Theories of justice: Rawls, Nozick, and beyond
What would a just society look like? John Rawls and Robert Nozick gave influential and opposing answers, and later thinkers have added new perspectives.
Rawls and the original position
John Rawls's A Theory of Justice (1971) asks what principles people would choose behind a 'veil of ignorance', not knowing their own sex, race, class, talents, or conception of the good life. Because no one could tailor principles to their own advantage, the choice would be fair. Rawls called this 'justice as fairness'.
Rawls's two principles
Rawls argued people would choose two principles. First, each person has an equal right to the most extensive basic liberties compatible with similar liberties for all. Second, social and economic inequalities are acceptable only if they are attached to positions open to all under fair equality of opportunity, and if they benefit the least advantaged members of society: the difference principle.
The difference principle
The difference principle allows inequality, such as higher pay for doctors, only when it improves the position of the worst off, for example by encouraging training that benefits everyone. Rawls argued that natural talents are morally arbitrary, a matter of luck, so no one deserves greater rewards merely for being born gifted; the benefits of talent should be shared.
Nozick's entitlement theory
Robert Nozick's Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974) argued that justice concerns how holdings came about, not their pattern. A distribution is just if it arose from just acquisition and just transfer, with rectification of past injustice. His Wilt Chamberlain example: if fans freely pay to watch a basketball star, the resulting inequality is just, and redistributing it would interfere with liberty.
The minimal state
Nozick defended a minimal state limited to protecting against force, theft, and fraud and enforcing contracts. He argued that taxation of earnings for redistribution is 'on a par with forced labour', since it takes the products of people's work. Critics respond that property rights themselves depend on social institutions, and that historical injustices taint many current holdings.
Capabilities and other views
Amartya Sen and Martha Nussbaum developed the capabilities approach: justice should be measured by what people are actually able to do and be, such as being healthy, educated, and able to participate politically, rather than by resources or happiness alone. This approach influenced the United Nations Human Development Index. Luck egalitarians, such as Ronald Dworkin, distinguish inequalities from choices from those from brute luck.
Communitarian and global critiques
Communitarians, such as Michael Sandel, objected that Rawls's veil of ignorance assumes an 'unencumbered self' detached from the communities and traditions that shape people. Cosmopolitans, such as Thomas Pogge, argued that Rawlsian principles should apply globally, not just within nations, while Rawls himself, in The Law of Peoples, proposed more limited international duties.
Worked example
Two societies: in A, everyone earns 40,000; in B, the poorest earn 50,000 and others earn far more. Strict equality prefers A. Rawls's difference principle prefers B, because its worst off are better off. Nozick asks only whether B's holdings arose through just acquisition and transfer; if they did, B is just regardless of pattern. A capabilities theorist asks what people in each society can actually do, beyond income.
Key takeaways
Rawls's A Theory of Justice (1971) chooses principles behind a veil of ignorance: justice as fairness. His principles give equal basic liberties and allow inequalities only with fair equality of opportunity and when they benefit the least advantaged, the difference principle, since talent is morally arbitrary. Nozick's Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974) judges distributions by just acquisition, transfer, and rectification, illustrated by Wilt Chamberlain, and defends a minimal state. Sen and Nussbaum's capabilities approach and Dworkin's luck egalitarianism offer alternatives; communitarians and cosmopolitans criticise Rawls.
Flashcard
Choosing principles without knowing one's position
Check your understanding
Behind Rawls's veil of ignorance, what do people NOT know?
