Skepticism and knowledge in society
Skeptics argue that we know far less than we think, perhaps nothing at all about the outside world. Answering them, and understanding how knowledge depends on others, are central tasks of epistemology.
Descartes' method of doubt
In his Meditations (1641), Rene Descartes resolved to doubt everything that could possibly be doubted, to find a certain foundation. Senses sometimes deceive; we might be dreaming; and an all-powerful evil demon might deceive us even about mathematics. He found one certainty: 'I think, therefore I am' (cogito ergo sum), since even being deceived requires that he exists.
The brain in a vat
A modern version imagines that you are a brain in a vat, connected to a computer that feeds you experiences identical to normal life. Since you cannot tell from the inside, how can you know you have hands? The skeptical argument: if you know you have hands, you know you are not a brain in a vat; you do not know that; so you do not know you have hands.
Responses to skepticism
G. E. Moore replied that he was more certain he had hands than of any skeptical premise, so the argument should run the other way. Contextualists hold that 'know' sets higher standards in skeptical conversations than in ordinary ones. Others challenge closure, the principle that knowledge extends to known consequences, and Hilary Putnam argued that a brain in a vat could not even think the thought 'I am a brain in a vat' with its usual meaning.
Hume's problem of induction
David Hume (1711 to 1776) argued that inductive reasoning, expecting the future to resemble the past, cannot be justified without circularity: any argument that induction works relies on induction itself. We expect the sun to rise tomorrow from habit, not from proof. Philosophers have offered pragmatic, probabilistic, and explanatory responses, but the problem remains influential.
Testimony
Most of what we know comes from others: teachers, books, experts, news, and friends. You probably know the distance to the Moon, your birth date, and that Antarctica exists by testimony. Reductionists say testimony is justified only when backed by our own evidence of reliability; anti-reductionists, following Thomas Reid, say we are entitled to trust others unless there is reason not to.
Expertise and trust
Societies divide cognitive labour: no one can check everything, so we rely on experts and institutions. Deciding whom to trust is itself an epistemic skill: considering track records, consensus among independent experts, conflicts of interest, and whether claims are open to checking. Misinformation exploits weaknesses in these judgements, and social media can create echo chambers in which only some voices are heard.
Social and feminist epistemology
Social epistemology studies knowledge as a collective achievement shaped by institutions and communities. Miranda Fricker's concept of epistemic injustice describes wrongs done to people as knowers: testimonial injustice occurs when prejudice leads listeners to give someone less credibility than they deserve, and hermeneutical injustice when people lack concepts to make sense of their experiences, as before the term 'sexual harassment' was widely used.
Worked example
Hume's problem applied: you have seen bread nourish people thousands of times and conclude the next loaf will nourish you. Why? Because nature has been uniform so far. But that assumes the future will resemble the past, the very thing in question. Hume concluded that the expectation rests on custom. Most philosophers accept induction anyway, but explaining why it is rational remains a deep puzzle.
Key takeaways
Descartes' Meditations (1641) doubted everything possible, reaching the certain 'I think, therefore I am'. The brain-in-a-vat argument challenges knowledge of the external world. Moore, contextualists, closure critics, and Putnam offer responses. Hume showed induction cannot be justified without circularity, resting on habit. Much knowledge comes from testimony; reductionists require independent checks, while Reid-style anti-reductionists allow default trust. Societies divide cognitive labour, making judgements of expertise crucial. Social epistemology and Fricker's epistemic injustice examine how knowledge depends on communities and fairness.
Flashcard
Doubt everything possible to find certainty
Check your understanding
Why did Descartes regard 'I think, therefore I am' as certain?
