OMB, and economic advisers. The cabinet heads 15 departments, confirmed by the Senate. The bureaucracy, over two million civilian workers, includes departments, independent agencies, commissions, and corporations, mostly hired through the civil service since the Pendleton Act (1883). Executive orders, such as the Emancipation Proclamation (1863) and Truman's 1948 desegregation order, direct agencies but can be reversed. Presidents lead foreign policy and commit forces without declarations, constrained by the War Powers Resolution (1973). Neustadt (1960) saw presidential power as persuasion. Vetoes, signing statements, and unitary executive debates, including Trump v. United States (2024), shape presidential power.
Flashcard
President's immediate staff and agencies
Check your understanding
What does the War Powers Resolution (1973) require?
