Justification: foundations, coherence, and reliability
What makes a belief justified? Philosophers have offered competing pictures: a building on firm foundations, a web of mutually supporting beliefs, or a product of reliable processes.
The regress problem
If every justified belief must be justified by another belief, we face a regress: that belief needs justifying, and so on. Justification seems to go on forever, circle back on itself, or stop somewhere. Each option corresponds to a theory: infinitism, coherentism, or foundationalism. Ancient skeptics such as Agrippa used this problem to argue that no belief is justified.
Foundationalism
Foundationalists hold that some basic beliefs are justified without depending on other beliefs, and all other justified beliefs rest on them. Classical foundationalists, such as Descartes, required foundations to be certain, such as 'I think' or reports of immediate experience. Modest foundationalists allow basic beliefs, such as ordinary perceptual beliefs, that are justified but fallible.
Coherentism
Coherentists deny that any belief is basic. Instead, beliefs are justified by fitting together in a coherent system, consistent, mutually supporting, and explanatory. Otto Neurath compared knowledge to a ship we must rebuild at sea, plank by plank, without ever standing on dry land. The objection is that a coherent web could be entirely detached from reality, like a well-written novel.
Internalism and externalism
Internalists hold that what justifies a belief must be accessible to the believer by reflection: their evidence, reasons, or experiences. Externalists hold that justification can depend on factors the believer may not be aware of, such as whether the process that produced the belief is reliable. The debate concerns whether justification is about being responsible or about being connected to truth.
Reliabilism
Alvin Goldman's reliabilism holds that a belief is justified if it was produced by a reliable process, one that tends to produce true beliefs, such as normal vision in good light, memory, or careful reasoning. Wishful thinking and guessing are unreliable. Reliabilism explains why children and animals can have justified beliefs without being able to give reasons.
Problems for reliabilism
Critics raise the 'new evil demon' problem: a person deceived by a demon, with experiences identical to ours, seems just as justified as we are, even though their processes are unreliable. There is also the generality problem: any belief-forming process can be described more or less broadly, and reliability depends on which description is chosen.
Virtue epistemology
Virtue epistemologists, such as Ernest Sosa and Linda Zagzebski, focus on the knower's intellectual virtues: faculties such as good perception and memory, and character traits such as open-mindedness, intellectual courage, and carefulness. Knowledge is true belief arising from intellectual virtue, success because of ability, as an archer's shot hits because of skill rather than a lucky gust of wind.
Worked example
Why are you justified in believing there is a cup on the table? A foundationalist says your perceptual experience directly justifies it. A coherentist says it fits with your other beliefs about the room, your eyesight, and so on. A reliabilist says your vision in good light is reliable. A virtue epistemologist says your belief comes from competent perception. Each theory explains the same ordinary case differently, but they come apart in unusual cases.
Key takeaways
The regress problem asks how chains of justification end: forever (infinitism), in circles (coherentism), or in foundations (foundationalism). Classical foundationalism demands certain foundations; modest foundationalism allows fallible ones such as perception. Coherentism justifies beliefs by systematic fit, like Neurath's ship, but risks detachment from reality. Internalists require justifiers accessible to the believer; externalists do not. Goldman's reliabilism ties justification to reliable processes but faces the new evil demon and generality problems. Virtue epistemology grounds knowledge in intellectual virtues and abilities.
Flashcard
Justifying beliefs seems to require endless chains
Check your understanding
According to reliabilism, what makes a belief justified?
