What exists? Substance, universals, and particulars
Metaphysics asks what the world is ultimately made of and how its parts relate. Debates about substances, properties, and identity sound abstract, but they shape how we think about everything else.
What metaphysics studies
Metaphysics investigates the most general features of reality: what kinds of things exist (ontology), what it is for something to be the same thing over time, the nature of causation, space, time, possibility, and necessity. The name comes from the editors of Aristotle's works, who placed his writings on 'first philosophy' after (meta) his Physics.
Substance
A substance, in traditional metaphysics, is something that exists in its own right and bears properties, such as a particular tree or person, as opposed to a property, such as greenness, that exists only in something else. Aristotle treated individual organisms as primary substances; Descartes distinguished mind and matter as two kinds of substance; Spinoza argued there is only one substance, God or Nature.
The problem of universals
Two red apples share something: redness. Is redness a real thing, a universal, wholly present in many places at once? Realists, following Plato or Aristotle, say yes. Nominalists say only particular things exist, and 'red' is just a word or a grouping we apply. Trope theorists say each apple has its own particular redness, and the two rednesses merely resemble each other.
Abstract objects
Numbers, propositions, and sets seem to exist without being anywhere or causing anything. Platonists about mathematics hold that the number 7 exists independently of minds; nominalists and fictionalists treat mathematical talk as useful without committing to abstract objects. The debate matters because mathematics is indispensable to science, which some argue gives reason to believe in mathematical objects.
Identity and change
How can something change yet remain the same thing? The ship of Theseus, recorded by Plutarch, has its planks replaced one by one until none of the originals remain; if the old planks are reassembled, which ship is Theseus's? Answers distinguish qualitative identity (being exactly alike) from numerical identity (being one and the same thing) and debate whether identity follows matter, form, or continuity.
Persistence through time
Endurantists hold that objects are wholly present at each moment they exist, persisting through time by enduring. Perdurantists hold that objects are spread out in time like in space, with temporal parts, so you are a four-dimensional 'worm' whose parts at different times have different properties. Each view handles puzzles of change and identity differently.
Possibility and necessity
Metaphysics also studies modality: what could have been and what must be. Something is necessary if it could not have been otherwise, like 2 + 2 = 4, and contingent if it could have been different, like your eye colour. Philosophers such as David Lewis and Saul Kripke analysed modal talk using possible worlds, ways things could have been, debating whether such worlds are real or useful fictions.
Worked example
Suppose a statue is made from a lump of clay. If the statue is squashed, the statue is destroyed but the clay survives; so the statue and the lump seem to have different properties and must be different things. Yet they occupy the same place and are made of the same matter. Is there one object or two? Responses include denying statues exist, accepting coinciding objects, or treating identity as relative to a sortal like 'statue' or 'lump'.
Key takeaways
Metaphysics studies the most general features of reality, including ontology, identity, causation, time, and modality; the name comes from editors placing Aristotle's work after his Physics. Substances bear properties; Aristotle, Descartes, and Spinoza disagreed about them. Realists, nominalists, and trope theorists answer the problem of universals differently. Platonists and nominalists debate abstract objects such as numbers. The ship of Theseus separates qualitative from numerical identity. Endurantism and perdurantism explain persistence. Necessity and contingency are analysed with possible worlds by Lewis and Kripke.
Flashcard
Study of the general nature of reality
Check your understanding
In the ship of Theseus puzzle, which distinction helps most?
