← Back to American Government

Judicial review and the courts' role

The federal courts interpret the Constitution and laws. Their power of judicial review makes them a co-equal branch able to check Congress and the president.

Article III

Article III establishes 'one supreme Court' and such inferior courts as Congress creates. Federal judges hold office 'during good behaviour', in practice for life unless impeached and removed, and their salaries cannot be reduced, protecting judicial independence. Article III limits federal courts to actual 'cases' and 'controversies', so they do not give advisory opinions.

Marbury v. Madison

In Marbury v. Madison (1803), Chief Justice John Marshall established judicial review: the power of courts to strike down laws that conflict with the Constitution. William Marbury sought a commission as a justice of the peace; Marshall held that the law giving the Supreme Court power to issue the order he sought was itself unconstitutional, asserting that 'it is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is'.

Judicial review in practice

Courts review federal laws, state laws, and executive actions for constitutionality. The Supreme Court has struck down federal laws relatively rarely but state laws more often. Famous exercises include Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), a notorious ruling denying citizenship to Black Americans, later overturned by the 14th Amendment, and Brown v. Board of Education (1954).

Hamilton's 'least dangerous branch'

In Federalist No. 78, Alexander Hamilton called the judiciary the 'least dangerous' branch because it has neither the sword (enforcement) nor the purse (money), only judgement. Courts depend on other branches and public acceptance to enforce rulings, as when President Eisenhower sent troops to enforce school desegregation in Little Rock, Arkansas, in 1957.

Judicial activism and restraint

Judicial restraint holds that judges should defer to elected branches and precedent, overturning laws only when clearly unconstitutional. Judicial activism describes willingness to strike down laws or create new doctrines. Both labels are used selectively in political debate; liberals and conservatives have each criticised 'activism' when courts ruled against their preferences.

Precedent and stare decisis

Under stare decisis ('let the decision stand'), courts generally follow precedents, previous rulings on similar questions, promoting stability and predictability. The Supreme Court can overrule its own precedents, as Brown overruled Plessy and Dobbs (2022) overruled Roe v. Wade, but usually does so rarely, considering factors such as reliance on the precedent and whether it has proved unworkable.

Limits on courts

Courts decide only real disputes brought by parties with standing (a concrete injury), avoid 'political questions' better resolved by elected branches, and require cases to be ripe and not moot. Congress can change the courts' jurisdiction in some areas, alter the number of justices (fixed at nine since 1869), and respond to statutory interpretations by passing new laws. Constitutional rulings can be reversed by amendment.

Worked example

In Marbury, the Judiciary Act of 1789 had given the Supreme Court power to issue writs of mandamus in original jurisdiction. Marshall reasoned that Article III defined the Court's original jurisdiction narrowly, so Congress could not expand it by statute; the conflicting provision was void. Paradoxically, by declining power in this case, Marshall secured the far greater power of judicial review.

Key takeaways

Article III creates the Supreme Court and allows Congress to create lower courts; judges serve during good behaviour with protected salaries, deciding only cases and controversies. Marbury v. Madison (1803) established judicial review. Courts review federal and state laws and executive actions, as in Dred Scott (1857) and Brown (1954). Hamilton called the judiciary the least dangerous branch, dependent on others to enforce rulings, as at Little Rock (1957). Restraint and activism describe judicial approaches. Stare decisis favours precedent, though the Court sometimes overrules it, as in Brown and Dobbs. Standing, political questions, ripeness, mootness, jurisdiction, and amendments limit courts; the Court has had nine justices since 1869.

Flashcard

Article III

Establishes the federal judiciary

Supreme Court.

Check your understanding

What principle did Marbury v. Madison (1803) establish?

Take the unit quiz

← Previous lesson Next lesson →