Arguments: premises, conclusions, and validity
Arguments are the basic tool of philosophy. Learning to identify premises and conclusions, and to judge whether an argument is valid and sound, is the foundation of clear thinking.
What an argument is
In philosophy, an argument is not a quarrel but a set of statements in which some, the premises, are offered as reasons to accept another, the conclusion. Indicator words help: 'because', 'since', and 'given that' often signal premises; 'therefore', 'so', and 'hence' often signal conclusions. Many arguments have unstated premises that must be spelled out to evaluate them.
Deductive validity
A deductive argument is valid if it is impossible for all its premises to be true while its conclusion is false: the conclusion follows necessarily. Validity concerns form, not truth. 'All fish can fly; salmon are fish; so salmon can fly' is valid, because if the premises were true the conclusion would have to be, even though the first premise is false.
Soundness
A sound argument is valid and has all true premises, so its conclusion must be true. To criticise a valid argument, you must reject at least one premise; to criticise an invalid one, you can point out that the conclusion does not follow even if the premises are granted. Separating these two kinds of criticism prevents a lot of confused debate.
Valid forms
Some forms are always valid. Modus ponens: if P then Q; P; therefore Q. Modus tollens: if P then Q; not Q; therefore not P. Hypothetical syllogism: if P then Q; if Q then R; therefore if P then R. Disjunctive syllogism: P or Q; not P; therefore Q. Recognising these patterns makes arguments much easier to assess.
Invalid forms
Two common invalid forms look similar to valid ones. Affirming the consequent: if P then Q; Q; therefore P. If it rained the street is wet; the street is wet; so it rained, ignoring street cleaners. Denying the antecedent: if P then Q; not P; therefore not Q. Spotting these fallacies is a key critical-thinking skill.
Inductive arguments
Inductive arguments aim to make conclusions probable rather than certain: generalising from samples, reasoning from analogy, or inferring causes. They are judged as strong or weak, and a strong inductive argument with true premises is called cogent. Most scientific and everyday reasoning is inductive, which is why new evidence can overturn conclusions.
Abductive reasoning
Inference to the best explanation, or abduction, reasons from evidence to the hypothesis that would best explain it, weighing simplicity, scope, and fit with other knowledge. Detectives, doctors, and scientists reason this way. A wet street, dark clouds, and people with umbrellas together make rain the best explanation, even though other explanations remain possible.
Worked example
Argument: 'If the universe had a beginning, it had a cause. The universe had a beginning. Therefore it had a cause.' This is modus ponens, so it is valid. Whether it is sound depends on the premises: is it true that everything with a beginning has a cause, and did the universe have a beginning in the relevant sense? Critics accept the form but challenge the premises, which is exactly where debate about this argument has focused.
Key takeaways
An argument offers premises as reasons for a conclusion; indicator words and unstated premises matter. Deductive validity means the premises cannot all be true while the conclusion is false; it depends on form, not truth. Sound arguments are valid with true premises. Modus ponens, modus tollens, hypothetical syllogism, and disjunctive syllogism are valid; affirming the consequent and denying the antecedent are invalid. Inductive arguments are strong or weak, and cogent when strong with true premises. Abduction infers the best explanation.
Flashcard
Premises offered as reasons for a conclusion
Check your understanding
'If it is a dog, it is a mammal. Rex is a mammal. So Rex is a dog.' What is wrong with this argument?
