Social ethics: duties to others and to the planet
Beyond individual choices, ethics asks what we owe to distant strangers, animals, future generations, and the natural world. These questions shape debates about poverty, climate, and our food.
Global poverty
Hundreds of millions of people live in extreme poverty. Peter Singer argues that affluent people are obligated to give substantially to effective aid, because distance does not reduce moral responsibility. Critics, such as some relational and political theorists, argue that duties are stronger to compatriots and that poverty requires structural and political change, not only charity.
Animal ethics
Bentham and Singer argued that the capacity to suffer gives animals moral standing, and Singer's Animal Liberation (1975) condemned 'speciesism', discounting interests because of species membership. Tom Regan argued that many animals are 'subjects of a life' with rights. These views challenge factory farming, which raises billions of animals annually in intensive conditions, and animal experimentation.
Environmental ethics
Anthropocentric views value nature for its benefits to humans; biocentric views extend moral standing to all living things; and ecocentric views, such as Aldo Leopold's land ethic (1949), value ecosystems and species as wholes, judging actions by whether they help keep ecological communities whole, stable, and flourishing. Each view shapes conservation priorities differently.
Climate ethics
Climate change raises questions of justice: wealthy nations emitted most historical greenhouse gases, while poorer nations often face the worst impacts. Principles such as 'polluter pays', 'beneficiary pays', and 'ability to pay' assign responsibility differently. The 2015 Paris Agreement embodies 'common but differentiated responsibilities'. Individuals also ask whether their own emissions matter given the scale of the problem.
Future generations
Our choices affect people not yet born. Derek Parfit's non-identity problem notes that different policies lead to different people being born, so a careless policy may not make any particular future person worse off than they would otherwise have been, yet it still seems wrong. Philosophers debate how much weight future people's interests deserve and whether to discount the future.
Distributive justice in society
Within societies, ethics asks what equality requires: equal opportunity, equal outcomes, or priority for the worst off. Debates over taxation, health care, education, and reparations for historical injustices apply these principles. These questions connect applied ethics to political philosophy, the subject of the next unit.
Moral status and the circle of concern
Moral status asks which beings matter morally for their own sake and how much. Historically, moral concern has expanded, from family and tribe to all humans, and arguably to animals and nature, a trend Singer called the expanding circle. Debates now extend to fetuses, people in persistent vegetative states, ecosystems, and potentially artificial intelligences.
Worked example
Is it wrong to fly for a holiday? One flight adds a tiny fraction to global emissions, so its direct effect seems negligible. Some philosophers argue that participating in a harmful collective practice is still wrong, or that each tonne of carbon has an expected harm, estimated through the social cost of carbon, often put at tens to hundreds of dollars per tonne. Others focus on political action as the main duty, since systemic change matters more than individual choices.
Key takeaways
Singer argues affluent people must give substantially to fight global poverty; critics emphasise compatriots and structural change. Animal ethics, from Bentham and Singer's anti-speciesism (1975) to Regan's rights view, challenges factory farming. Environmental ethics ranges from anthropocentric to biocentric and ecocentric views like Leopold's land ethic (1949). Climate ethics assigns responsibility by polluter, beneficiary, or ability to pay, reflected in the 2015 Paris Agreement. Parfit's non-identity problem complicates duties to future generations. Distributive justice links to political philosophy, and moral concern has expanded over time.
Flashcard
Prevent bad things if no comparable sacrifice
Check your understanding
What does Peter Singer mean by 'speciesism'?
