Philosophy before Athens: Indian, Chinese, and Indigenous thought
Philosophy began in many places. Long before Socrates, thinkers in India, China, and elsewhere asked deep questions about reality, the self, and how to live well.
The Axial Age
The philosopher Karl Jaspers called the period from roughly 800 to 200 BCE the Axial Age, when influential traditions of thought emerged in several regions at once: the Upanishads and Buddhism in India, Confucianism and Daoism in China, the Hebrew prophets, and Greek philosophy. Scholars debate how far the concept fits, but the period did produce remarkably lasting ideas.
The Upanishads
The Upanishads, Indian texts composed from roughly the eighth century BCE, explore the relationship between the individual self (atman) and ultimate reality (Brahman). A famous teaching, often summarised as 'that thou art', suggests that the deepest self is identical with ultimate reality. These ideas shaped Hindu philosophy, including the later Vedanta schools.
Buddhist philosophy
Siddhartha Gautama, the Buddha, lived around the fifth century BCE in northern India. His Four Noble Truths diagnose suffering, its origin in craving, its possible cessation, and the Eightfold Path leading there. Buddhist thinkers developed the doctrine of anatta, no permanent self, and later schools, such as Madhyamaka associated with Nagarjuna, developed rigorous arguments about emptiness and dependence.
Indian logic and knowledge
Indian schools also developed formal theories of knowledge. The Nyaya school studied valid means of knowing, such as perception, inference, comparison, and testimony, and analysed inference with structured examples. Jain philosophers proposed anekantavada, the many-sidedness of reality, holding that any single viewpoint captures only part of the truth.
Confucius
Confucius (Kongzi, traditionally 551 to 479 BCE) taught that a good society rests on cultivated character and proper relationships. Key ideas include ren (humaneness), li (ritual propriety), and filial piety, respect for parents and elders. The Analects, compiled by his followers, records his sayings, including a version of the principle 'do not impose on others what you yourself do not desire'.
Daoism and other Chinese schools
The Daodejing, attributed to Laozi, and the writings of Zhuangzi describe the Dao, the 'way' underlying nature, and recommend wu wei, effortless action in harmony with it. Mohists argued for impartial care for all; Legalists for strict laws and strong rulers; and Mencius and Xunzi debated whether human nature is basically good or must be shaped by education and ritual.
Indigenous and African thought
Many Indigenous and African traditions transmitted philosophy orally through stories, proverbs, and practices. Ubuntu, from southern Africa, expresses the idea that 'a person is a person through other persons', emphasising community and relationship. Many Indigenous philosophies of the Americas and Australia stress kinship with land and the responsibilities that relationship creates.
Worked example
Compare views of the self. The Upanishads suggest a deep self identical with ultimate reality; Buddhism denies any permanent self, seeing a stream of changing processes; Confucianism understands the self through roles and relationships; ubuntu defines personhood through community. Each view supports different practices: meditation on the self, letting go of attachment, cultivating roles, or strengthening communal bonds.
Key takeaways
Philosophy emerged in several regions, sometimes grouped as the Axial Age (about 800 to 200 BCE). The Upanishads link atman and Brahman. The Buddha's Four Noble Truths, Eightfold Path, and doctrine of no-self, developed by thinkers like Nagarjuna, offer rigorous analysis. Nyaya studied valid knowledge; Jains taught many-sidedness. Confucius stressed humaneness, ritual, and relationships; Daoists the Dao and wu wei; Mohists, Legalists, Mencius, and Xunzi debated ethics and human nature. Ubuntu and Indigenous philosophies emphasise community and relationship with land.
Flashcard
About 800 to 200 BCE in Jaspers' account
Check your understanding
Which concept from Buddhist philosophy denies that there is a permanent, unchanging self?
