Why have a state? Social contract theory
Why should anyone obey the government? Social contract theorists imagined people agreeing to form a state, and asked what such an agreement would justify.
The problem of political obligation
Governments claim the right to make laws, tax, and use force. Political philosophy asks what, if anything, justifies this authority and creates a duty to obey. Anarchists answer that no state is legitimate; most philosophers seek conditions under which states can be justified, often by appeal to consent, fairness, or the benefits they provide.
Hobbes
Thomas Hobbes, in Leviathan (1651), written after the English Civil War, imagined a state of nature without government as a 'war of all against all', in which life would be 'solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short'. Rational people would agree to give up their freedom to an absolute sovereign who would keep peace. Even a harsh ruler, for Hobbes, is better than anarchy.
Locke
John Locke's Second Treatise of Government (1689) described a state of nature governed by natural law, in which people have rights to life, liberty, and property, which they acquire by mixing their labour with unowned resources. People form governments to protect these rights more reliably. If a government violates them, people may resist and replace it, an idea that influenced the American Declaration of Independence.
Rousseau
Jean-Jacques Rousseau's The Social Contract (1762) opens: 'Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains'. He argued that legitimate authority comes from the general will, the collective will of citizens aimed at the common good, as opposed to the sum of private interests. By obeying laws they make together, citizens remain free. Critics worry that the general will can justify suppressing dissenters.
Consent and its problems
Few people ever explicitly consent to their government. Locke appealed to tacit consent, shown by enjoying the state's benefits, such as using roads; David Hume objected that a poor peasant cannot meaningfully consent by staying in his country if he cannot leave. Modern theorists often appeal to hypothetical consent: what reasonable people would agree to.
Feminist and race critiques
Carole Pateman's The Sexual Contract (1988) argued that classical contract theory assumed the subordination of women, and Charles Mills's The Racial Contract (1997) argued that it historically excluded non-white people from full membership. These critiques ask who the imagined contractors are and whose interests the contract served, prompting revisions of the tradition.
Alternatives to contract
Other justifications of authority include utilitarian arguments (states maximise welfare), the principle of fairness (those who benefit from cooperative schemes must do their share), natural duties of justice (we must support just institutions), and democratic theories on which authority comes from equal participation in collective decisions.
Worked example
Must you obey a law you think is mistaken, such as a speed limit you believe is too low? Hobbes would say yes, since order matters most. Locke would say yes unless the law violates basic rights. A fairness theorist would say you benefit from others following traffic laws, so you owe compliance. A philosophical anarchist would deny any general duty but note good reasons, such as safety, for driving carefully anyway.
Key takeaways
Political philosophy asks what justifies state authority and the duty to obey. Hobbes's Leviathan (1651) pictured a brutal state of nature and justified an absolute sovereign. Locke's Second Treatise (1689) grounded government in protecting natural rights and permitted resistance. Rousseau's Social Contract (1762) located legitimacy in the general will. Consent is problematic: tacit consent faces Hume's objection, so many theorists use hypothetical consent. Pateman (1988) and Mills (1997) exposed exclusions in contract theory. Fairness, natural duty, utility, and democracy offer other justifications.
Flashcard
Duty to obey the state
Check your understanding
How did Hobbes describe life in the state of nature without government?
