Socrates and Plato: questioning and the Forms
Socrates made philosophy a way of life through relentless questioning, and his student Plato built on it a vast system about knowledge, reality, and justice.
Socrates
Socrates (about 470 to 399 BCE) wrote nothing; we know him mainly through Plato's dialogues and Xenophon's writings. He questioned Athenians about virtue, justice, and courage, often showing that confident experts could not define their own key terms. He claimed his only wisdom was knowing that he did not know, and famously held that 'the unexamined life is not worth living'.
The Socratic method
Socratic questioning, or elenchus, proceeds by asking for a definition, drawing out its implications, and showing that it conflicts with other beliefs the person holds, forcing revision. The aim is not humiliation but clearer understanding. Teachers, lawyers, and therapists still use versions of the method to examine assumptions.
The trial and death of Socrates
In 399 BCE, Socrates was tried for impiety and corrupting the young, convicted, and sentenced to death by drinking hemlock. Plato's Apology presents his defence, and the Crito shows him refusing to escape, arguing that he must honour his agreement to live under Athens' laws. His death became a lasting symbol of the conflict between philosophical inquiry and political power.
Plato and the Academy
Plato (about 427 to 347 BCE) wrote dialogues in which Socrates is usually the main speaker, though later dialogues increasingly express Plato's own views. He founded the Academy in Athens around 387 BCE, often called the first institution of higher learning in the Western world, which operated in some form for centuries.
The theory of Forms
Plato argued that beyond the changing physical world lie the Forms, perfect, unchanging, non-physical realities such as Justice itself, Beauty itself, and Equality itself. Particular things are just or beautiful by participating in the Forms. True knowledge, for Plato, is of the Forms, while the physical world offers only opinion, because it constantly changes.
The allegory of the cave
In the Republic, Plato imagines prisoners chained in a cave, seeing only shadows on a wall and taking them for reality. One prisoner escapes, sees the fire and objects casting the shadows, and finally the sun outside, representing the Form of the Good. The allegory pictures education as a painful turning of the soul from appearances towards truth.
The Republic and justice
The Republic asks what justice is and why we should be just even if injustice paid. Plato's answer describes a just city ruled by philosopher-kings, defended by guardians, and supported by producers, each class doing its own work, mirroring a just soul in which reason rules spirit and appetite. Critics, from Aristotle to Karl Popper, have questioned its authoritarian features.
Worked example
Plato's Euthyphro asks: is something pious because the gods love it, or do the gods love it because it is pious? If the first, piety seems arbitrary, depending on divine whim; if the second, piety has a standard independent of the gods. This 'Euthyphro dilemma' still shapes debates about whether morality depends on religion, and it illustrates Socratic questioning in miniature.
Key takeaways
Socrates (about 470 to 399 BCE) questioned Athenians about virtue, professing knowledge of his own ignorance and holding that the unexamined life is not worth living. His elenchus tests definitions against other beliefs. He was executed in 399 BCE after a trial recorded in the Apology, refusing escape in the Crito. Plato founded the Academy around 387 BCE. His theory of Forms places perfect realities beyond changing appearances, pictured in the allegory of the cave. The Republic links a just city and a just soul. The Euthyphro dilemma questions whether morality depends on the gods.
Flashcard
Athenian philosopher, about 470 to 399 BCE
Check your understanding
In Plato's allegory of the cave, what do the shadows on the wall represent?
